Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Unconvincing England open WXV 1 defence with victory against USA

By Martyn Thomas
VANCOUVER, BRITISH COLUMBIA - SEPTEMBER 29: Alex Matthews of England scores her team's fourth try during the WXV1 Pool match between USA and England at BC Place on September 29, 2024 in Vancouver, British Columbia. (Photo by Rich Lam - World Rugby/World Rugby via Getty Images)

England ran in nine tries to kick off their WXV 1 title defence with a 61-21 victory against USA, however the Red Roses were far from convincing in Vancouver.

ADVERTISEMENT

Lark Atkin-Davies, Ellie Kildunne (twice), Georgia Brock, Alex Matthews, Bo Westcombe-Evans, Morwenna Talling, Jess Breach and Ella Wyrwas all crossed the whitewash, while Zoe Harrison added 16 points from the kicking tee.

But this was not a vintage performance and there is much for head coach John Mitchell and his players to work on ahead of matches against New Zealand and Canada.

Video Spacer

‘This Energy Never Stops’ – One year to go until the Women’s Rugby World Cup

With exactly one year to go until Women’s Rugby World Cup England 2025 kicks off
in Sunderland, excitement is sweeping across the host nation in anticipation of what
will be the biggest and most accessible celebration of women’s rugby ever.

Register now for the ticket presale

Video Spacer

‘This Energy Never Stops’ – One year to go until the Women’s Rugby World Cup

With exactly one year to go until Women’s Rugby World Cup England 2025 kicks off
in Sunderland, excitement is sweeping across the host nation in anticipation of what
will be the biggest and most accessible celebration of women’s rugby ever.

Register now for the ticket presale

Mitchell had described his side’s performance in their final warm-up against the Black Ferns a fortnight ago as “patchy” and it was a similar story at BC Place.

Despite ceding territory and possession for much of the match, USA were able to gain some momentum as Alev Kelter (twice) and captain Kate Zackary breached the English defence to briefly cut the deficit to 12 points midway through the second half.

Defending champions England, although much-changed from the side that beat New Zealand at Allianz Stadium, were expected to win against opponents who started the day seven places and almost 22 points adrift of them in the World Rugby Women’s Rankings, and they dominated territory from the off.

That pressure told in the 12th minute as Atkin-Davies profited from a smart lineout move to score in the right corner.

ADVERTISEMENT

Harrison added an impressive conversion and it looked as though the Red Roses might canter into the distance as Kildunne went on a trademark slaloming run minutes later.

Fixture
WXV 1
USA Womens
21 - 61
Full-time
England Womens
All Stats and Data

The electric full-back picked up the ball deep inside her own half and used the presence of debutant Westcombe-Evans to her right to step past McKenzie Hawkins and Bulou Mataitoga before straightening and beating the former again en route to the line.

Harrison slotted the extras once more but while England kept up their pressure on the American line they were unable to find a way over it.

And that allowed Kelter to give the Women’s Eagles hope of a comeback with nine minutes of the half remaining, with a moment every bit as magical as that produced by Kildunne.

ADVERTISEMENT

On a rare foray into the English 22 Kelter weighted the perfect chip over the defensive line before racing onto the bouncing ball and evading the attentions of both Jess Breach and Lucy Packer on her way over the whitewash.

Hawkins converted but the Red Roses reasserted their dominance at the end of the half with two quickfire tries that took the match away from their opponents.

The first of those came from an error from Kelter as the Olympian fumbled the ball on her own line, under pressure from Packer, and Brock pounced to grab her first Test try on her maiden start.

Player Carries

1
Hope Rogers
10
2
Rachel Johnson
9
3
Bulou Mataitoga
8

And England secured the try bonus point on the stroke of half-time as Player of the Match Matthews, in her first match as captain, glided through a gap and over the line with the clock in the red.

USA started the second half with real belief and breached the Red Roses defence inside four minutes of the restart as Kelter went over again.

Their momentum was stalled somewhat when Westcombe-Evans slid in to hold off the covering Mataitoga and mark her first cap with a try.

