UBB - Toulouse : la composition des équipes

Well, I would disagree with your take that you don’t take the piss out of the opposition. Sledging is very much a part of the game - “four more years”/"just a shit richie mccaw”/any swan dive celebration/wit kant commentary/English yelling when they win minor penalties/etc etc. Cricket has much the same when a wicket keeper chats shit in a batsman’s ears, but no one complains about it. Just because we can’t hear what goes on a ruck or maul, or see what goes on, doesn’t mean it doesn’t go on. Sport is emotional and so is taking the piss. Let’s not pretend that rugby has a history of behaving like absolute gentleman before the final whistle goes off.

The spirit of rugby…now this is an interesting one. What does that mean? 2-3 years ago, the 6-2/7-1 split was against the spirit of rugby, but now it is used by club and country. Does this mean the spirit of rugby can change? In 1974, the Lions had an infamous Call 99. Today, teams are still getting into fights. Other sports don’t do this. Is this the spirit of rugby? I think this phrase is one of those useful ones that means everything and nothing and can be used by both sides of the fence, as well as the fence itself, to justify what they want to see. But perhaps we should not be looking at Pollock, but at ourselves. Are we (the rugby public) all not giving a self-described wind up merchant exactly what he wants? Are we not the problem here? I think this conservative group of sports fans needs to realise that just bc they have viewed rugby a certain way for a long time, does not mean that it necessarily needs to be viewed that way for ever and ever amen. That’s gatekeeping and the generations to come don’t like or respect it, not to mention valuable markets that have different values. As rugby culture breaks into new markets, it needs to constantly adjust.

A far more constructive way to resolve this issue, I would argue, is to regulate behaviour. Football players get carded for removing their shirts, why not introduce a similar mechanism? Of course, there would be an adjustment period and probably more polemics, but regulation, law tinkering, and adjustment, is what makes rugby rugby. (Is this the spirit of rugby?) Or, and I would personally prefer this option, we let the kid play. He’s not hurting anyone other than people who want to be hurt.

If a penalty try was awarded and Leinster went on to win the final the same way, they’d be immortals. Free haircuts for life. The style of play wouldn’t have been any different just the margins by which it’s success is measured.

Frawley’s narrowly missed drop goal at the death last final. Could have won as easily as they lost without a style being found out.

The governance of the Welsh and Irish unions is not comparable. On any level.

On one hand talking about expanding for commercial reasons, but then saying younger squad members would play giving big names a rest making it more for development purposes?

The problem with SRP is it serves two masters - fans who want a good competition to watch, but also the national teams in developing players so they can go on to become international players.

The case for maximising young player development:

A major problem NZ and Australia have is at U20s. AR and NZR would be best served by investing in proper U20 super rugby competition that runs in conjunction with Super Rugby, rather than the one-off carnival style thing that happens at the moment. 20 year olds coming out of France and England in particular, but also France are noticeably more developed than the equivalent players from NZ, Australia and even SA.

NZ and Australia probably both have one too many teams in SR. If you’re taking a long term view they are best served by cutting teams from the comp now and improving the quality even more. Although MP have been good this year there is also an argument for cutting them too, and reducing to 8 teams that all play each other home and away in a round robin. It would be a ridiculously strong competition with a lot of depth if all the best players are redistributed.

This in conjunction with a full U20s competition (possibly playing just one round rather than 2) would make NZ and Australia international teams much stronger with a lot more depth.

But that solution would make less money and cost more.

NPC would need to be fully amateur or semi-pro at best in this model. If you cross reference the losses NZR posted today with the costs they have previously published about operating the NPC, you can attribute a huge amount, if not all of the losses, to the NPC. At the moment this is putting way too much money into a failing high performance competition at the expense of development.

He looked over to the stands again.

What about that other Lions story? The one were O’Driscoll battered the head off ya to the delight of everyone in camp?

Knee, hip, collarbone and concussion all across just a couple of seasons.

Slightly harsh on Michalak. I always thought it’s only the Kiwis of a certain age that didn’t like him. And only on the back of one game.

I think world rugby was more complicit than the French media in building up Chabal. They always encouraged his ‘lead with the head’ style of play which has only given him progressive brain damage.

I’d be more concerned with the English press re: Pollock than the French. They only get built up in order to knock them down.

Looks a handy player all the same.

Meanwhile, Rassie recently admitted that he never has one-on-one with players because a knowledge of their personal lives might cloud his judgement in terms of selection. I think someone like Sacha probably needs an environment where he can be himself on the field but will be reigned in if he puts himself before the team. He'll have that at the Boks. Not sure he has that at the Stormers.

Leinster still bombed it. Completely. No leadership on the Pitch. It proves that Sexton’s greatest strength was mental. They were up when he departed the 21'/22 final at 62 mins. Sat out the 22/23 final when they bombed a 17-nil start. Not around 23/24.

And to think that Leinster has been 4/4 in finals at one point.

And don’t forget to add teams from Super Rugby South America too.

It showed.