1
Dagg weighs in on All Blacks' 'confusing as hell' fullback selections
By Ned Lester
All Blacks coach Ian Foster has appeared resolute in his preferred selection of Beauden Barrett at fullback throughout the past 15 months, but a start for Damian McKenzie in the 15 jersey against Uruguay suggested there may be another option on the selection table.
ADVERTISEMENT
McKenzie’s form in Super Rugby Pacific as the architect of the Chiefs attack was destructive. Occupying the first receiver role, the 28-year-old piled pressure on defences with an unpredictable and evasive running game, helping his team to a near-perfect record in the competition.
Continuing that form with the All Blacks, McKenzie has had a run as both primary and secondary playmaker and looked equally effective at each.
The dual playmaker model has challenged the chemistry of New Zealand’s playmakers since 2019’s World Cup, and while McKenzie’s form would see him ready to take centre stage under the bright lights of Paris, the lack of sample size of him playing next to first five-eighth Richie Mo’unga is cause for concern.
A man who has won a World Cup in the 15 jersey, Israel Dagg, says it may be too late for a changing of the guard.
“I just don’t think that Fozzie (Ian Foster) will make that change,” Dagg told SENZ Breakfast. “He’s had four years to make that change and he hasn’t made it. So, I don’t think he’s going to come out in the quarter-final and make that change.
“Look I’ve seen a lot from Damian, don’t get me wrong, I’ve had to change my tune on Damian. I just think with Beauden being at fullback, there wouldn’t be a position for Damian on the bench. But, there has to be a position for Damian on the bench with just how well he is playing.
ADVERTISEMENT
“He’s got that X-factor about him, he’s got that randomness about him. Whether that’s enough to win a big pressure moment in a quarter-final, well time will tell. He has to be in the conversation now.
“I don’t think they’ll change the fullback role. I think they’ll stick tried and true with Richie Mo’unga at ten and Beauden at fullback, and Will Jordan on the wing with Mark Telea on the left.
“I think they’ll just keep it the same as what we saw against Italy. It’s just too late. Why would they do that now?
“It wouldn’t surprise me, because they’ve been confusing as hell with some of the ways that they’ve approached these games. But, I think they’ll stick tried and true to what they’ve done already and it’ll be the same team.”
ADVERTISEMENT
Play McKenzie at 15 your win the World Cup
Mo'unga isn't the problem remember he’s a winner DMac not so much. The team needs a decent 7 and a new 13 and the best 15 not on the wing.
It breaks my heart to see so many genius coaches and selectors among Rugby Pass armchair pundits, whose talents remain tragically unrecognised by New Zealand Rugby and whose informed advice would certainly secure the ABs a fourth World Cup victory if only Ian Foster were to bother reading this thread. Then again, what the f*** do any of us know? I wouldn’t bet against Beauden playing a blinder in the 15th. He’s overdue for a good performance. And he’s surely not lacking for either talent or motivation. Same goes for another brilliant under-achiever, Rieko. Here’s hoping.
Stay asleep ‘champ’.
There's a reason he hasn't had a good game in years pal.
Just look at Foster's record with the ABs, 4 years of bad selections,player's out of positions.If we win this game it won't be because of the coach.
Well said re genius coaches and selectors. Been waiting for someone to say this.
As you say - overdue. You can’t pick a player based on past glory.
I would bet against BB having a blinder - he has not had one vs Tier 1 or NZ SR sides for 2-3-4 years. But Foster has made his bed so too late to change.
But here is hoping
I say put Mckenzie in at 10 for first half and Richie Mo’unga on bench. Assess after first half. Mckenzie deserves a shot.
Yo want to bench Mohunga????? Seriously?????
The QF isn’t the place to experiment.
If Foster doesn’t know who his best XV is, he is even more out of his depth than I previously thought.
Im not an All Black supporter but Barrett has been woeful this WC. To drop Richie would be unfair.
Is Dagg bluffing? D’mac makes a great game changer off the bench. Might just come down to game plan.
If Foster doesn't want McKenzie, France wants him on the bench to replace Ramos in the event of an injury! He’s one of the best fullbacks in this competition, well ahead of BB.
There’s no way DMac will start at 15. The dual playmaker system is Foster’s baby, and Beauden is his boy. The whole dual playmaker thing was designed to accomodate BB in the first place, and I guess Foz will live or die by that decision in these knock-outs.
John the duel playmaker system was designed for Dmac and BB. Sadly Mounga and BB have no chemistry.
It was designed to accommodate Richie, no reason why you couldn't put McKenzie into Fullback and retain dual playmakers. However Beauden with his height and defensive reads won't be axed. In fact the Irish are so strong upfront that the Allblacks need to suck it up and drop Will Jordan and shift Telea onto the right wing and select Leicester on the left. The reserve backs Roigard ALB and six forwards as they go after Ireland upfront. Save Will Jordan and DMac as injury cover.
Think you're right. Just to let BB backseat drive past Mounga and undermine his effectiveness
He’ll go down with Barrett chip kicking us to disaster again and inserting himself as first receiver. Can’t wait for Foster to be gone.
Agree. Can't believe BB still starting 🙄