Édition du Nord
Select Edition
Nord Nord
Sud Sud
Mondial Mondial
Nouvelle Zélande Nouvelle Zélande
France France

Salary cap : Toulon a saisi le Conseil d'État

Le président du RC Toulon Bernard Lemaitre juge l'amende « injustifiée et disproportionnée », infligée pour son manque de transparence sur le plafond salarial (Photo by GERARD JULIEN/AFP via Getty Images).

Avec AFP

Le Rugby Club Toulonnais, récemment condamné à une amende pour son manque de transparence sur le plafond salarial (‘salary cap’), a saisi lundi le Conseil d’État pour « obtenir des clarifications sur sa réglementation et ses modalités d’application », a déclaré le président Bernard Lemaître à l’AFP.

ADVERTISEMENT

« Nous estimons que certaines décisions sont arbitraires et nécessitent un cadre légal plus transparent et équitable », a-t-il estimé, souhaitant « éviter toute interprétation arbitraire » du règlement qui limite la masse salariale des clubs de Top 14.

En juin, le RCT avait été sanctionné d’une amende de 500 000 euros par la Commission de discipline et des règlements de la Ligue nationale de rugby (LNR) pour son manque de transparence et de coopération lors de la saison 2022-2023.

La sanction a été ramenée à 300 000 euros, dont 200 000 euros avec sursis, par la commission d’appel de la Fédération française de rugby (FFR), une amende toujours « injustifiée et disproportionnée » aux yeux du patron du RCT, qui assure n’avoir toujours pas reçu la motivation de la décision de la LNR.

Le RC Toulon affirme n’avoir pas dépassé le plafond du salary cap

Le président de l’équipe varoise, qui a précisé ne pas remettre en cause le système du plafond salarial mais seulement son application, a également affirmé que son club n’avait en aucun cas dépassé le plafond.

« Le plafonnement des salaires pour garantir une certaine équité entre les clubs est, sur le principe, une bonne chose », explique Lemaître, à la tête du RCT depuis février 2020.

« Ce que nous demandons, c’est que les règles soient appliquées de manière uniforme, transparente et que les clubs sachent à quoi s’en tenir afin d’assurer une prévisibilité et une sécurité juridique ».

Dans le viseur du RCT : « La concentration des pouvoirs au sein de la LNR, et notamment entre les mains du ‘salary cap manager’, pose problème et nécessite une révision ».

ADVERTISEMENT

En 2019, le président de Montpellier Mohed Altrad avait également déposé une requête contre le plafond salarial devant le Conseil d’État, qui n’avait pas abouti.

Une situation qui n’est pas comparable à la requête du RCT, d’après Bernard Lemaître. « Cette dernière concernait une question prioritaire de constitutionnalité sur le principe même du ‘salary cap’. Notre recours ne remet pas en cause ce principe », assure-t-il.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video

South Africa vs Black Ferns XV | Women's International | Full Match Replay

Play Video

England vs Spain | Women's International | Full Match Replay

Play Video

Classic Wallabies vs British & Irish Legends | Second Match | Full Match Replay

Play Video

Ireland vs Scotland | Women's International | Full Match Replay

Play Video

Should the Lions’ last-minute try have stood? | Whistle Watch

Play Video

Lions Share | Episode 6

Play Video

KOKO Show | July 29th | George Gregan Stops by to lift spirits after the MCG Madness

Play Video

Historic Lions Series win at the MCG | Ep 7: The Ultimate Test

Trending on RugbyPass

Commentaires

0 Comments
Soyez le premier à commenter...

Inscrivez-vous gratuitement et dites-nous ce que vous en pensez vraiment !

Inscription gratuite
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

H
Hellhound 19 minutes ago
'The success of Skelton, Hooper and Tupou should trigger a rethink on Australia’s overseas selection criteria'

While that may have been true in the past, a lot have changed and still is. While SA have more players, it doesn't mean they are better players. What makes them better players, is competing against some of the world's best internationals at club level, so by the time they themselves get to the international stage, they already know those players strengths and weaknesses. They may be uncapped, but they have already faced international stars multiple times by then, making them more mature and streetwise. Those experiences benefits the Boks massively. NZRU doesn't have the money to develop more and better players. While they might look good in SR, they are not ready to face the best in the world and that holds the AB's back. By allowing SA players to leave and play for other clubs world wide, they allow those players to be developed at no cost by others as SARU don't have the money to develop stars. Rugby have changed. Laws have changed. Everything is changing and if NZ don't, they may fall further behind. Once the most feared team, that statistic is merely a relic of the past and you will never see that amount of fear again. Teams don't fear the AB's anymore. They just see the AB's as “one” of the best and a very tough Test, but not invincible. Most Tier 1 nations is confident they can beat the AB's. Unlike others, I don't believe that the AB's went through a bad stage. They went through a transitional period as very team do. The other nations just caught up and is starting to surpass them. The Boks are the most feared team now, but they are definitely not invincible not undefeatable. However, a team need to bring a near flawless game plan to beat them. The Boks ability to win most games on “sleep mode”, not even getting out of 2nd gear, is what teams fear. Once the Boks start shifting gears, the game become almost impossible to beat them. However, it can be done. By the top 6 anyone can beat anyone.

