1
All Blacks player ratings vs Springboks | Qatar Airways Cup
By Finn Morton
This might be one of the All Blacks’ darkest days in the Ian Foster era. Following four wins on the bounce, the New Zealanders were blown off the park 35-7 by the Springboks in London.
ADVERTISEMENT
And the Rugby World Cup is next.
Playing on the hallowed turf at Twickenham, the All Blacks had no answers for the Springboks’ dominance in all areas of the Test. They were relentless.
Scott Barrett was sent off after receiving a second yellow card just before the break, and that practically summed up their night. Things didn’t go to plan.
- Beauden Barrett – 2
This was probably Beauden Barrett’s worst performances in an All Blacks jersey. The legendary playmaker looked lost and out of place against a red-hot Springboks outfit. Barrett struggled during the first term, much like his teammates, and this trend continued after the break.
Barrett, who was inside his own 22 at the time, sent a cross-field kick into touch on the full just after the break. The Springboks made the most of their opportunity with world-class hooker Malcolm Marx crossing in the corner. Barrett was also beaten, easily, by Canan Moodie a few minutes later. Moodie looked like he’d scored an absolute worldie, only for the score to be cancelled out by the TMO.
- Will Jordan – 4
Will Jordan was sensational against the Springboks in Auckland last month, but it was a very different story at Twickenham. Jordan was ineffective for long periods of this match. The ball just didn’t come the winger’s way, sure, but Jordan normally finds a way.
Jordan, and the New Zealand rugby public, thought he’d scored the All Blacks’ first points of the Test on the stroke of halftime. But the referee and TMO intervened, the decided to dismiss the score due to a knock-on. That was the closest Jordan got to a genuine highlight.
- Rieko Ioane – 4
Rieko Ioane was kept quiet, very quiet at Twickenham. The All Blacks centre didn’t have any memorable moments as the New Zealanders struggled to survive the Springboks’ storm. Ioane, much like his midfielder partner Jordie Barrett, just couldn’t get things going.
- Jordie Barrett – 3.5
It was not a good night for the Barretts. All three of them – spoiler alert for those who are yet to read on to Scott, or hear what happened – made a couple of telling errors against a spirited Springboks outfit. During the first half, Barrett rushed out in defence to meet Andre Esterhuizen – but the Boks’ inside centre beat him, easily too.
Barrett also threw an intercept pass that allowed Boks wing Kurt-Lee Arendse to score under the sticks in the 34th minute. Barrett dropped his head, and so did his teammates. It just wasn’t their night. Barrett carried the ball eight times for more than 30 metres, and made 70 per cent of his tackles.
- Mark Telea – 5
Mark Telea burst down the left edge with his first carry early on, but that was a glimpse of promise on an otherwise tough night. Telea was caught flat-footed in defence with Damian Willemse dancing around him with ease during the first term. The wing was also caught out under the high ball a couple of times.
ADVERTISEMENT
But, it must be said that Telea worked hard – and that means something. The speedster ran for more than 90 metres, which was a fair bit better than many of his teammates.
- Richie Mo’unga – 5
With the All Blacks down to 13 men during the first half, playmaker Richie Mo’unga showed courage, passion and intent to hold a Springboks player up over the try line – preventing a certain try. But Mo’unga’s hero status was undone shortly after. Mo’unga missed what appeared to be a relatively routine penalty shot at goal, with the ball bouncing back off the upright.
Mo’unga was still one of the All Blacks’ best on a tough night, though, with the playmaker getting busy in both attack and defence.
- Aaron Smith – 4
Quite early on, as the rain begin to pour down onto the 30 players out in the middle, Smith made an uncharacteristic error. The halfback, who was only a few metres out from his try line, drilled a pass at captain Sam Cane’s ankles. Cane couldn’t regather at first, and the loose ball almost opened the door for a Springboks try. That, to a degree, summed up Smith’s night. The veteran couldn’t get things right, and neither could the All Blacks.
- Ethan de Groot – 4
Ethan de Groot is one of the most consistent players for the All Blacks week-to-week. The superstar loosehead is usually able to impress even when the going gets tough, but the fact that he couldn’t on Friday just highlights the All Blacks woes.
The Springboks took control on the back of some relentless work from their forwards. New Zealand, with de Groot in their front row, were penalised on multiple occasions during the first term alone. De Groot finished with three carries, but had made the equal-most tackles by an All Black when he was replaced.
