Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

All Blacks player ratings vs Argentina | The Rugby Championship

Ardie Savea of New Zealand is tackled during The Rugby Championship match between New Zealand All Blacks and Argentina at Eden Park on August 17, 2024 in Auckland, New Zealand. (Photo by Phil Walter/Getty Images)

The All Blacks have bounced back after a dominant first half to beat Argentina 42-10 at Eden Park in Auckland.

ADVERTISEMENT

After the shock loss last week, the All Blacks made an emphatic statement with a 35-3 first half scoreline rendering the game all-but-over.

The introduction of the All Blacks bench early in the second half disrupted the home side’s flow a bit and the two sides finished 7-all in the second half.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

Here’s how the All Blacks rated against Argentina at Eden Park:

1. Tamaiti Williams – 7
The scrum was totally dominant in the first half. The first two resulted in penalties to the All Blacks and the third nearly pushed the Pumas off their own ball. Had their way with Argentina at scrum time. The All Blacks came up with a crucial maul turnover on Argentina’s first trip inside the five. Penalised on a kick escort, was charged with two penalties conceded. Off at 53.

2. Codie Taylor – 8
First throw from the five metre was picked off going to the tail. Otherwise steady ann accurate with 11 from 12. Had a nice one-two play at the front of the lineout with Blackadder. Had six carries and seven tackles. Off at 51.

3. Tyrel Lomax – 7
Anchored a dominant scrum on the tighthead side. Good work rate from Lomax around the park with six tackles in the first half. Penalised for a no arms tackle leading to Argentina’s first three points. Off at 51.

4. Tupou Vaa’i – 9
One of Vaa’i’s best nights in a black jersey. Was the primary lineout option on the night and proved to be a very reliable option. Pressured Argentina’s lineout. Came up with a brilliant intercept after the ball was judged to be out of the ruck. The All Blacks scored on the next phase.

ADVERTISEMENT

5. Sam Darry – 7
Industrious work from Darry cleaning a lot of rucks in the first half. Wasn’t really used all that much at lineout time with the load spread around. Finished with three takes. Off at 54.

6. Ethan Blackadder – 7
A much better showing from Blackadder. Muscled up early for a big two-man tackle with Ardie Savea. A big defensive shift from Blackadder again but this time with a clean sheet. Was the second lineout option and offered pressure on Argentina, disrupting a couple of their throws.

7. Dalton Papali’i – 6
A couple of big first phase tackles from Papali’i. Got through 10 tackles in total and went off at 51 mins for Sam Cane.

8. Ardie Savea – 9
Early touch from a chip kick featured to classic Savea bump offs to set the tone for his night. Scored the second try from close range. Looked damaging with his carries. Had a burst down the right flank early in the second that led to the first.

ADVERTISEMENT

9. TJ Perenara – 7
A brilliant offload and assist for Will Jordan late in the first half with a snipe down the blindside from a lineout maul. A classic TJ play with the halfback at his best. Brought out the box kick in the second half. Off at 51.

10. Damian McKenzie – 8
Scored the first try from a deft chip. Handled most the kicking this week with TJ handing over the exits. Had one error, kicked out on the full after 10 minutes, but otherwise made good distance on his raking punts. Had a well-timed league pass to put Barrett through the line. Kicked 5/5 off the tee to start the game. Off at 51.

11. Caleb Clarke – 7
Scored a winger’s try with an open line midway through the first half. Got into the game with his kick chase in the second. Had a nice grab around the boot laces on a failed Pumas’ grubber kick and turned it into an attacking run.

12. Jordie Barrett – 7
A smart chip kick option for the first try to Damian McKenzie. Had an important kick block late in the first half and involved in the shift wide for Clarke’s try. Had some strong carries in the second half including a slice up the middle for a clean break.

13. Rieko Ioane – 6
A quiet first half for Ioane with a couple of carries in traffic. Had an important save from a kick off receipt gone wrong. Moved to the left wing with Lienert-Brown on. Had one slim chance with Tele’a linking up.

14. Will Jordan – 6
Scored a blistering try late in the first half with his speed down the short side. Scored a second from a simple block shape floating off his wing. Moved to fullback for the last half hour. Became isolated on a kick return and got pinged for holding on with no support around. Had another duffed kick that sparked a Pumas counter. A world class showing on the wing and a less than impressive cameo at fullback.

