Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

England will be the blockbuster, but Scotland is the banana peel for the All Blacks

(Photo by ANDY BUCHANAN/AFP via Getty Images)

The All Blacks head into their Northern tour a much more settled outfit after coming home with a wet sail through the most turbulent home season in recent memory.

ADVERTISEMENT

The worst seems over as the side has rapidly improved on the back of a historic home series loss to Ireland, claiming a Rugby Championship title for the second straight season and third straight SANZAAR title.

That seismic series loss to Ireland led to a tense, but ultimately much-needed second look at where this team was headed, which in all likelihood, was a quarterfinal exit in France next year.

Video Spacer
Video Spacer

With the benefit of hindsight, the assistants do seem to have played a massive part in this unravelling.

Tasked with most of the field work during trainings, honing the finer details and holding players to account in the search of perfect execution, the assistants play a much larger role in the machine than most realise.

When those conversations go amiss and details aren’t corrected, players left unsure or confused, it can go horribly wrong and yet no one in charge can quite figure out why.

The All Blacks were a talented side that look disjointed, lacking technical accuracy in just about everything, and most notably, looking rigid and lacking ingenuity in how they wanted to play.

ADVERTISEMENT

The promotion of Joe Schmidt from selector to assistant has clearly had the desired impact with the former Ireland head coach a stickler for accuracy and minor details that led to exponential returns.

Unfortunately for Ian Foster, he is in a lose-lose situation now in terms of his stature with the public.

Given how his hand-picked coaching team crashed and burned, if they go on to win the World Cup, most will be grateful to Jason Ryan and Schmidt for rescuing the sinking ship.

If they lose, many will lay fault on Foster for digging a hole too deep to get out of.

Although the lack of minutes for fringe players has been a criticism, the side has benefitted from continuity in the selections.

ADVERTISEMENT

They needed to build cohesion and the only way to do that is to continue to play, ideally under direction from a taskmaster who can identify and sort out the issues.

Rieko Ioane went from a ball-hogging, artificial midfielder to a genuine No 13 with world class touch in the space of a couple months. Will Jordan finally got enough ball to ensure New Zealand’s best rugby player could actually make an impact.

Richie Mo’unga finally got things clicking and began to play with loose freedom, in a good way, with the shackles of doubt and indecision removed. David Havili showed flashes and they finally used his skills in a way that suit, instead of asking him to truck up carries into much larger midfielders.

Jordie Barrett got a run at No 12 and looked like the bruising option that has been sorely missed. His line running was direct, his carries were strong and his hits in defence were stronger.

However, the sample size is too small to rubber stamp a permanent position move for Barrett. The All Blacks need that kind of performance against the likes of South Africa, France or England, sides that are defensively up for it.

The Twickenham test against a fit Manu Tuilagi would be a golden opportunity for Barrett to solidify his midfield credentials.

Beauden Barrett has been playing at fullback a little more, even starting there in the final test against the Wallabies, yet no one is talking about whether ‘dual playmakers’ work or not, a sign things are clicking.

Up front the sea change in the front row worked wonders immediately, picking hard workers who can nail their roles across the park. This lift in energy from a younger, more mobile front row immediately raised the standard of All Black play.

Samisoni Taukei’aho has been the find of the season for the All Blacks, without a doubt. His power in the carry left opposition forwards reeling, giving front foot ball while his accurate throwing at lineout time cemented a starting role going forward.

The makings of a champion side are there, but bigger scalps must be taken on the path to the top. They won’t get a chance to avenge their losses to France or Ireland until the World Cup, and will have only one more against South Africa.

This end of year tour with tests against Japan, Wales, Scotland and England can help restore the All Blacks’ reputation in Europe again.

The 2018 tour featured a win over England by a whisker, before a shock defeat to Ireland in Dublin.

The 2021 edition started well with a 54-16 defeat of Wales, albeit outside the international window, before crushing back-to-back defeats to Ireland and France to finish the year.

