1
Conor Murray under fire from fans for 'terrible, terrible' call
By Ian Cameron
Ireland veteran Conor Murray’s late-game decision to box kick the ball away in the dying minutes against England at Twickenham has sparked widespread criticism among Irish rugby fans.
ADVERTISEMENT
The match – which saw heavy underdogs England secure a narrow 23-22 victory over Ireland in the Guinness Six Nations – was sealed by Marcus Smith’s dramatic stoppage-time drop goal.
It was maybe England’s standout performance under Steve Borthwick and it also dashed Ireland’s hopes for back-to-back Grand Slams.
Video Player is loading.
Despite Ireland being the overwhelming favourites, England’s frenzied performance, marked by tries from Ollie Lawrence, George Furbank, and Ben Earl, turned the tables on the visitors.
As the game reached its crescendo, Ireland appeared to regain control with James Lowe’s try in the 72nd minute, setting the stage for what many expected to be a carefully managed endgame. However, Murray’s decision to kick, relinquishing possession in the crucial final minute, has become the focal point of fan frustration and disbelief for many.
Fans took to social media to express their dismay, questioning the rationale behind Murray’s choice at such a critical juncture. One fan lamented the lack of tactical acumen in holding onto possession and running down the clock, while another branded the decision as “criminal,” questioning the judgment of Ireland’s senior players in such pressure-cooker situations.
One fan asked: “I’m asking, not griping: Why didn’t Conor Murray hold possession and run through couple of clock-eating phases with Ireland’s last possession?” Another fan said: “Conor Murray kicking the ball away with a minute to go is criminal.. what the absolute **** are we doing.. so called ‘senior players’ ****ing the game away.” Another irate Irish fan wrote: “Full blame on Conor Murray there, or whoever made that call to kick with a minute to go, handing the ball to England – terrible, terrible decision! ”
ADVERTISEMENT
There were many tweets in the vein on the matter.
The chorus of disapproval crescendoed with accusations squarely aimed at Murray for handing the initiative back to England, a move that ultimately led to Smith’s winning drop goal.
Others defended Murray, pointing out that in modern rugby holding onto possession in your 22 can present more risk of conceding a penalty than simply punting the ball back to the opposition and hoping to force an error of them.
Tim O’Connor – a respected Irish rugby account on X – wrote: “It’s not 2008 any more. You can’t run off over a minute of time, against much better defences, with “Use it!” and the breakdown contest. The best you’ll get is a caterpillar ruck closer to your line. Get it out down-pitch, chase, trust your defence. It won the last two RWCs.”
Former Ireland hooker turned pundit Bernard Jackman pointed that Murray’s kick was the least of it in terms of poor defensive play by Ireland. “Lots of talk about the last 2 minutes and whether we should have kicked it off or not. But Ireland will be very disappointed with these two phases of defense. England were down to 14 and to concede that much ground from a 4 man lineout on the first phase and not get more players far side on phase two was poor. Good England attack though.”
Lots of talk about the last 2 minutes and whether we should have kicked it off or not. But Ireland will be very disappointed with these two phases of defense. England were down to 14 and to concede that much ground from a 4 man lineout on the first phase and not get more players… pic.twitter.com/2nm75EqfzG
— Bernard Jackman (@bernardjackman) March 10, 2024
ADVERTISEMENT
Ireland can still claim the championship if they manage to beat Scotland next week at the Aviva Stadium.
In my view, the best option was ball back to Lowe and a kick into the England 22. At worst first tackle is made in their half near half way…that is if they run it back. If they kick high and contestable, that at worst is short of the Ireland 10 m line.
Murray is an ageing star player of yesteryear, and I would be playing Craig Casey by now, off the bench. His pass is the best of any of Ireland’s top three in the position, and he is a very good all round player. His size compared to murray is of low significance.
I felt there must have been a better option than kicking out of bounds to the 10 metre line. Despite what Flatman says off a line out or scrum pretty much equals about 10-20 metres gained out wide of the attacking team plays a simple effective blocker backdoor play. At that rate England has the play at the 22 with Ireland having to defend all 3 scoring options. Had to be a better option
Beware the Favorites tag.