Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Argentina player ratings vs All Blacks | The Rugby Championship

TJ Perenara Kicks

New Zealand got their Rugby Championship campaign back on track with a first half blitzing of Argentina to secure a 42 – 10 win in Auckland.

ADVERTISEMENT

The victory was the All Blacks 50th consecutive unbeaten outing at Eden Park and was a reminder that a lot can change in a week at the top level.

Looking far more composed and assured in their game plan, Scott Robertson’s side dominated the physical contest and played at a pace that Argentina simply could not live with. On the flip side of this, Los Pumas looked lethargic just a week on from arguably their best performance of the past five years. Soaking tackles, getting held up in the carry and being blown away at the ruck, Felipe Contepomi’s side will depart New Zealand with a feeling of a glass half empty ahead of back-to-back home clashes with the Wallabies.

Here is how Los Pumas fared in Auckland.

1. Thomas Gallo – 3
Obliterated at scrum time under the weight of a wheeling Los Pumas pack as Sordoni struggled mightily on the other side. Despite his obvious struggles he remained on the park for sixty minutes.

2. Julian Montoya – 4
A rose between two thorns, Montoya put in an industrious shift for sixty minutes. Most of his work was done around the ruck where Los Pumas had to contend with lightening quick ruck speed from the All Blacks.

3. Lucio Sordoni – 3
Conceding two penalties and getting twisted like a bottle cap at scrum time, Sordoni never got to the pace of the contest.

Defence

161
Tackles Made
137
14
Tackles Missed
31
92%
Tackle Completion %
82%

4. Marcos Kremer – 3
Far from his rampaging best with three carries for four meters and thirteen tackles. Starting the contest in the secondrow, he was unable to mix it with the inexperienced All Blacks locks physically as he missed a few key tackles. Shifting to his preferred position in the backrow for the final half an hour saw a significant uptick in his performance but by that point a result was out of reach.

ADVERTISEMENT

5. Pedro Rubiolo – 3
Completely outshone by his opposite number Sam Darry, his inability to control the line-out meant that his team squandered several attack opportunities throughout the contest.

6. Pablo Matera – 4
Left clutching at shadows as Ardie Savea rampaged from the base of the All Blacks scrum, Matera was a tick off the pace. Yet despite this he never lacked for passion and intent and was Los Pumas only secure option at the line-out with six takes. Despite his willingness to get stuck in, his statistical performance was direction reflection of the hiding his front five took as he looked to plug the gaps that should’ve been filled by those wearing numbers 1 – 5.

7. Juan Martin Gonzalez – 4
Held up immediately from the kick-off in the second half was a snapshot of a performance in which he was found isolated on several occasions. Despite being one of the top carriers for his side, Gonzalez conceded two costly penalties as the All Blacks doubled up on him in the tackle leading to several turnovers and spilled balls.

8. Joaquin Oviedo – 5
Few could blame him for making little impact behind a scrum that was back tracking faster than the selection committee who sent RayGun to the Olympics. In open play he was busy as he made 30 meters from five carries and fronted up defensively with 12 tackles (1 dominant) before being replaced in the 50th minute.

ADVERTISEMENT

Possession

Team Logo
13%
25%
29%
33%
Team Logo
12%
16%
46%
26%
Team Logo
Team Logo
44%
Possession Last 10 min
56%
52%
Possession
48%

9. Gonzalo Bertranou – 3
Directly responsible for the All Blacks third try when the referee clearly told him the All Blacks were onside when he picked up the ball. Despite this he simply passed the ball to Tupou Vaa’i which set up a simple through the hands try for Caleb Clarke. In his defence, Los Pumas ruck was a shambles throughout the first half which was reflected in his rather dismall 18 passes during his time on the park.

10. Santiago Carreras – 3
Plucked from the action two minutes into the second half says it all for the flyhalf. Standing in stark contrast to his round one outing, Carreras looked lost behind a pack that couldn’t get any go forward ball. This forced him further into the pocket where he never looked like challenging the line and saw him shuffle stagnant ball onto those around him. Defensively he was found wanting on several occasions most notably when Will Jordan skinned him one-on-one in what should’ve been a routine tackle.