15. Beauden Barrett – 8
A smart first touch after Argentina dropped the ball, smashed it downfield in the wet conditions. Cleaned up well at the back all night. Scored on a great line punching into space on a flat ball from McKenzie. Moved into first five for final 30.

Substitutes

16. Asafo Aumua – 5 – On at 51. Strong carry first up running over the Pumas’ halfback. Much better at lineout time making all his throws. Produced a massive hit on Mateo Carreras and got yellow carded for it.
17. Ofa Tu’ungafasi – 2 – On at 53. Scrum dominance continued with the new front rowers, winning a penalty on first shove. Gave away a silly penalty clearing well past the ruck with the All Blacks on attack. Got stripped from the five on a lineout throw to the front. A tired tackle effort on the Pumas late try.
18. Fletcher Newell – 4 –  On at 51. Two carries and two tackles for the big prop.
19. Josh Lord – On at 54.
20. Sam Cane – 5 – On at 51. Came on energised and got into the defensive work. Made four tackles and had a couple of carries. Won a turnover defending his line with a forced knock-on.
21. Cortez Ratima – 4 – On at 51. Forced a collapsed maul turnover in unison with Savea and Blackadder. Attack languished a bit as the ruck slowed down with new cleaners on.
22. Anton Lienert-Brown – N/A – On at 59. Had one electric run late but otherwise a rather quiet showing in his 21 minutes with a few touches.
23. Mark Tele’a – 4 – On at 51. Involved frequently but didn’t get much space from the Pumas. Had one great carry up the middle with about 15 post-contact metres.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

48 Comments
S
SO 125 days ago

Thought Tuungafasi is playing more like Laulala did which is very poorly.He does not seem up to it anymore!

d
dk 125 days ago

I think he's still solid, but I'd prefer Williams on the bench if DeGroot is back. Tamaiti feels exciting as well as solid.

B
B 126 days ago

Ardie rated a 10/10...I totally agree that his gameplay rated a 9... but what about his captaincy....where I stood watching the game he effected a lot of onfield chatter, his overall team interaction especially with Blackadder, the rapport with referee Andrea Piardi throughout the 83 minutes and for mine what upped his rating was when late in the game Ardie asked the referee and then called everyone into a huddle under the posts for a general team warning...the yellow card for a head contact in front of me..laughable...the player stayed on the field no HIA was called but 5 minutes later went off clutching his right-side rib cage where Asafo Aumua smashed him...Ouch...a positive first 40 and apart from Jordans second try, the second half was nothing short of shite...Go the AB's...you needed to step up and finish a lot stronger... but instead fumbled and bumbled...any win is good and keeping the reputation of fortress Eden Park intact achieved...

R
RD 126 days ago

I've been arguing for years that Will Jordan can't play Fullback, hopefully more people are realising it now, 2 of his 4 touches there were ineffective, the other two were disastrous, the first running directly into defenders without support when he should have kicked and the other his attempted chip or punt that ended up being closer to a grubber.


Not only is he a poor backfield defender and a poor kicker but he normally benefits so much from having a tactically minded fullback creating those half opportunities he scythes through so well, completely wasted at Fullback.

C
Chiefs Mana 126 days ago

Need to persevere to build depth at fullback though - his decision making will improve.

a
av 126 days ago

I agree. No doubt that he has to be in the team but that’s at 14 for me right now. He’s a great super rugby fullback but international rugby is a different animal in terms of the technical side of it, positioning, kicking, linking up, defense etc…


He will learn and get there eventually but for now he has to be the 14 because he’s too good to leave out of the team. That’s a good tactic by razor to move him to 15 in the last 20-30 mins so at least he’s playing there.

S
SC 126 days ago

One muffed kick and he can’t play fullback, lol. As if Beauden Barrett, Jordie Barrett, and Damian McKenzie have never shanked a punt in their test career.

L
Longshanks 126 days ago

BB didn't do anything at first five for 30 minutes and gets an 8?! Don't think he was that flash at fullback either but Ben Smith seems to be chairman of his fan club.

