Cooney fans can't get their heads around their man's Ireland axe

Andy Farrell’s decision to omit John Cooney from the Ireland squad for this month’s resumption of the delayed 2020 Six Nations has unsurprisingly been discussed at great length online. 

The Ulster scrum-half has missed out on a place in the 35-man squad behind Conor Murray, Kieran Marmion and recently qualified Jamison Gibson-Park. The New Zealand-born half-back also pipped his provincial teammate Luke McGrath, which shows the wealth of options Ireland have. 

Cooney was undeniably Ireland’s form No9 at the beginning of 2020 but was only handed three bench appearances during the Six Nations, replacing Murray in all three. He was likely to start in Ireland’s penultimate fixture against Italy before Covid-19 dashed that hope. 

Simon Zebo on his relationship with Irish rugby, the upcoming Champions Cup final and his iconic Lions punishment

Simon Zebo on his relationship with Irish rugby, the upcoming Champions Cup final and his iconic Lions punishment

Since the PRO14 restart in August, Cooney has not been able to recapture the form he was showing earlier in the year and was even dropped to the bench for last month’s final against Leinster. 

His dip in form has been noted by many outraged fans, but his Ireland omission has come as a shock nonetheless with the feeling that he had enough credit in the bank to warrant maintaining his place in the squad. 

Big Dev's warmly-received comeback earlier this year has now been forgotten https://t.co/12IXslePp6

— RugbyPass (@RugbyPass) October 8, 2020

On the subject of form, Murray’s performances over the past twelve months have repeatedly been brought up online. Although the Munster player has a respected reputation at Test level to fall back on that Cooney does not, he has not of late been able to replicate his world-class form of two years ago. 

This has subsequently flagged another conspiratorial issue, that players who are centrally contracted with the Irish Rugby Football Union receive preferential treatment. But given the competition that there is, there are surely other factors that have played a part in Farrell’s decision. 

It is hard to name a player, though, whose Test career has been more scuppered by 2020’s break than Cooney, who has struggled to catch a break in green. He looked to have put the disappointment of missing out on the World Cup behind him last season but he will need to show that resolve again to bounce back. 

amazing how Cooney’s recent form is held up as some criteria for selection, while he was imperious for 18months, while others, centrally contracted+out of form for the same period of time get a pass on recent form. yes, makes complete sense. well at least he got a fair crack…

— Niall Brew (@Brewkid) October 8, 2020

No #teamofus or #shouldertishoulder when selections are based on central contracts and pleasing the media. Should be embarrassed by the scrum half selection.

— Colin McConaghie (@ColinMcConaghie) October 8, 2020

No Cooney? This central contract crap at its peak now

— Alex Jones (@Alexjonesyfifa) October 8, 2020

Great to see Gibson Park and McCloskey in there. However… Coonaldo left out?? Hmmm. Yeah he hasn’t been great since then restart, however, there’s another scrum half who hasn’t been great for 2 years who always seems to get picked and never dropped ?

— Matthew Potter (@buddylove1788) October 8, 2020

So Cooney has 2 bad games and he's out of the picture completely. Conor Murray arguably looked worse than Cooney in those games and gets in. All other POTY nominations Young and Senior in the squad. Something not adding up

— Paul Kenny (@Paulkenny101) October 8, 2020

The form argument doesn’t stack up. Murray out of form for 2 years. Marmion and JGP not been regularly selected to start at club level. So basically they are picked on one game yet anyone who watched Cooney on Friday night saw he was terrific?

— Colin McConaghie (@ColinMcConaghie) October 8, 2020

If Cooney is dropped because of 2 or 3 average performances since rugby came back then you gotta drop Murray who's been average at best for nearly 2 years now.

— Archie (@archiehanna3) October 8, 2020

Only choosing 4 players from the second best team in the pro 14 ?
And Cooney was just nominated for Irish player of the year, but since he had 2 bad games is dropped, while Murray hasn't played well in 2 years and is continually picked!!! https://t.co/zWvS0txzGA

— JJohnston (@jjohnston032) October 8, 2020

Are we planning on talking about John Cooney’s omission from the squad or…? https://t.co/IfpckhspsB

— Tom Home (@_TomHome) October 8, 2020