- Dane Coles – 4
Veteran Dane Coles put in a solid shift during the first half in London, but it was far from an outstanding display. The All Blacks struggled, and that includes Coles. The hooker missed some throws at the lineout, and otherwise failed to assert himself as the Boks ran riot. Coles was replaced by Samisoni Taukei’aho during the break.
- Tyrel Lomax – N/A
Today, Tyrel Lomax is a frontline All Black. If the Hurricanes tighthead wasn’t named to start this Test, there would’ve been mass confusion, shock and potentially anger. Lomax is just that important to the All Blacks, and has been for about a year now.
But that’s what makes Lomax’s injury so concerning.
Lomax left the field less than 15 minutes into the Test, and let’s face it, it didn’t look good. The Australian-born prop was carted off the field, and a closeup replay showed Lomax looking fairly upset. It wouldn’t fair to give Lomax a rating considering his limited minutes out in the middle.
- Samuel Whitelock – 3
Test centurion Sam Whitelock was absent from the All Blacks’ side that ran riot against the Boks in Auckland last month. Whitelock, 34, was ruled out due to a persist injury. But after taking the field during both Bledisloe Cup Tests, Whitelock was primed and ready to go against South Africa in London.
ADVERTISEMENT
But things didn’t go to plan. Far from it. Whitelock, much like his teammates in black, was kept quiet. The experienced campaigner was held to a few stops in defence, a couple of carries, and didn’t really make an impact at the set-piece.
- Scott Barrett – 2
Scott Barrett made history on Friday night, but not for the right reasons. Barrett is the first All Black ever to be sent off twice in Test rugby. Two yellow cards make a red, and that’s the easiest way to summarise Barrett’s night. Barrett received his marching orders following a needless high tackle on a defenceless Dane Vermeulen. What this means for Barretts Rugby World Cup remains to be seen.
- Luke Jacobson – 4
When the All Blacks and Springboks met in Auckland last month, flanker Shannon Frizell made his mark in the No. 6 jersey. Frizell was even compared to legendary All Blacks Jerome Kaino – but the loosie didn’t get the chance to repeat history at Twickenham. After picking up a “niggly” hamstring injury, Chiefs backrower Luke Jacobson was thrust into the starting side to take on the Boks.
But Jacobson’s night was cut short, and it was due to own doing. Following Scott Barrett’s red card late in the first term, the loose forward was replaced by lock Tupou Vaa’i. Jacobson had made five tackles and carried the ball twice. It’s fair to say it’s not the Test that Jacobson would’ve wanted.
- Sam Cane (c) – 4
Captain Cane had a tough night against the Boks. The flankers first major involvement was a dropped pass, with the loose ball ending up in the in goal. Cane managed to dive on the ball to prevent a try, but it piled more pressure on the All Blacks.
Shortly after, Cane was sent to the sin bin following a series of penalties from the New Zealanders. The skipper joined lock Scott Barrett in the sin bin as the All Blacks went down to 13 men. Cane made seven tackles and led the All Blacks in carries (10) by the time he was replaced.
- Ardie Savea – 4.5
Ardie Savea had some positive involvements early on, especially in attack, but the No. 8 went missing as the Test went on. Savea popped up here and there, sure, but was far from his best against the Boks. But backrower was solid in defence, and worked pretty hard to get things going in attack as well.
Replacements
- Samisoni Taukei’aho – 4.5
- Tamaiti Williams – 3.5
- Fletcher Newell – 4.5
- Josh Lord – 3
- Tupou Vaa’i – 4
- Dalton Papali’i – 4.5
- Cam Roigard – 6 – Was easily the All Blacks’ player on the night, and the young halfback came on quite late. Roigard scored a brilliant solo try which saw the All Blacks avoid a scoreless outing.
