Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

All Blacks winger chimes in on GOAT debate after France defeat

PARIS, FRANCE - NOVEMBER 16: Gabin Villiere of France is tackled by Caleb Clarke of New Zealand during the Autumn Nations Series 2024 match between France and New Zealand at the Stade de France on November 16, 2024 in Paris, France. (Photo by Franco Arland/Getty Images)

Scott Robertson’s All Blacks have slumped to a one-point defeat at Stade de France at the hands of a France side buoyed by 80,000 home fans.

ADVERTISEMENT

France were helped by an impressive performance from the boot of first five Thomas Ramos, who had 15 points, kicking all of his six attempts. 

The game went down to the final minutes after All Blacks captain Scott Barrett chose to take the three in front of the posts with five minutes to go, down four points.

Penalties

13
Penalties Conceded
9
0
Yellow Cards
0
0
Red Cards
0

All Blacks blockbusting winger Caleb Clarke said his teammates were hurting following the nail-biting defeat. 

“Straight away, a bit disappointed, it’s natural to feel a little hurt after that loss, boys got around each other after the final whistle went because everyone put it all out there, ” said Caleb Clarke to the media minutes after the final whistle against France.

“Man you could feel it in the changing rooms, everyone was hurting but again a hurting All Blacks side is a dangerous side as well.

“So really looking forward to having another opportunity next week against Italy and inflicting the hurt onto our next opponents.”

ADVERTISEMENT

France were able to wrestle back the momentum early in the second half through a Louis Bielle-Biarrey try after a Tupou Vaa’i mistake with the ball in hand. 

The All Blacks settled for three points on multiple occasions, staying within touching distance of France late in the second half.

Related

Clarke admits the All Blacks had the opportunities to win the game, but failed to be clinical.

“We talked about it in the changing rooms. It’s small margins is what it takes to win Test matches, and sport goes one winner so all credit to France they played an awesome game that put us under pressure, we had our opportunities but kind of let it slip.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Clarke had 14 carries and an equal game-high two line breaks, which he put down to the amount of ball his teammates managed to give him.

Player Line Breaks

1
Louis Bielle-Biarrey
2
2
Caleb Clarke
2
3
Romain Buros
1

“I think I was just happy to get the ball, I wanted it in my hands a lot more and to get some go forward and felt like getting on the edges. 

“Especially coming back down the blindside we had some success, but again I think we tried to force the pass, especially in the 22 is the guttering part, forcing the pass, or missing the clean, which really made us lose the game in the end.”

When asked about how the All Blacks manage to balance the risk and reward passes on attack, Clarke credits the coaching staff and the messages the players receive.

“I think Razor (Scott Robertson) does a great job during the week, where he wants us to express ourselves and play freely but again he tells us don’t force the pass, making sure we are through contact before we throw it or making sure whoever we are passing to is open and free. 

“Razor is really balancing it well and we had a great week this week too, leading up to the game, that’s probably why it hurts a bit more, that we didn’t get the result especially because it’s by one point.”

It was Clarke’s first encounter against France’s talisman and superstar halfback Antoine Dupont,  with the 25-year old saying he has lots of respect for the halfback. 

“I have so much respect for that dude, I think that was my first time running up against him, I was just saying before he tackled me but I didn’t even see him coming, I was like where the heck did you even come from.”

Clarke has chimed in on the GOAT debate in rugby and was asked about whether Dupont can be the greatest even without playing away from home. 

The All Blacks winger still backs his fellow countryman as the best ever.

“I think for me the GOAT is still Richie McCaw, until he can play against him, yeah we will see how that goes.”

Watch the exclusive reveal-all episode of Walk the Talk with Ardie Savea as he chats to Jim Hamilton about the RWC 2023 experience, life in Japan, playing for the All Blacks and what the future holds. Watch now for free on RugbyPass TV

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

21 Comments
J
Jmann 33 days ago

Dan Carter is the leading points scorer and leading points per game person for a player with significant tests. 2s RWC winner and member of the games greatest ever team. It's not even close. The only question of GOAT for rugby is whether McCaw deserves it given Carter's numbers.