But Harrison’s conversion attempt struck the upright and there was the hint of a contest when USA captain Zackary came steaming through from an attacking lineout to score.

Hawkins added her third conversion of the night to make the score 33-21 but it signalled the introduction of the English cavalry and the Red Roses accelerated away in the final quarter.

Talling, Breach and Kildunne, again, crossed the whitewash before replacement scrum-half Wyrwas picked off an interception in the final minute to round off a comprehensive, if not totally comfortable, victory.

One year to go until the Women’s Rugby World Cup!
With exactly one year to go until Women’s Rugby World Cup England 2025 kicks off in Sunderland, excitement is sweeping across the host nation in anticipation of what will be the biggest and most accessible celebration of women’s rugby ever. Register now for the ticket presale.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

1 Comment
B
BC 1 hr ago

Nine tries and unconvincing? Agree that it wasn't vintage but the expansive game that the Red Roses are trying to play can be error strewn and work needs to be done on the wide passing to ensure wingers keep their depth. There were though some flashes of brilliance. The debutants did not really put their hands up for starting positions and may not feature again this tournament. England conceded a try from a chip ahead when once again, like the BFs first try at Twickenham, the bounce of the ball went the attackers way. Kildunne tried it herself a few minutes later and just as it looked as if she would regather and likely score it bounced away from her. C'est la rugby.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

T
TT 51 minutes ago
Despite some positives Razor's first Rugby Championship was a failure

RE B.cup2,


ABs, finally an 80min performance. Back to where they were when Foster handed them over to Razor?? No way, get real, that is 1 80min game out of 9 so far this season. & that was V 10th ranked team in the world.


The biggest failure is the lack of new AB development. That would have made losses so much more worthy.


As Tuipulotu, Cane, Roigard & TJ were 1st picks when available all season there’s nothing to say the same won’t be the case for the Nth tour. So the big question is what's been developed for the hardest AB Nth tour in history??? Yes, Aumua, Tosi, Sititi. But now only V Japan to do the others needed, i.e. alot!

 

{starters}

1 {Williams} / Tu’ungafasi &?- nil back up has been run


2 {Taylor}/ Aumua &?- nil back up has been run


3 {Lomax}/ Tosi &?- nil

4,5 Locks {Vaa’I, S.Barrett ] P.Tuipulotu &?- just micro time for Barry


6,7,8 Loose forwards { Sititi, A.Savea } &?- perpetually injured Blackadder but nil SR star H.Sotutu


9 {Roigard } & Ratima & - chatty TJ. Covered


10 D.McK & BB &?- just micro time for Barry


12 & 13 ALB R. Ioane &?- just micro time for SR star Proctor but zero SR performer Havili run!!


14 Reece &? - zero time for SR star Narawa

 

11 {C.Clarke} / &?- Tele’a's slower & VERY low impact

 

15 {W.Jordan} & J&B.Barrett

 

 

Its way too late & the real Robertson failure but V Japan MUST be STARTING game time & development for,

(2)Aumua, (3)Tosi, (4)Barry, (5)Tuipulotu, (8)Sititi, (6)Sotutu, (9)Ratima (10)Plummer, (13)Proctor, (14) Narawa, (15) Stevenson.


Yes even if bizarrely not squad members.


But instead we get chat about, you guessed it, 9th ranked SR Crusaders family, Fihaki, Havili, Fainga’anuku, Bell, perpetually injured Blackadder and, no joke, Noah Hotham (watch his show in Fiji game & that Crusaders  SR circus ).


In a NZR review Robertson needs to be told exactly as per this article. Management, selection & results failure. Immediate improvement of HIS, & gang, performance needed.


SR success as anyone awake new pre his appointment, irrelevant. But the delusional chat about Crusaders call ups show he's stuck in the past.

 

Here we go … wait for it … the Razor Occult excuses (ie apparently such win’y ... but now whinny folk)

9 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING All Blacks player ratings vs Australia | Bledisloe Cup II All Blacks player ratings vs Australia
Search