1
'Best 9 in the country on form': Ex-All Black halfback's view on Finlay Christie
By Sam Smith
Former All Black halfback Justin Marshall has agreed that Blues halfback Finlay Christie is the form number 9 in New Zealand this year, but warned that it doesn’t mean he will be given the All Blacks starting role.
ADVERTISEMENT
On hearing former Blues and All Black Steve Devine’s opinion that Christie had surpassed Aaron Smith in the pecking order on SENZ’s The Bunnings Trade Rugby Run radio show, Marshall sided with the Devine’s view that Christie is in a purple patch of form that is above everybody else.
“I certainly think he [Christie] is the in form 9 in the country,” Marshall said on SENZ’s The Bunnings Trade Rugby Run.
Video Player is loading.
This is a modal window.
The Video Cloud video was not found.
Error Code: VIDEO_CLOUD_ERR_VIDEO_NOT_FOUND
Session ID: 2025-05-19:3949052588285fdbb5808c09 Player Element ID: brightcove-embedded-video
“Equally so was Brad Weber, he was playing well before his injury. He’s just super consistent, he delivers.
“I think in terms of the balance and the threat that he is at the moment, Finlay Christie, he is arguably the best 9 in the country on form.
“Whether or not that gives him the All Black number 9 jersey is definitely up for debate, because the All Blacks build their rhythm around what Aaron Smith delivers.”
“That doesn’t mean he can’t pressure him for an opportunity to start, but I would imagine if you are picking the side at the moment, he would definitely be in that matchday 23.”
ADVERTISEMENT
Marshall believed there would be a spot for Christie on the bench to come into games late and provide impact based on his Super Rugby Pacific form.
He highlighted his performance against the Crusaders in Christchurch as the game where Christie showed he is operating at a higher level.
“He’s playing good rugby, and he particularly stepped up his game against the Crusaders I thought. He was a real threat around the breakdown, he took steps and brought players into the game,” he said.
“His defence was very good. He’s a gritty little defender. His kicking game is as good as the rest in the country.
ADVERTISEMENT
“So I wouldn’t disagree with Steve Devine that at the moment he’s the form player in that jersey in the country, he is above the level that everyone else is playing at.
“But I don’t believe that gives him the right to step into that All Black number 9 jersey right now.”
The long time back-up to Aaron Smith has been TJ Perenara, who has played 56 of his 77 tests as a reserve halfback since debuting in 2014.
Despite pushing Christie’s claims forward to take over the reserve halfback role, Marshall didn’t believe that Perenara would be done either.
“No, I don’t,” Marshall proclaimed when asked if he thought Perenara’s time was up.
“TJ is too competitive to be done, he brings qualities to the jersey that others don’t have in the country, and you certainly can’t count out a guy that has been to World Cups and delivered.
“Again, he is a player that has continually been selected in All Blacks teams … probably over the last decade I would imagine. I’d be very reluctant to rule out TJ Perenara from any mix, in any equation that the All Blacks come up with.”
“He’ll be very well aware that there are other players in the country playing well like Finlay Christie, Brad Weber and Folau Fakatava,
My three 9s for 2022 and building into RWC 2023 would be Smith, Christie and Ratima. TJP's time has passed, and Weber makes way for Ratima's development.
Ratima and Fakatava should be the combo from 2024.
1. Why wouldn't the slowest worst passing no 9 in AB history not be standing up for his successor as slowest worst passing no 9 in NZ? 2. Christie? Anyone would look good behind the Blues pack. The true measure of a decent no 9 is how they perform when their pack is going backwards.