B
BH 126 days ago

Another game that proved Beauden is better at coming on as a substitute than starting.

S
SC 126 days ago

How Beauden got a higher rating than Jordan, regardless of position, was laughable

T
Toaster 126 days ago

Yeah I thought he was decent at fullback but average at first five

M
Michael86 126 days ago

TaMighty was callosal in that game and he gets a 7. Will Jordan ripped them apart and gets a 6 lol

I
IS 126 days ago

He did at wing bit at fullback he wasn't that good

T
Toaster 126 days ago

Will did well but made a couple of bad mistakes


Great to have him back though

It’s interesting those mistakes were made at fullback where almost everyone wants him to play at test level

d
dk 126 days ago

Blackadder was immense. Everywhere and all the time. So much work making a huge difference.

D
DM 126 days ago

Yep he's been copping a bagging lately so it's good to see him turn up, Tupou and Darry both also stepped up to the plate. Loved Ardies passion.

T
Toaster 126 days ago

Finally

I’ve been a knocker but played really well

Vaai too who I’ve also thought wouldn’t cut it


Let’s see if they make it against the big boys

M
Michael86 126 days ago

Ratings are a bit harsh

T
Tk 126 days ago

I really don't get why subs all have low ratings? Players don't choose their minutes. If only on for 21 mins how did they play for those 21 mins? Two players no ratings, did writer simply run out of enthusiasm?

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 1 hour ago
Does South Africa have a future in European competition?

I rated Lowe well enough to be an AB. Remember we were picking the likes of George Bridge above such players so theres no disputing a lot of bad decisions have been made by those last two coaches. Does a team like the ABs need a finicky winger who you have to adapt and change a lot of your style with to get benefit from? No, not really. But he still would have been a basic improvement on players like even Savea at the tail of his career, Bridge, and could even have converted into the answer of replacing Beauden at the back. Instead we persisted with NMS, Naholo, Havili, Reece, all players we would have cared even less about losing and all because Rieko had Lowe's number 11 jersey nailed down.


He was of course only 23 when he decided to leave, it was back in the beggining of the period they had started retaining players (from 2018 onwards I think, they came out saying theyre going to be more aggressive at some point). So he might, all of them, only just missed out.


The main point that Ed made is that situations like Lowe's, Aki's, JGP's, aren't going to happen in future. That's a bit of a "NZ" only problem, because those players need to reach such a high standard to be chosen by the All Blacks, were as a country like Ireland wants them a lot earlier like that. This is basically the 'ready in 3 years' concept Ireland relied on, versus the '5 years and they've left' concept' were that player is now ready to be chosen by the All Blacks (given a contract to play Super, ala SBW, and hopefully Manu).


The 'mercenary' thing that will take longer to expire, and which I was referring to, is the grandparents rule. The new kids coming through now aren't going to have as many gp born overseas, so the amount of players that can leave with a prospect of International rugby offer are going to drop dramatically at some point. All these kiwi fellas playing for a PI, is going to stop sadly.


The new era problem that will replace those old concerns is now French and Japanese clubs (doing the same as NRL teams have done for decades by) picking kids out of school. The problem here is not so much a national identity one, than it is a farm system where 9 in 10 players are left with nothing. A stunted education and no support in a foreign country (well they'll get kicked out of those countries were they don't in Australia).


It's the same sort of situation were NZ would be the big guy, but there weren't many downsides with it. The only one I can think was brought up but a poster on this site, I can't recall who it was, but he seemed to know a lot of kids coming from the Islands weren't really given the capability to fly back home during school xms holidays etc. That is probably something that should be fixed by the union. Otherwise getting someone like Fakatava over here for his last year of school definitely results in NZ being able to pick the cherries off the top but it also allows that player to develop and be able to represent Tonga and under age and possibly even later in his career. Where as a kid being taken from NZ is arguably going to be worse off in every respect other than perhaps money. Not going to develop as a person, not going to develop as a player as much, so I have a lotof sympathy for NZs case that I don't include them in that group but I certainly see where you're coming from and it encourages other countries to think they can do the same while not realising they're making a much worse experience/situation.

144 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Return of 30-something brigade provides welcome tonic for Wales Return of 30-something brigade provides welcome tonic for Wales
Search