Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'Destroy all hope': Another Pumas loss would be the 'end of the line' for Foster

Sam Cane of the All Blacks is thanked by Puma players after The Rugby Championship match between the New Zealand All Blacks and Argentina Pumas at Orangetheory Stadium on August 27, 2022 in Christchurch, New Zealand. (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

Less than two weeks after a ringing endorsement from New Zealand Rugby (NZR), All Blacks coach Ian Foster is under renewed pressure following a third successive home loss this season.

ADVERTISEMENT

Foster was confirmed as coach through to next year’s World Cup in the wake of victory over South Africa at Ellis Park, but a first ever home defeat to Argentina in Christchurch has again set alarm bells ringing.

New Zealand media on Monday said another loss to the Pumas in Hamilton on Saturday should be “the end of the line” for Foster.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

“One more loss and Hamilton, for the sake of a legacy 120 years in the making, has to be the terminus,” rugby writer Gregor Paul wrote in the New Zealand Herald.

“Everyone knows that defeat this week will destroy all hope, make it impossible to keep talking about micro improvements in skill execution while lamenting macro failures in decision-making.”

While Foster has been spared the axe, NZR have repeatedly shaken up his staff, sacking two assistant coaches after the home series defeat to Ireland, while bringing in a new forwards coach and selector Joe Schmidt as attack coach and strategist.

NZR seized upon the rousing win at Ellis Park as evidence the changes were working but the Christchurch shock further eroded fans’ confidence in the team.

ADVERTISEMENT

Until last Saturday’s clash, the All Blacks had never lost three successive home Tests in their 119-year history.

Their tally of four losses for the season so far has been surpassed only twice, in 1998 when they lost five under former coach John Hart, and in 1949 when they were defeated six times.

Related

With two Rugby Championship Tests against Australia and away matches against Japan, Wales, Scotland and England to round out the season, more unwanted history could be in store.

“But we have got a lot of faith that some of the things we’re building are paying dividends,” Foster said.

ADVERTISEMENT

Veteran All Blacks lock Sam Whitelock said better execution in Hamilton could right the ship.

“We have to make sure that we are taking every opportunity we get, and with Test match rugby you might only get one or two in a game,” he said.

“It’s something I know we’ll have a good look at over the next couple of days.”

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

8 Comments
J
James 807 days ago

Man look at that photo of Codie Taylor and Fozzie. Looks like Taylor does not like him one bit.

W
Walter 808 days ago

Foster should have been replaced a long time ago, or even better not appointed in 2019 for start. you have to go with the times, modern, different play styles and not not sticking with the same old, same old. As Jase Ryan is there already, add Razor Scott Robertson and you will see a change very soon.

G
GrahamVF 808 days ago

Colin, the AB’s struggle to win WC’s has seen them win almost at will during the four years between even cups only to lose at the sharp end of the tournament. They were lucky to beat a very mediocre French team by one point to win the cup in NZ for the second time. They have only won one cup outside of NZ. Their style of play doesn’t suit knock out rugby and games like SA in Bombela and Argentine are virtually cup finals because of the previous poor results. If they really don’t care win or lose but just go out to play they will dare much better. For the AB’s and the Boks their greatest enemy is their fear of losing.

C
ColinK 808 days ago

Loss to Japan......Loss to Scotland. Loss of our beloved team :-{ its nice for everyone else I guess. I do wonder if the laws of the modern game have been designed in a way that the All Black way of playing just does not work anymore. Get Razor in there and see if its a culture and coaching issue or something much deeper.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 1 hour ago
Scott Robertson explains the new halves pairing for the All Blacks ahead of France

More indecision and excuses from Razor.


You've given a spot at 6 to Finau whom you haven't even had the courage to use off the bench in the last two games. Now the young enforcer is going into a big much with no rugby, we should expect a similar result to how Aumua struggled to impact a game after he'd hardly been given any chances of the bench either.


Weve now dropped a back three player who also wasn't even given any game time off the bench for someone coming in cold when they really need to have been playing constantly to perform at their best. There are just so many better pictures that should have been present rather than this mickey mouse selection.


I really hope Finau can overcome this, it won't be the first time he's had to. How is the bench even made up? Could you not just have included these changes in the article as well? I actually like BB coming back in, it highlights how courageous he is after sitting out through another concussion that could just as easily sent him back into months of symptoms again.


Dmac was also off his game last week, as was Ratima, with the poor platform Razor and his team have been setting the players up with. He needs to freedom to clear his mind from the clutter that saw him make so many bad decisions last week. It will still probably be a net loss for the team performance not having him on from the start but it should be better for them in the long run if he's allowed to just come on late and play his game trying to claw things back for the team.


With Roigard starting that might prove an outlet for the team to actually get on top first however. Along with Ardie busting a gut in his new role and emptying the tank by halftime, and being replaced by another new star, might mean that Dmac is just icing on the cake at the end.

13 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING ‘Not a huge surprise’: Michael Hooper on All Blacks’ win over Ireland ‘Not a huge surprise’: Michael Hooper on All Blacks’ win over Ireland
Search