328 Go to comments
H
Hellhound 1 hour ago
New Zealand just needs to look at the NPC to change eligibility laws

Yeah that changed the game so much badly for the Boks. Don't be glib. It's exactly because of that eligibility changes that the Boks became the double WC champs and the best in the world. They can actually choose the best players to play for the Boks, no matter where they are plying their trade. That's why they are 4 deep in every position talent wise. Besides that, it allows the players to grow and learn and become better under different coaches. It allows them to earn a lot of money and make rugby a professional career without having to worry how they are going to pay for their houses and families and debt worries etc. Everything they learn, they bring back to SA, helping the younger generation grow and learn. It's why Rassie is miles ahead of every other coach. As much as players want to play for their country, guess what? They will always put family first. That is why the players will go where who ever pays them the most. SA can't afford their Bok stars, but other clubs world wide can and they employ those stars. They get small change from SARU compared to what clubs and endorsement deals pay them. The players that plays for the Boks do it out of national pride and they play for more than just money. It's why they are the best. It's why they don't have a best player in each position. It's why it's a team effort and all players but into that ideology. It's why the Boks are so successful. Look at the RFU in England. Look at Wales and others. Always the same problems. Money. Players leaving because of funds not caring if that affects their eligibility to play for their country. SA is currently getting raided for its talent. Not just some of the older players, but especially the young stars. Eligibility is strangling careers of players. Especially those who wants to play for their country as they are stuck earning peanuts. With SA, these players earn Mega. Why? They are not restricted by where they play. The Currie Cup is a small competition that doesn't have space for more players. In the world of rugby however, there is thousand of clubs where they can go ahead and make a name for themselves. Instead of being stuck behind a player for years and effectively destroying their own chances of representing their country. There is so many Bok players who was never in the Bok planning. That wasn't even known. Players who made a name for themselves elsewhere and became Boks where they never would have. Eligibility is only hurting the players and once they realise that, they always leave for green pastures despite it costing them a possible Test cap.

20 Go to comments
H
Hellhound 1 hour ago
'We struggled': Ex-All Black first five backs Springboks to end Eden Park streak

Blah blah blah. The Boks is 4 deep in every position and no top players in any position. Age won't be a problem. Neither will the Boks be a weak run over. Arrogance and over estimation of current AB's players is what is going to make the AB's go down 2-0 again. Clearly not having watched the Boks closely since the WC in 2023, you have missed the amount of players that's been used. The depth that has been build. It was all over the news and still is. Just by taking out 5 players alone, the Boks age grade drops by at least 2-3 years. By the next WC, they will already be more experienced than most players in other teams, including the AB's. This AB's team is good, but definitely not great and can barely beat a C team French. There is many good players in NZ, but very little depth. Despite SA losing so much talent to other countries, the wheels keep churning out absolute stars, and the sad thing is that many will be lost to the Boks due to other great stars already filling those positions, with other young great stars backing them up. The Boks have so many players in every position,they can employ any strategy they wish and still beat all comers. Can the AB's or other teams do that? No team is undefeatable, not even the Boks. However, unless the Boks lose deliberately or another team bring nothing but their A game and a near flawless game plan, they will lose. As usual these 2 Tests between them will be absolutely great and very very close. When it comes to the Boks vs AB's, ranking doesn't matter. Experience doesn't matter. Nothing matters except the game. Neither ever wants to lose against each other. Every game is like a WC final. But to write of the double WC champs as old? Players who have beaten the AB's 4 games in a row? Players who have won the last WC by 1 point each in the knockouts? Players who knows how to bend but not break in the toughest and tightest games? That knows how to win? Take off the blinders, judge not by emotion, but by logic and common sense. Stats. Facts. Performance. Skill. Everyone wants their team to win and that is a great thing. You and everyone wants to talk about the Georgians and Italy as no contest and the Boks going into the RC as “under cooked”. The Boks never moved out of 2nd gear, experimenting, changing of complete game plans, almost complete team changes, without losing a step. Absolutely destroying these weak teams. Something this AB's side couldn't do to a weak C French team. Last year the Boks used 55 players, and so far used 49 ( would be more if not for injuries ) this year, with the RC still to come, and the EOYT. Last year the Boks only lost 2 tests by 1 point each with these same so called “OLD” players. What's going to be the excuse when the AB's lose against these “OLD” players? The ref again? Or Rassie's innovative experiments? Do not be glib or blind. Show respect where it's due and respect the opposition and what they have achieved. Don't like the current narrative where more and more pundits calls this Bok team to be the best ever team? Better than the AB's of 2011-2015? To me, this is a different time, different players. I don't like to compare teams unless they are the same era. Then that team was the best. Currently it is the Boks. Should the Boks make it a triple WC crown, they would arguably be seen as the best ever team. That argument of the best team ever will carry on until the end of the 2027 WC. Currently this AB team have great potential with tweaks here and there, and with Mouanga back in the frame, it's a big step up. No win is guaranteed. Overhyping players and games does no good for the players on the field, just adding extra pressure that will lead to individual mistakes on the field that will cost a team a game.

4 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Scott Robertson explains 'hugely challenging' five-halfback situation Scott Robertson explains five-halfback situation