- Anton Lienert-Brown – 4
Sam has to go, the player's don't respect him Ardie should be 7
The variables came to haunt The All Blacks that day. It seemed everything that could go wrong for them compounded the haunting. They were not switched on mentally and the ref was clearly trigger-happy. !3 men then 14 for most of the match at this elite level...nigh impossible. However, I do not subscribe to the doom, gloom, and knives that masquerade as pens that the scribes are attacking the All Blacks with from all directions. I again see valuable lessons that resemble the All Blacks losing to Oz in a Test before the 2015 World Cup. All the mistakes that the All Blacks made, are fixable. The amount of variables that haunted the All Blacks are extremely unlikely to visit them again in this World Cup. It's pointless for me to enter into the minutiae of the sorry story of stats from the lineouts to, well, every facet, They were writ large for everyone to see. The Poms before the 2007 World Cup were thrashed yet they almost snatched the big prize. The All Blacks have all the weapons to win this World Cup. Personally, I think it's not so much a wake-up call but more a stark reminder to not just the All Blacks but every team at the World Cup or in fact any Test at any time, that if you are not switched on mentally, then you will come second. At this elite level when all bodies are physically primed, it is the mental component that is the most crucial of all. Yes, the loss was difficult to digest but again, all the mistakes I saw were clearly fixable. Two hours for the entire Test. Intensity was missing. This was not the World Cup It was all a bad dream kids and you'll wake up tomorrow and I'll tell ya a story of the men in black who wrote a story of excellence and magnificence as they stormed through France and defeated everything that dared get in their way... Everything's going to be alright. I promise.
You would have thought the rugby world would have learned from the past - in 1995 - All Blacks dominated only to be beaten against the odds in the Final. 1999 AllBlacks thrashed France in the lead up then lost to them against the odds. 2003 All Blacks thrashed the Wallabies in the lead up then lost to them against the odds. 2007 The All Blacks had beaten Les Bleus in their previous 7 encounters then lost to France against the odds. 2011 All Blacks lost to South Africa and Australia in the lead-up to winning the World Cup. 2015 All Blacks lost to The Wallabies in the lead-up to beating them in the World Cup Final. 2019 The All Blacks had beaten England 15 out of their previous 16 encounters. England won...against the odds. For the love of God, rugby people the lessons are there for all to see. The All Blacks defeated The Springboks convincingly at said World Cup yet South Africa went on to win the big show. Again and again again... There is a fine line between champagne and flat beer... The margins are minuscule History tells us that teams can turn their form around quicker than a politician's promises vanish. The All Blacks pain they will feel should cut to the bone. If they felt cock sure after their excellent form in the Rugby Championship, they have been brought thundering back to earth with a performance of shameful ineptitude. Nobody can understand that more than they do. They have two weeks to process what happened and concoct a plan to never experience such pain again. Here's the thing, There are really no special secrets to how they will do this. It will be back to tending to the little things because they add up to the big things. Yes, there will be tweaks in the game plan to combat the various challenges of playing against differering styles but the more things change, the more they stay the same...Forwards win matches and backs by how much. In the final analysis, rugby, like life can turn on a dime and the approaching World Cup will not escape the lessons we have been taught from history that previous form counts for naught. So, for now, we will endure the immediate pain of defeat, for soon it is my belief that we will get to savour the sweet taste of the nectar of world rugby supremacy when the Might of the All Blacks, right what's wrong and lift high for all their vanquished opponents to see, The Golden Chalice of the Webb Ellis Trophy in the year of Our Lord 2023.
Abs just not what they. Other teams have caught and overtaken them they’ll never dominate again. Books on form blow most away. Only Ireland and France will give them hard game
Well and truly out muscled up front. Hopefully a lot of lessons taken onboard. Still ceases to amaze me how BB can be in the 23. Consistently out of position/goes missing all the time. Would love to see Jordan there with leister and emoni on the wings…. I fear Foster is to stubborn or stupid to move past BB
We haven't found the right center's yet and it's not to late to try someone else at 7?
I think the ratings were nice to the All Blacks, except for Roiguard who should have been 8. He made good choices, considering he was behind "a beaten pack" which is always a good way to judge a half back's metal. He has certainly got that in spades.
Barrett - 7.5
Combined that it is….
Anytime there is a red card in the first half of a match all plans are out the window. Losing a lock against SA with the size of their pack was never going to go well, and especially when you have under sized loosies. Jacobson came off and now you have Sam and Andie will have almost no impact. Then when they emptied the bench the lineout went from bad to worse....
As a Bok fan, these ratings are harsh. I thought Telea was easily the best player and was dangerous almost every time he got the ball.
Overall the team defended very well being down a man for most of the game and massive credit should be given for that especially only conceding one try with 13 men! Any other team would have capitulated much sooner.
Rieko got some good go forward and Richie Moanga played very well considering the pressure his pack was under. Granted all the Barrett brothers had a nightmare and scrum was absolutely wrecked (ref even felt sorry on the last one and didn’t give a penalty) but sometimes things go wrong but there were certainly a couple of 7s and 6s at least
Cam Roigard gets a 6!?!
Author follows his spoiler up with the spoiler alert, that about says it all.