Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'Don't talk to us about player safety': Manu Tuilagi's Top 14 debut controversy

By Ben Smith
(Source/Canal+)

England international Manu Tuilagi’s debut for Bayonne in the Top 14 has caused a stir after a shot on La Rochelle’s Gregory Alldritt caused the loose forward to have a go at the ref officials.

ADVERTISEMENT

The 33-year-old England centre made his delayed debut for new club and a fast start had Bayonne up 20-0 early. In the 29th minute Tuilagi crossed paths with Alldritt, launching into the loose forward.

The French international was not happy with the tackle and asked the officials to review what appeared to be head-on-head contact, however the response from referee was not what Alldritt wanted to hear.

Referee Luc Ramos told his TMO that “the player is complaining” about the tackle, before responding to Alldritt that “the tackle is legal, it’s your head that tilts forward.”

“It’s not legal. Don’t talk to us about player safety anymore,” Alldritt responded.

Bayonne went on to win comfortably by 37-7 over the two-time European champions however if the tackle had been judged differently, it could have been a contest.

Women’s Rugby World Cup England 2025 ticket application opens 5 November (22 October for Mastercard holders). Register your interest now.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

1 Comment
B
Bull Shark 27 mins ago

I think that ls a reasonable call.


I wonder if world rugby will add “having a big head” to mitigation?


Tuilagi obviously goes low but Alldritt’s big head gets in the way.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 1 hour ago
Will the withdrawal of the ‘top 20’ devalue France’s tour of New Zealand?

That doesn't change anything other than who is responsible, NZR could also choose to promote their domestic final next week and send only the eliminated players north. And in this example both SA and French players are paid by clubs (have a ready of JD Kiwi's 'Rassie' article).


Look, I read a comment from you above, and want to re-iterate if it is not clear, no one is complaining here. This is simply a discussion about what we do about it. France is not unique in resting players for their welfare, everybody has to do it so we understand the situation. Don't worry too much about why it's done because that is irrelevant, it can just as easily be done another way. For now, the sending of competitive B/C squads is arguably 'better' or more interesting than sending the top players (maybe the squad that visited Australia wasn't good enough?), the main point to be raised is Nick's, that doing it that way is hindering the players from reaching their potential and limiting their experiences from playing rugby as a job.


France's previous teams that get smashed when touring NZ were often close to France's best, with at most half a dozen players missing, sometimes key ones, but not generally enough to explain the results. Often I would suggest, the results would be better explained by France playing those players from the Final. That playing really stuffed players on tour wasn't good for their results.


So regardless of why or how, what would you like to see as a French supporter? What has been your most favoured domestic setup of the years? Would you rather watch those players playing at home in the Top 14 or away touring?

633 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING 'Call a spade a spade': Sonny Bill Williams says current All Blacks don't like pressure SBW: All Blacks don't like pressure
Search