11. Mateo Carreras – 4
Sprung into action in the final ten minutes with some good carries that padded his stat line to 24 meters from five carries. Prior to this golden patch he was completely anonymous and spent most of his time back pedalling as the All Blacks went through the gears.

12. Santiago Chocobares – 4
Fronted up defensively in face of an All Blacks onslaught with 14 tackles made. Unfortunately opportunities to carry were far and few between as he got his hands on the ball just four times for nine meters.

13. Lucio Cinti – 4
Utilised as a kicking option on a handful of occasions, the Saracens centre didn’t have the time and space that he enjoyed a week ago. Defensively, Reiko Ioane’s pace caused him significantly more challenges than Anton Leinert-Brown did a week ago which saw the All Blacks get around the rush defence seemingly at will throughout the first half.

14. Matias Moroni – 3
One carry for two meters is about as bad as it gets for a winger who last week torched the All Blacks in broken play. Part of the triplet that were removed from the action in the 42nd minute, his inability to cover the All Blacks kicking game was a major red flag. When he was removed, Los Pumas handled this area more comfortably with Bautista Delguy covering the open space more efficiently which nullified a previously rampant attack.

Match Summary

0
Penalty Goals
1
6
Tries
1
6
Conversions
1
0
Drop Goals
0
110
Carries
129
9
Line Breaks
3
14
Turnovers Lost
21
5
Turnovers Won
3

15. Juan Cruz Mallia – 5
Head and shoulders above his teammate, the Toulouse fullback was brave in defence as the All Blacks peppered him with an array of kicks. Offensively he was Los Pumas top carrier with 9 carries for 68 meters and a try. His willingness to step up as a first receiver saw him score what was a truly exceptional individual try as he slipped between multiple All Blacks defenders.

Substitutes:
16. Ignacio Ruiz – 5
Entering the match when his team had been under the pump for sixty minutes, he brought some much needed flair and willingness to get on the ball both in attack and defence. Coming up with some good tackles and a key turnover, he was the pick of the forward replacements.

17. Mayco Vivas – 3
Bearing the brunt of the pressure going through Sclavi’s side of the scrum, he didn’t have an opportunity to test Fletcher Newell like he did in round one. Away from the set piece he got himself involved with five tackles and three carries during his twenty minute cameo.

18. Joel Sclavi – 3
Three penalties conceded during his thirty minute shift on the park is not the impact he would’ve wanted to have on the fixture. Drifting away from being the ultimate impact sub that he was a week ago, he merely picking up where the starting front row left off.

19. Franco Molina – 3
Seven tackles (1 missed) and one penalty conceded, he was somewhat of a non-factor for the thirty minutes he was on the park. Perhaps his biggest contribution was freeing up Kremer to move into the backrow where he had more of an impact.

20. Tomas Lavanini – 3
Huffing and puffing without ever blowing the All Blacks away, Lavanini came on and tried to unsettle the hosts. In reality he didn’t walk the walk that his talk merited as he was seen to be constantly getting stuck into verbal altercations.

21. Lautaro Bazan Velez – 5
Certainly an upgrade on the struggling Bertanou, the Benetton halfback handled a messy ruck as best he could. Completing 48 passes to Bertanou’s 18, he got the Argentine backline rolling and crucial shifted the ball away from the All Blacks poachers.

22. Tomas Albornoz – 5
Brought more direction to the attack than Carreras which saw an uptick in Los Pumas performance albeit the win was out of reach. Defensively he brought a physical edge which saw a noticeable reduction in the All Blacks simply going through the middle of the rush defence.

