Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

42-cap All Black calls for an end to 'overused' haka

New Zealand perform the haka head of pool clash with Canada. (Photo by Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)

NZ Herald / Christopher Reive

ADVERTISEMENT

Former All Black Joe Karam believes it’s time for the team to take a page out of the history books when it comes to the haka.

In the lead up to the All Blacks‘ semifinal loss against England last week, the haka was a significant point of discussion among local and foreign media alike.

The pre-game haka has become synonymous with the All Blacks, however there was a time when it was reserved for special occasions. Usually performed ahead of the team’s last match of a tour, the haka wasn’t performed in New Zealand until 1975.

Karam, who played 42 games (10 tests) for the All Blacks from 1972-75, said he would like to see it go back to a similar system.

Video Spacer

“This is not meant with any disrespect to the haka or anything to do with M?oridom; it’s simply that I think the overuse has made it banal and, to some extent, embarrassing in a way – as though the whole of New Zealand is living for the haka when really we’re not, we’re living to watch the All Blacks play a game,” Karam said.

“It’s become a PR, branding, money-making exercise as opposed to something which could add much more value if it was treated respectfully for particular occasions which could be the last game of a tour or perhaps the first game of the year or whatever it might be. Now the focus of the All Blacks appears to almost be more on the haka; they must spend hours and hours practising.

ADVERTISEMENT

https://www.instagram.com/p/B4QAPI0FsBc/

“The general populous in New Zealand for, say, the last 30 years thinks that the haka is an integral, customary tradition of the All Blacks but until about 1980 the only time the haka was ever done by the All Blacks was on the last game of each tour they went on. It wasn’t ever done in New Zealand at all, (so) the customary tradition sort of thing is not really real; it’s not a part of All Blacks folklore, bearing in mind the All Blacks go back to 1905.”

In his three years with the All Blacks, Karam only performed the haka twice. He said performing it more reservedly would make fans and players cherish the experience more.

“If we had a special haka once a year or whatever, I think we’d really look forward to it and it would be something to treasure.”

This article first appeared on nzherald.co.nz and is republished with permission.

ADVERTISEMENT

World Rugby have faced criticism for fining England due to the way they reacted to the haka:

Video Spacer
ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

M
MA 3 hours ago
How the four-team format will help the Wallabies defeat the Lions

In regards to Mack Hansen, Tuipoloto and others who talent wasnt 'seen'..

If we look at acting, soccer and cricket as examples, Hugh Jackman, the Heminsworths in acting; Keith Urban in Nashville, Mike Hussey and various cricketers who played in UK and made the Australian team; and many soccer players playing overseas.


My opinion is that perhaps the ' 'potential' or latent talent is there, but it's just below the surface.


ANd that decision, as made by Tane Edmed, Noah, Will Skelton to go overseas is the catalyst to activate the latent and bring it to the surface.


Based on my personal experience of leaving Oz and spending 14 months o/s, I was fully away from home and all usual support systems and past memories that reminded me of the past.


Ooverseas, they weren't there. I had t o survive, I could invent myself as who I wanted, and there was no one to blame but me.


It bought me alive, focused my efforts towards what I wanted and people largely accepted me for who I was and how I turned up.


So my suggestion is to make overseas scholarships for younger players and older too so they can benefit from the value offered by overseas coaching acumen, established systems, higher intensity competition which like the pressure that turns coal into diamonds, can produce more Skeltons, Arnold's, Kellaways and the like.


After the Lion's tour say, create 20 x $10,000 scholarships for players to travel and play overseas.


Set up a HECS style arrangement if necessary to recycle these funds ongoingly.


Ooverseas travel, like parenthood or difficult life situations brings out people's physical and emotional strengths in my own experiences, let's use it in rugby.

68 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Money not everything in Toulouse ‘paradise’ as rivals try to rein in champions Money not everything in Toulouse ‘paradise’ as rivals try to rein in champions
Search