1
'Absolute disgrace' - Bok fans rage over Eben Etzebeth yellow
By Ian Cameron
They may have won the game, but Springboks’ supporters were left more than a little miffed after talismanic lock Eben Etzebeth was yellowed carded for pushing an obstructing player of his way.
ADVERTISEMENT
Etzebeth was sin-binned after pushing the Argentinian player out of the road as he advanced towards Emiliano Boffelli, who had jumped to claim a high ball.
Boffelli took a heavy fall, although replays showed that the Puma had collided with another Argentine player in the air which altered his trajectory downward, while it appeared that the player Etzebeth had shoved had little to do with the incident.
Referee Damon Murphy didn’t see it that way and gave Etzebeth his marching orders.
It was a decision that enraged many Bok fans and feeds into the greater narrative of referee incompetency that has been popular in South Africa since the British & Irish Lions tour in 2021.
Popular South African superfan Jared Wright observed: “I don’t agree with that. Eben has clearly pushed someone but his push did not result in Boffelli landing badly. I don’t know how they got to that decision.”
I don't agree with that.
Eben has clearly pushed someone but his push did not result in Boffelli landing badly.
I don't know how they got to that decison.#RSAvARG
— Jared Wright (@jaredwright17) September 24, 2022
Sports broadcaster Matt Pearce wrote: “Look forward to anyone in rugby officialdom being able to justify that yellow card for Eben Etzebeth. Hope it is removed from his record on review.”
Look forward to anyone in rugby officialdom being able to justify that yellow card for Eben Etzebeth. Hope it is removed from his record on review.
— Matt Pearce (@MattP555) September 24, 2022
ADVERTISEMENT
The Rugby Balrog wrote: “I really hate criticizing refs, but that card to Eben was one of the craziest calls I’ve ever seen. Carding a guy pushing an obstructing player? Wh… what?”
https://twitter.com/TheRugbyCat/status/1573720983332069376
“The officials have ruined Rugby Union. The Rugby Championship was decided by officials. Eben gets a yellow card for what? Pushing someone out of his way? World Rugby, your refusal to do anything about this is killing the game.”
The officials have ruined Rugby Union. The Rugby Championship was decided by officials. Eben gets a yellow card for what? Pushing someone out of his way? @WorldRugby your refusal to do anything about this is killing the game.
— Ngamla Gouws 🇿🇦 (@RenaldoGouws) September 24, 2022
Another account wrote: “Yellow to Etzebeth an absolute disgrace… Officials are cocking up the game of rugby. And turning people away from the game … It’s becoming very difficult to watch.”
Yellow to Etzebeth an absolute disgrace…. Officials are cocking up the game of rugby. And turning people away from the game … It's becoming very difficult to watch
— Front Row Grunt (@FrontRowGrunt) September 25, 2022
Dylan Jack wrote: “I cannot explain that yellow carding of Eben Etzebeth. Wish I could, but I can’t. Damon Murphy saw something everyone didn’t.”
ADVERTISEMENT
I cannot explain that yellow carding of Eben Etzebeth.
Wish I could, but I can't.
Damon Murphy saw something everyone didn't.— Dylan Jack (@dylmjack) September 24, 2022
South African journalist Brendan Nel took issue with the Australian referee’s overall performance, writing: “Damon Murphy was terrible today. Crucify me if you must as an internet troll. But any ref who gives 6 yellow cards, and 39 penalties doesn’t want a game to flow. This was supposed to be a spectacle. It was the opposite. And Murphy confused everyone. More than once.”
Nothing about the try Eben scored and was then disallowed because he was "offsides"? He caught the ball in the lineout, never let go of it and scored the try, don't see how he was ever offsides.
In my career as a ref I never had reason to award a penalty try nor heard of one - two in one half !! given for Boks pack tripping over themselves.