23. Bautista Delguy – 4
Replacing Moroni in the 42nd minute, the Clermont flyer came off his wing far more than his starting compatriot. Offering himself as a carrier into traffic took pressure of the halfbacks as Los Pumas played out a more even second half against an All Blacks side who slightly took their foot off the gas.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

1 Comment
b
by 139 days ago

What has happened to what was once probably the toughest scrummaging country in world rugby.

C
Carlos 138 days ago

A very long story of poor management and worse local rugby y policies. Basically, a catastrophe.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

f
fl 3 hours ago
What is the future of rugby in 2025?

on the article "Why defensive aggressor Felix Jones will drive new-look England" I said:


"Look at the kick:pass ratio from England’s games under Borthwick:

Italy 20:100

Argentina 50:100

South Africa 53:100

Fiji 24:100

Samoa 22:100

Chile 12:100

Japan 25:100

Argentina 55:100

Fiji 30:100

Ireland 21:100

Wales 24:100

Wales 13:100

Ireland 26:100

France 22:100

Wales 26:100

Italy 23:100

Scotland 18:100

The average is 27:100

The average in games we have won is 28:100

The average in games we have lost is 26:100, but these averages are skewed by the fact that we have tended to kick less and pass more against worse sides

The average in games where we have beaten current top 10 sides is 35:100

The average in games where we have beaten current top 8 sides is 39:100

The average in games where we have beaten current top 7 sides is 53:100

The average in games where we have lost to teams currently ranked lower than us is 20:100"


on the article "Four talking points after England's narrowest-ever win over Italy" I said:


"Look at the kick:pass ratio from England’s last 8 games

Italy 20:100

Argentina 50:100

South Africa 53:100

Fiji 24:100

Samoa 22:100

Chile 12:100

Japan 25:100

Argentina 55:100

So (1) England spread it wide more yesterday than against anyone bar Chile, and (2) all of england’s best performances have been when we kick loads, and in every match where we kick loads we have had a good performance."


"In particular you're neglecting the impact of the type of D Felix Jones was trying to introduce, which demanded most of England's training energy at the time."


I'm not, actually, I'm hyper aware of that fact and of its impact. I think it is because of the defence that England's new attack faltered so much for the first three games, something you ignore when you try to judge England's attack in the six nations by taking an average of either the trys scored or the rucks completed over the whole tournament.


"International coaches don't just pick those styles like sweets from a sweet shop!"

Yeah, I know. England's defence wasn't exactly the same as SA's, but it was similar. England's attack did rely on turnovers more than the Irish system did, but it was still pretty similar to it, and then shifted to something similar-but-not-identitcal to the Labit/Nick Evans systems, which are themselves similar but not identical.

103 Go to comments
f
fl 4 hours ago
The Fergus Burke test and rugby's free market

"So who were these 6 teams and circumstances of Marcus's loses?"


so in the 2023 six nations, England lost both games where Marcus started at 10, which was the games against Scotland and France. The scotland game was poor, but spirited, and the french game was maybe the worst math england have played in almost 30 years. In all 3 games where Marcus didn't start England were pretty good.


The next game he started after that was the loss against Wales in the RWC warmups, which is one of only three games Borthwick has lost against teams currently ranked lower than england.


The next game he's started have been the last 7, so that's two wins against Japan, three losses against NZ, a loss to SA, and a loss to Australia (again, one of borthwicks only losses to teams ranked lower than england).


"I think I understand were you're coming from, and you make a good observation that the 10 has a fair bit to do with how fast a side can play (though what you said was a 'Marcus neutral' statement)"


no, it wasn't a marcus neutral statement.


"Fin could be, but as you've said with Marcus, that would require a lot of change elsewhere in the team 2 years out of a WC"


how? what? why? Fin could slot in easily; its Marcus who requires the team to change around him.


"Marcus will get a 6N to prove himself so to speak"


yes, the 2022 six nations, which was a disaster, just as its been a disaster every other time he's been given the reigns.

224 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Ronan O'Gara weighs in on Jack Crowley selection controversy Ronan O'Gara weighs in on Jack Crowley selection controversy
Search