R
RedWarrior 33 days ago

That NZ team was not GOAT. They scraped a home world cup and needed a dodgy schedule to win in 2015. Barely shaded SA after a walk over QF. The modern SA team are better and to be honest same could be said for Ireland and France team in the last few years.

D
DrinkAwayTheConcussion 33 days ago

I don’t understand the debate at all.

PSDT is the GOAT.

DuPenis isn’t even in the conversation with people who use words with more than two syllables.

B
Bull Shark 34 days ago

I do understand the preoccupation with Dupont and official/unofficial GOAT status.


Men of his stature are in short supply.

L
LRB 34 days ago

To the author..


"The All Blacks have slumped to a one point defeat"


Slumped.??


Dictionary meaning of slumped..


sit - lean - fall heavily & limply


I'm urging you to amend that sentence & please educate yourself on the English language.

B
Bull Shark 34 days ago

I’m the GOAT

L
LK 33 days ago

You turned into a Goat?

N
Nope 34 days ago

If you’re not willing to play in every national game on offer then you simply cannot be considered in the GOAT conversation, could you imagine Ritchie, Dan, Siya saying “nah, I don’t wanna travel for my team”, no, because it would never happen. The guy is good, GOAT? Absolutely not.

G
GH 33 days ago

It might be times for non-french people to understand Dupond (or any international player from Toulouse or La Rochelle) can NOT play in southern hemisphere. Impossible. There are only three southern games in june while Toulouse or La Rochelle are in semi-finals and finale of Top14. The debate is closed before it even began. All Blacks coaches can decide who play or not in local championships, not the case in France, it isn't even an option

R
RedWarrior 34 days ago

Another Kiwi re defines prerequisites for great players to suit his one eyed jingoistic outlook.

H
Hellhound 34 days ago

There is different GOATS in rugby. Different times, different era's. Different rules, different players. Instead of THE GOAT, it should be ONE of the GOAT's of rugby. Lomu, Habana,Augustin Pichot etc. Just my personal opinion.

H
Head high tackle 34 days ago

This GOAT stuff is just plain silly. He's a good player who plays 7 tests a year in a big year. It gets more and more rediculs every week.

B
Bull Shark 34 days ago

Cheslin Kolbe is the GOAT

I
Icefarrow 34 days ago

Especially considering how ineffective he was this match. None of his usual flair.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

H
Hellhound 3 hours ago
Does South Africa have a future in European competition?

All you can do is hate on SA. Jealousy makes you nasty and it's never a good look. Those who actually knows rugby is all talking about the depth and standards of the SA players. They don't wear blinders like you. The NH had many years to build the depth and players for multiple competition the SA teams didn't. There will be growing pains. Not least travel issues. The NH teams barely have to travel to play an opponent opposed to the SA teams. That is just one issue. There is many more issues, hence the "growing pains". The CC isn't yet a priority and this is what most people have a problem with. Saying SA is disrespecting that competition which isn't true. SA don't have the funds yet to go big and get the players needed for 3 competitions. It all costs a lot of money. It's over using players and get them injured or prioritising what they can deliver with what are available. To qualify for CC, they need to perform well in the URC, so that is where the main priorities is currently. In time that will change with sponsors coming in fast. They are at a distinct disadvantage currently compared to the rest. Be happy about that, because they already are the best international team. You would have hated it if they kept winning the club competitions like the URC and CC every year too. Don't be such a sourmouth loser. See the complete picture and judge accordingly. There is many factors you aren't even aware of at play that you completely ignore just to sound relevant. Instead of being an positive influence and spread the game and help it grow, we have to read nonsense like this from haters. Just grow up and stop hating on the game. Go watch soccer or something that loves people like you.

129 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Return of 30-something brigade provides welcome tonic for Wales Return of 30-something brigade provides welcome tonic for Wales
Search