1
Clive Woodward calls out Ben Earl over post-match comments
By Ian Cameron
Sir Clive Woodward has criticised England’s outstanding No.8 – Ben Earl – following his side’s 23-22 Six Nations win over Ireland in Twickenham.
ADVERTISEMENT
Marcus Smith’s dramatic last-minute drop goal prevented Ireland from securing back-to-back Grand Slams, leaving the Six Nations title up for grabs. England, buoyed by their victory against the reigning champions, head to Lyon to contest the crown against France. This comes just two weeks after a disappointing defeat to Scotland, showcasing a remarkable turnaround in form and morale.
However, Woodward has told Earl to focus on performing on the pitch rather than attacking the media in post-match interviews. Earl, known for his dynamic play for the Saracens and England, delivered a standout performance against Ireland, contributing significantly to the win.
Video Player is loading.
His post-match interview with ITV revealed the depth of his and the team’s emotions, a reflection of the side’s tumultuous journey in recent weeks.
“I’m a bit emotional,” he said. “Because obviously Jamie [George] lost his mum the other week and we spoke a lot about that this week. And then Danny’s 100th and some of the crap that’s been thrown at this team over the last week. Apparently, we’re the worst England team ever, we’ve done pretty well for that accolade.”
Woodward wasn’t happy with the remarks and issued his rebuke in his Daily Mail column. Woodward suggests Earl’s exceptional talent and on-field contributions should remain his primary mode of communication.
“I didn’t like seeing a number of them hit back at the media in post-match interview,” wrote Woodward.
ADVERTISEMENT
“Ben Earl was one to criticise the coverage England received after their Scotland defeat. That’s not what champion teams or champion individuals do. They should ignore the media or just see criticism as positive feedback like I did.
“Earl’s comments that ‘apparently we are the worst England team ever’ and ‘we have done pretty well for that accolade’ were not needed and detracted from the team’s performance and his own, which was outstanding.
“I don’t think anyone in the press called England’s current crop the worst in the country’s history!
“England’s players have to accept that if they play poorly — as they did in Edinburgh — they will be criticised. It’s part of playing at the highest level. I also think England shouldn’t just take aim at the media as a collective. If a player or coach has a grievance with what a journalist has written, then name them directly! If that is me, then I’m absolutely fine with that!”
ADVERTISEMENT
No Clive we don’t want sterile, scripted and soulless responses from players. Ben Earl plays with his heart on his sleeve (similar to Dalligio) so if he expresses his emotions and feelings in the media good on him. Clive if you haven’t noticed Rugby needs some things to change or it will become extinct. Fans enjoy seeing the players with genuine passion and showing their human qualities.
Speak for yourself.
I don’t want to listen to players whinge and complain. News flash, if you play international sport you will get criticised some times. Get over it. If you don’t like it, find another job. I wouldn’t go on social media to complain about my job.
All of this nonsense about players needing personalities.
No
I watch rugby because I like the sport. I couldn’t care less what players think, feel or do outside of the sport. I am not interested in their personalities. The only people that really care about all that rubbish are kids who idolise their heroes. And I wouldn’t want my son idolising someone with a chip on their shoulder, like Earl clearly has.
Ben Earl’s personality comes across in the way he plays and interviews and I love it!
Suck it up, Clive.
Alas, Sir Clive has become a broken record. I remember him being spikey with the press, and indeed, downright offensive about his employer. The words pot and kettle spring to mind.
Seems like the players aren't the only ones sensitive about criticism 😀
Ben Earl and the England team used media commentary to unify (they are saying you are sh1t, whatcha gonna do about it?). You want a grievance common to all players to create a collective purpose.
Maybe the sense of grievance was so acute (eg Borthwick's observation about the jersey weighing heavy V Scotland= media were hurting team) he could not help himself.
Media might think twice now or might feel they owe Earl some revenge later. Not enough info for Lord McDuck to judge Earl.
Jesus as if anyone cares what that has been has to say.
Woodward is a self-important irrelevance these days….
He gets paid to write rugby articles. He's the only English coach to win a RWC. You might not care for his opinion, but he's better qualified than most other scribes.
Clive Woodward should focus less on criticising players, and more on being a better journalist.
Players or coaches who have not performed well deserve criticism we still have free speech as far as I am aware.