Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Are ravaged Wales facing a Six Nations mission impossible?

By PA
PA

Ireland and Wales meet in Dublin on February 5 to launch the penultimate Guinness Six Nations before the 2023 World Cup.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here the PA news agency examines five talking points heading into an event that sees France or England as favourites to seize Wales’ crown.

Wales face mission impossible
Wales are the champions who have consistently punched above their weight by becoming the competition’s most successful side since 2005, but surely even this remarkable rugby nation will be unable to defend their title. Seasoned campaigners Alun Wyn Jones, Josh Navidi, Justin Tipuric, Ken Owens and Leigh Halfpenny have been ruled out of the entire tournament through injury, while two more stars in George North and Taulupe Faletau could also miss out altogether. The depth of Wayne Pivac’s squad is being tested to its limits, but it also presents the stage for newcomers in the mould of Taine Basham and Louis Rees-Zammit to showcase their talents.

Video Spacer

Wales coach Wayne Pivac & skipper Dan Biggar preview Six Nations

Video Spacer

Wales coach Wayne Pivac & skipper Dan Biggar preview Six Nations

Eddie’s quest for consistency
England’s rollercoaster ride under Eddie Jones took another plunge downwards last year in the form a fifth-place finish in the Six Nations, on points difference their worst performance since Italy joined the competition in 2000. The team has been reshaped into ‘New England’ in a genuine overhaul that has seen go-to players of the Jones era such as the Vunipola brothers and Elliot Daly culled. A clean sweep of autumn victories over Tonga, Australia and South Africa has restored confidence but another finish near the wrong end of the Championship table would be unacceptable.

Smith takes centre stage
At the heart of the excitement building around England’s new direction is Marcus Smith, the highly gifted playmaker who has yet to put a foot wrong in five caps. He showed real maturity in a 27-26 victory over world champions South Africa in November, emerging from his toughest test yet with his reputation enhanced. The 22-year-old’s flair in attack has always been obvious, but it is his generalship that has shown the greatest improvement. A first Six Nations provides a new challenge, however, as Smith must prove he can deliver at the highest level when the distance is a marathon and not a sprint.

Dupont’s France on the march
Of all the teams involved, it is France who have the greatest capacity to animate the tournament as they continue building for the 2023 World Cup they are hosting. In Antoine Dupont they possess the world’s finest player who has redefined the role of a scrum-half, while an array of attacking threequarters are provided ample quality ball by one of the game’s strongest packs. A first victory over New Zealand on home soil since 2009 lit up their autumn and has lifted expectations heading into the Six Nations.

Scotland hint at new era
While Wales have excelled, Scotland’s epic quest for Six Nations glory continues. It is been 22 years since they last lifted the crown – Italy were not even part of the competition then – but could this be their year? Victories in London and Paris in 2021 is evidence of a side now able to mix it with the best and after supplying a large contingent to the Lions tour of South Africa, there is an abundance of talent in their ranks with the magical Finn Russell unrivalled as an attacking fly-half. It is an exciting time for Scottish rugby, but their past is littered with false dawns so cautious optimism is advised.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

M
M.W.Keith 1 hour ago
'Let's not sugarcoat it': Former All Black's urgent call to protect eligibility rules

I understand that there are choices to be made in professional sports and choices have consequences, but it does seem strange that a professional athlete who plies their trade in order to make a living cannot represent their country at test level. All talk of loyalty and so on is an outdated argument, we live in a global economy. It makes the armchair critic feel nice and so on, chatting smack about loyalty to a jersey and so on, but to think that someone like Mounga is not loyal to NZ just bc he is taking a paycheck - which as a professional athlete he is entitled to do - is a quite silly. No one is calling PSDT or Handre Pollard disloyal to SA bc they are taking a better paycheck somewhere else. No one accuses Cheslin Kolbe of being disloyal to the Green and Gold just because he missed out on years of eligibility by playing in France. Since Rassie opened the selection policy, the overseas players have more than proved their worth. Anyone who says otherwise is deluded and is living in an outdated version of reality. South Africans understand that the ZAR is worth very little and so no one in the country criticises a South African for leaving to find better economic opportunities elsewhere.


This is the same for anyone, anywhere. If there is an economic opportunity for someone to take, should they lose national privilege because they are looking for a better paycheck somewhere else? What a silly idea. The government doesn't refuse your passport because you work in another country, why should you lose your national jersey for this? If a player leaves to a so-called lesser league and their ability to represent their national jersey at a high level diminishes bc of it, then that should say it all. If Mounga were to return to the ABs and his playmaking is better than D-Mac and BB, then he is the better player for the position. If BB and D-Mac eclipse him, then they are the better players and should get the nod. Why is this so difficult to understand? Surely you want the best players to play in the national team, regardless of who pays their monthly salary? Closing borders is historically a silly economic idea, why should it be any different in national level sports?


The old boys tradition in rugby has created a culture of wonderful sportsmanship, it is why we all (presumably) prefer the game to football. But when tradition gets in the way of common sense and sporting success, perhaps traditions should change. Players have the right to earn money, there is no need to punish them for it. Rugby needs to think globally if it wants to survive.

36 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Scottish Rugby set for huge Duhan van der Merwe shaped boost Scottish Rugby set for huge Duhan van der Merwe shaped boost
Search