Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Edinburgh fall to 14-man Benetton despite red card for former Wasp

By PA
(Photo by Paul Devlin/SNS Group via Getty Images)

Edinburgh failed to take advantage of the early sending-off of Benetton debutant Matteo Minozzi as they were beaten 24-17 by the Italians in the United Rugby Championship.

ADVERTISEMENT

Minozzi was dismissed for dangerous play after just 10 minutes at the Stadio Monigo on Saturday but the hosts – who had two spells with just 13 men – claimed a hard-fought, bonus-point win with tries from Marcus Watson, Sebastian Negri, Niccolo Cannone and Rhyno Smith.

Edinburgh twice fought back to level in the second half with Henry Immelman claiming a double but Smith’s score proved decisive as Benetton held on in a nervy finish.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

It was a gritty showing from the home side, who could hardly have made a worse start.

Charlie Savala landed a penalty to give Edinburgh a 3-0 lead but that was the least of Benetton’s problems as Minozzi was sent off after catching Wes Goosen in the head with a high boot.

The Italians responded well and enjoyed a prolonged spell of possession. They were confident enough to decline a penalty shot at goal and were rewarded when Tomas Albornoz sent Watson over in the corner with a cut-out pass.

Edinburgh were pinned back on their line as Benetton maintained the momentum and their task got harder when Goosen was sinbinned after a series of infringements.

Henry Pyrgos escaped a yellow card after being penalised for a deliberate knock-on but Benetton eventually broke through when Sebastian Negri touched down from a looping Dewaldt Duvenage pass.

ADVERTISEMENT

That gave Benetton a 10-3 interval lead but Edinburgh hit back after the break as a delayed pass from Savala brilliantly opened up the defence for Immelman to skip over a challenge and touch down.

With Savala converting, the scores were brought back to level but parity did not last long.

Benetton reclaimed the initiative when Cannone forced his way over and Albornoz’s first conversion of the afternoon established a seven-point cushion.

Related

Another twist followed as Benetton were reduced to 13 players when Federico Ruzza was sinbinned.

ADVERTISEMENT

Edinburgh made their two-man advantage count as Nick Haining broke a tackle and sent Immelman over out wide on the hour. Savala again added the extras but Edinburgh could not keep up the intensity.

A brilliantly-disguised and well-weighted chip over the top from Duvenage wrongfooted Edinburgh and Smith raced through to touch down for a try Jacob Umaga improved.

Smith became the second Benetton player sinbinned for a high tackle in the closing minutes but the hosts held on.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

f
fl 47 minutes ago
‘The problem with this year’s Champions Cup? Too many English clubs’

"Yes I was the one who suggested to use a UEFA style point. And I guessed, that based on the last 5 years we should start with 6 top14, 6 URC and 4 Prem."

Yes I am aware that you suggested it, but you then went on to say that we should initially start with a balance that clearly wasn't derived from that system. I'm not a mind reader, so how was I to work out that you'd arrived at that balance by dint of completely having failed to remember the history of the competition.


"Again, I was the one suggesting that, but you didn't like the outcome of that."

I have no issues with the outcome of that, I had an issue with a completely random allocation of teams that you plucked out of thin air.

Interestingly its you who now seem to be renouncing the UEFA style points system, because you don't like the outcome of reducing URC representation.


"4 teams for Top14, URC and Prem, 3 teams for other leagues and the last winner, what do you think?"

What about 4 each + 4 to the best performing teams in last years competition not to have otherwise qualified? Or what about a UEFA style system where places are allocated to leagues on the basis of their performance in previous years' competitions?

There's no point including Black Lion if they're just going to get whitewashed every year, which I think would be a possibility. At most I'd support 1 team from the Rugby Europe Super Cup, or the Russian Championship being included. Maybe the best placed non-Israeli team and the Russian winners could play off every year for the spot? But honestly I think its best if they stay limited to the Challenge Cup for now.

39 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Will Bristol's daredevil 'Bears-ball' deliver the trophy they crave? Will Bristol's daredevil 'Bears-ball' deliver the trophy they crave?
Search