Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Concussion claims another - RugbyPass looks at players who've been forced to retire due to head knocks

Alistair Hargreaves leaves pitch with concussion

Concussion has ended the career of another professional rugby player, this time in Super Rugby.

Hurricanes prop Reggie Goodes is just 26, but has had to step away from the game.

The South African-born player took a head knock during a pre-season match for the Hurricanes in February 2017, the third time he had been forced to take extended leave from the game due to concussion since 2014.

ADVERTISEMENT

RugbyPass looks at some other players have been forced to walk away due to head injuries.

Nathan White – Waikato, Leinster, Connacht and Ireland:

Ireland international prop with 13 caps retired in 2016 aged 35. He featured in all five of Ireland’s games at the 2015 World Cup. White suffered a head injury while playing for Connacht in March 2016 against Leinster and retired in September of that year on medical advice.

Alistair Hargreaves – Sharks, Saracens and South Africa:

Former Saracens captain, who led the club to the 2015 Premiership title. The Springbok hung up his boots just a week after Nathan White’s announcement in September 2016. Hargreaves was 30 when he retired, after repeated concussions over a two year period.

Kevin McLaughlin – Leinster and Ireland:

McLaughlin was 31 when he walked away from the game. The flanker suffered a head injury playing for Leinster in their Pro 12 opener against Edinburgh on September 4th 2015. McLaughlin was captaining the side on the day, making his 115th appearance for the club. Less than three weeks later he retired.

Jonathan Thomas – Ospreys, Worcester and Wales:

The former Wales flanker was diagnosed with epilepsy, thought to have been brought about by head trauma. His club Worcester said at the time that Thomas had suffered “a degree of brain injury”. Thomas was part of Wales’ Grand Slam winning squads in 2005 and 2008.

ADVERTISEMENT

James Broadhurst – Hurricanes and New Zealand:

Broadhurst made one appearance for the All Blacks, against South Africa in July 2015. Just a month later the second row was concussed while playing for Taranaki in a Mitre 10 Cup clash against Wellington, it proved to be his final game. He continued to suffer headaches, with doctors advising him to keep his heart rate below 120-beats-per-minute to avoid them. He announced his retirement in April 2017.


Mouritz Botha – Saracens, Newcastle Falcons and England

Newcastle Falcons’ former England lock Mouritz Botha was forced to call time on his rugby career at the age of 35.

A Premiership title winner with Saracens back in 2011, Botha made the decision on medical advice after failing to recover from concussion suffered during the 2016-17 season.

ADVERTISEMENT

Capped 10 times by England and playing Super Rugby for the Sharks in his native South Africa, the 6 foot 5 forward admitted it was a tough being forced into retirement but was able to look back on a successful playing career.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

S
SK 55 minutes ago
Why England's defence of the realm has crumbled without Felix Jones

The way they are defending is sometime pathetic to be honest. Itoje is usually on the inside of the rush and he is paired with a slower tight forward. Unable to keep up with the rush we have seen the line become disconnected on the inside where the big boys are. How many times have we seen Earl rush past the first receiver almost into no mans land covering no attacker. It looks like a system without any guidance. Tome Wright, Ikitau and a number of Wallabies went back to this soft centre as did Williams, Jordan and several others. Also when the line is broken the multiple lines of defence seems to be missing. The rush is predicated on a cover and recovery system with multiple lines of defence but with England you dont see it any more. Fitness and conditioning seems to be off as well as players are struggling to keep up with the intensity of the rush. Felix Jones has left a huge hole. The whole situation was and is a mess. Why they insist on not letting him go and having him work remotely is beyond me. Its leading to massive negative press and is a hot button issue thats distracting from the squad. Also the communication around Jones and his role has been absolute rubbish and is totally disjointed. While some say he is working remotely and playing a role others are saying theres been no contact. His role has not been defined and so people keep asking and keep getting different answers. England need a clean break from him and need to start over. Whatever reason for his leaving its time to cut the rope before the saga drags the whole Borthwick regime down. As for Joe El Abd well good luck to him. He is being made to look like an amateur by the whole saga and he is being asked to coach a system thats not his and which has been perfected and honed since 2017 by Nienaber, Jones, Erasmus and Co and which was first started by White in 2004. He is literally trying to figure out a system pioneered by double world cup winning coaches at the highest level and coach it at the same time. Talk about being on a hiding to nothing.

28 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Why England's defence of the realm has crumbled without Felix Jones Why England's defence of the realm has crumbled without Felix Jones
Search