Their last dominant end of year tour in Europe came five years ago, in 2017, when they handsomely beat France, got past Scotland in a tight one and blitzed Wales.

Rieko Ioane scooped up the Breakthrough Player of the Year award, while Beauden Barrett bagged his second consecutive World Player of the Year crown.

It has been awhile since the All Blacks swept all before them up North and that outcome this year would still be considered a pleasant surprise in New Zealand.

Most would pick the England test as the toughest of this tour, and it will be tough, but Scotland is the less fancied opponent that can cause problems going under the radar, even without mercurial flyhalf Finn Russell.

Scotland were one Stuart Hogg-miracle try and conversion away from a historic win back in 2017, before a Barrett cover tackle scuppered Scottish hopes at the death by barrelling the fullback over the sideline.

This Edinburgh test has been a long time coming and this Scotland side has been strong in recent years, matching and beating a faltering England side twice, even beating France in Paris in last year’s Six Nations.

In 2020 during Russell’s first enforced sabbatical, the combination of Adam Hastings and Stuart Hogg worked incredibly well during the Six Nations, with Hastings offering similar playmaking upside in attack without the inevitable catastrophic plays Russell can bring.

Why Hastings was then dropped when Russell returned in 2021 was a mystery, but if he is back at No 10 he will do more good than harm for Scotland.

England will be the blockbuster test, but Scotland is the banana peel Foster does not want to step on right before the big dance at Twickenham.

ADVERTISEMENT

Boks Office | Episode 37 | Six Nations Round 4 Review

Cape Town | Leg 2 | Day 2 | HSBC Challenger Series 2025 | Full Day Replay

Gloucester-Hartpury vs Bristol Bears | PWR 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

Boks Office | Episode 36 | Six Nations Round 3 Review

Why did Scotland's Finn Russell take the crucial kick from the wrong place? | Whistle Watch

England A vs Ireland A | Full Match Replay

Kubota Spears vs Shizuoka BlueRevs | JRLO 2024/2025 | Full Match Replay

Watch now: Lomu - The Lost Tapes

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

3 Comments
C
Chris 886 days ago

England will be an interesting test. Eddie probably been prepping for years.

S
Simon 886 days ago

Typically disrespectful article basically saying Japan and Wales will be warm up matches!! NZ's easiest game will be the England game as Eddie Jones cannot select a starting 15 if it slapped him in the face. His selcetion tactics seriously undermine England's potential and that is why until Eddie goes after the World Cup, England will have the odd great win but will be turned over by several teams and will not go beyond the QF at the world cup.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

P
Poorfour 1 hour ago
Antoine Dupont undergoes surgery on injured knee ahead of long absence

So “it wasn’t foul play because it wasn’t foul play” is - to you - not only an acceptable answer but the only possible answer?


I would hope that the definition of foul play is clear enough that they can say “that wasn’t foul play - even though it resulted in a serious injury - because although player A did not wrap with the right arm, he entered the ruck through the gate and from a legal angle at a legal height, and was supporting his own weight until player B entered the ruck behind him and pushed him onto player C’s leg” or “that wasn’t foul play although players D and E picked player F out of a ruck, tipped him upside down and dropped him on his shoulder because reasons.”


Referees sometimes offer a clear explanation, especially when in discussion with the TMO, but they don’t always, especially for incidents that aren’t reviewed on field. It’s also a recognised flaw in the bunker system that there isn’t an explanation of the card decisions - I’d personally prefer the bunker to prepare a short package of the best angles and play back to the ref their reasoning, with the ref having the final say, like an enhanced TMO. It would cost a few more seconds, but would help the crowd to understand.


Greater clarity carries with it risks - not least that if the subsequent feedback is at odds with the ref’s decision they run the risk of harassment on social media - but rugby is really struggling to show that it can manage these decisions consistently, and offering a clear explanation after the fact would help to ensure better consistency in officiating in future.

9 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ How to solve a problem like Welsh rugby How to solve a problem like Welsh rugby
Search