Adam Hastings one of four players called up by Scotland

It would be asking a huge amount from Les to lead Aussie into a WC with a 15-month runway, which is why I feel Joe has not quite let go yet!

Henshaw is done, Aki and Ringrose are first choice and have been for years. Henshaw cannot affect an 80 minute match anymore. If Irelands suffocating, multi-phase power game doesn’t work he doesn’t have the pace. Age has caught up with both him and Conan.

Keenan looked the fittest player in rugby two years ago, but in last years game v England and this weekend he looks well off the pace. Maybe a good break for him, especially after the Olympics, would be the best thing.

In saying that, not being picked for the Lions really helped Ireland in 2022 as Sexton, POM, JVDF, Ringrose, Lowe and Ryan had storming seasons if I remember rightly. Sexton in particular looked very fresh, leading to that series win in New Zealand. If those players were picked for the Lions would they have won that series? I am not sure.

England players suffered a lot in 2018 after the 2017 Lions, so while its nice to have your teams players get Lions recognition, it might not be the worse thing if they aren’t there either.

As you say both of Les’ teams at Irish and Queensland have tended to attack well but the output is uneven. Mistakes in specific areas can come in bunches, without correction - look at my previous pieces on the Reds’ lineout and exit strategy. They often do not change even when something is not working.

At risk of flattering the Reds/Wallabies too much, I fear they are at risk of potentially turning into a Scotland-esque team under LK - i.e., attack-oriented, great set plays - but lacking the killer physicality/X factor to beat the top teams?

This could well turn out to be right, let’s see!

I’d still take Saints over Bath with both on their best day Ed. Bath are good but they are not that good - c.f their result v Leinster compared to Saints.

Needs a season or two solely at club level to learn how to play the sportl as he struggles in almost every aspect of the game.

Shouldn’t be anywhere near the Irish squad, much less the Lions.

Can’t lace Crowley's boots at this stage and pretty much the sole reason Ireland lost the Grand Slam.

To be fair to him though - it is a common problem of the D4 player. Never as good as their thicko supporters tell you they are. They love to spew inordinate amounts of ignorant 💩 - much like the Saffas and the other SH thickos

Purely impressionistically (I do not have your data or powers of analysis NB!), the Reds under Kiss seem to have some of the attacking hallmarks of a JS coached team (i.e., attacking mindset, good set plays, seem to build a lot of attacking rucks?), but I fear they are lacking the discipline/control/mindset which JS seemed to be building with the Wallabies at the end of last year. I hope JS has enough time with the Wallabies, irrespective of his ongoing role, to instil that control/discipline before Kiss comes in.

At risk of flattering the Reds/Wallabies too much, I fear they are at risk of potentially turning into a Scotland-esque team under LK - i.e., attack-oriented, great set plays - but lacking the killer physicality/X factor to beat the top teams? IMO, Australia does not suffer from the same problem Scotland seems to - i.e., lacking the athletes to compete notwithstanding the team being a well-oiled machine. It would be a shame to see our physical ‘resources’ not used properly (e.g. Big will, Tupou, LSL, JAS, Bell, Bobbie V)