La Rochelle a trop gâché face au Leinster

Faster! Faster!

Good idea 👍

I would really like to see all conversions and penalty kicks at goals being reduced to 15 seconds, that is get rid of the kicking tee and make them all drop goals, 7s style. That way teams will be forced to play more instead of these 60 meters penalties.

I expect another 70% season in 2025. A perfectly respectable outcome in a year where boldness in selections and blooding new talent is vital.

Razor went for respectable and safe in 2024. Build a relatively solid foundation. Albeit a boring one with more questions than answers. But he has to take a few chances in selections in 2025 or stick around 70% with the current crop to 2027 AND miss a World Cup medal.

The question is whether the NZ public can live with another 70% season whilst Razor and his 7 assistant coaches get their feet properly under their desks. I suspect they will accept 70% if they see innovation. And I suspect they won’t accept 70% if they don’t and it’s more of the same.

But indeed DMac is the best 10 NZ has got. Can’t argue that.

I genuinely am concerned about messing with the most unique part of Rugby Union.

I don’t really see what the issue is with teams scrumming for penalties - but I take the point about refs being under pressure and making the wrong call.

I mean putting 16 forwards into a meat grinder for a knock-on or forward pass seems a bit harsh too!

But winning a penalty/penalty advantage encourages the attacking team to have a crack at it with space when a free kick turns the whole thing into a ruck.and all 8 forwards standing in a line ready to receive you. Unless it’s a quick tap which it rarely is.

The penalty also gives teams a reason to kick for territory and set up an attacking lineout. Which means more tries.

I also don’t get why scrums should be a deterrent to gaining “new fans”. Perhaps the drama and mystique (including the time wasted) setting up and engaging in scrums should be emphasized over the shrill complaining about how slow the game is. Why put down as a negative something that is great albeit an acquired taste? Market the scrum. Don’t change it.

Has anyone watched American sports? Built in boredom which Rugby is far from if we’re close to 40mins in play time!

Stopping the clock during resets makes perfect sense. As for the rest. Leave the scrum alone please.

A pet hate of mine is how some English refs (not Luke Pearce or Matt Carley funnily enough) will say "use it or reset" if the scrum has gone down despite the ball successfully making its way to the feet of the #8. Under no circumstances should that ever lead to a reset.

I think the main thrust by far ought to be the need to devalue resets and remove the pressure on the ref to make decision when he probably doesn't want to. Stopping the clock during the reset process and only starting it again on the new 'Crouch' command achieves that aim.

I don't like the assistant ref participating in scrum reffing. They are a long way away and they may not be on the same page as the main official, leading to even more pens!

LaRoche were missing a few but so were Leinster with the backline also completely reshuffled during the week. When the game was only 6-3 to LaRoche and Leinster scored a neat try it looked like they would strike again. Nowell's block to stop a 3 on 1 and certain try was surely worth a yellow. If Leinster score before H/T they go in 16-6 and I felt a bonus point was available. LaRoche succeeded in making it a dogfight but this time they discovered Leinster had more dog in them. LaRoche have won all the big home games including Toulon, Bordeaux and Toulouse. (A weak Toulouse team but in the away match LaTocje got within one score in Toulouse.

If remaining matches go as expected then Bordeaux will be overall #1 seed and Leinster will be #2 with both having home matches until the final. Toulouse sent the big guns to get a bonus point with against Sharks but they failed. They will likely finish second in their group with a #5 seeding and have away matches after the round of 16.

Toulouse likely away to eg Northhampton in QF and would play Bordeaux away should they make a semi final. Leinster would likely play Toulon/LaRoche in a semi in Dublin.

The accepted version of 'not being able to see past Toulouse' might need revising particularly as Bordeaux scored 69 against Exeter.

if its a toss up between Isiekwe, Coles, and Kpoku for a world cup place, but Isiekwe and Coles both have 20 caps and have trained with the squad for multiple consecutive campaigns, and Kpoku hasn't, club form might not be deciding factor for Borthwick (nor should it be!)