Northern | US

New Zealand put Scotland to sword despite Ewan Ashman hat-trick

Beauden Barrett scores for NZ - PA
Comments
45 Comments

Ewan Ashman became only the fifth player ever to score a hat-trick against New Zealand, but it was not enough to prevent Scotland going down to yet another defeat in this fixture.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Scots sensed an opportunity to end their long wait for a first victory over the All Blacks after Edinburgh hooker Ashman notched a treble to keep them within three points of their visitors at the end of an epic, seven-try first half.

But the hosts lost their way after the break as Dave Rennie’s on-song side closed out an ultimately comfortable 43-21 Nations Championship triumph.

VIDEO

Scotland, who were given something of a reality check as they were unable score a point in the second half, have now failed to defeat New Zealand in 34 meetings since they first locked horns in 1905.

There was a moment’s applause ahead of kick-off in memory of former Edinburgh captain Ally Donaldson, who died in September, and long-serving All Blacks head of security Logan Cadwallader, who died in Edinburgh last weekend.

Fixture
Nations Championship
Scotland
21 - 43
Full-time
New Zealand
All Stats and Data

Since Scotland last played, against Fiji almost four months, New Zealand – ranked second in the world – had been involved in 10 matches, including a gruelling four-game series against South Africa.

The battle-hardened visitors went ahead in the fourth minute as back-rower Wallace Sititi capitalised on some slack Scottish defending to score off a lineout. Damian McKenzie was off target with the conversion.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Scots responded in the eighth minute as Ashman squeezed over from a lineout, with Finn Russell converting.

After All Blacks wing Will Jordan was held up on the line by Ben White, the visitors regained the lead in the 16th minute as prop Ethan de Groot bulldozed his way through three Scots to notch from close range. McKenzie converted.

Hooker Codie Taylor then scored from a lineout maul in the 20th minute, but McKenzie’s conversion was short of the required distance as the All Blacks entered the second quarter with a 10-point advantage.

Scotland responded strongly and New Zealand flanker Peter Lakai was sin-binned in the 23rd minute for repeated infringements.

ADVERTISEMENT

Within three minutes, the deficit was reduced to three as Ashman powered through after brilliant work by Rory Darge and Sione Tuipulotu, with Russell adding the extras.

Just as Gregor Townsend’s side looked to be in the ascendancy, 14-man New Zealand reasserted their authority as Beauden Barrett found a gap after being fed by McKenzie, who duly added the extras.

New Zealand were struggling to maintain their discipline amid the mayhem and Sititi was sin-binned for cynical play just as Lakai returned to the fray in the 33rd minute.

The hosts made the extra man count in the 37th minute as Ashman became the first Scot to score a hat-trick against the All Blacks following another lineout maul and Russell again converted to make it 24-21 to the visitors at the break.

Scotland were unable to maintain their first-half intensity after the restart, however.

Once restored to their full quota of 15, New Zealand seized control of the scoreboard with a couple of quickfire tries, scored by Josh Moorby and Barrett, either side of Scotland captain Tuipulotu being sin-binned in the 51st minute for multiple team infringements.

The Scots’ hopes of a fightback were all but extinguished in the 68th minute as substitute Asafo Aumua capitalised on more dismal defending at a lineout.

1 YEAR TO GO - RWC27

1 YEAR TO GO 

The countdown is on until the biggest Men’s Rugby World Cup ever kicks off in Australia. Go All Out and secure your seats with tickets now available! 

BUY TICKETS NOW

Watch Nations Championship - Round 5 LIVE

Hemispheres collide in the new Nations Championship. Stream live, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV.

Watch on RPTV
Starts 4th July 2026 - USA only.
ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

45 Comments
P
PMcD 3 days ago

The one takeaway from this weekend is that SA, NZ & FRA are in a league of their own and I doubt the others will live with them. This contest is basically a test between those 3 teams.

S
Spew_81 3 days ago

It will be interesting to see if Ireland has improved. They had dropped off a bit earlier in the year.


The same with England.

P
PMcD 3 days ago

Whilst the AB’s have clearly improved their defence, I thought Brace was very favourable to the AB’s with high tackles and another ref could take a very different view.

B
BK 3 days ago

Look. If you watch this Rennie team and how they play - only Boks can really counter them. How many games have been close in the 1st half and then blown out … France really stayed with them in June but that was this regime’s first game. Italy really tried but if they could score tries against Boks can you imagine … what happens against other teams …

P
PMcD 3 days ago

I think SA & FRA are the only teams that will live with the ABs at the moment, those 3 have all pulled away from the rest over the last 6 months.

O
Over the sideline 4 days ago

The ABs looked very down the whole game plus pre and post match. Very clearly affected by the loss of their security guy.

B
B 4 days ago

In the big games, Scotland still can't get it over the line in the last quarter


The constant theme under Townsend


A 60 mins team against an 80 mins team

P
PMcD 3 days ago

The drop off in quality of the bench was/is noticeable.


They have a very competitive starting XV but they lack strength across the wider 23. It’s only going to get harder for them with the new eligibility rules, so will be harder to replace as that team ages out.

E
Eric Elwood 4 days ago

It was a controlled win by the ABs. Scotland (and Glasgow) can eek yellows out of attacks and feed off them which kept them in touch. ABs eased away.

80-85% performance after a tough week, leaving emotional energy for the big England match and a potential final the week after.

J
JW 4 days ago

What a terrible broadcast. What’s changed in Scotland? Didn’t even catch the sideline haka on our feed. Crowd was louder than the ref, which was kinda nice the amount he was involved (and not having to care about some of his rough decisions).


The July window set a new bar as far as coverage of test match footy was concerned but this was so average, and then combined with the stop start nature…


Credit to Scotland’s starting effort, they were sublime and showed the All Blacks where the bar is at execution wise. NZ just far too strong though.

P
PMcD 3 days ago

ITV won the rights to the Nations Championship, so it was a complete change of filming/broadcast providers for these games.

B
Bruiser 4 days ago

Should have piled on 60 points but lost our ambition. Ratimas 20 minutes of pointless and inept kicking and indecision around the ruck killed off a chance to turn the knife

u
unknown 4 days ago

Yiu have no idea what you're talking about do you it's like you have zero rugby knowledge at all

O
Over the sideline 4 days ago

Disagree. Roigatd was less than impressive last night and Ratima increased the pace of decision making from the nase.

J
JC 4 days ago

Ratima played to game plan. The job was to close it out and win not force it. Scotland didnt score during that time. His kicking game worked, that’s test rugby.

J
JW 4 days ago

Don’t know how you can’t see they didn’t have the heart for it Bruiser, blaming Ratima is just a cope for your lack of attention or sleep imo.


I was expecting similar myself but it was only really at the end and after where I realized what the team hand been going through.

d
d 4 days ago

Preston hasn’t impressed either, finding a test-level backup for Roigard must be a priority for Rennie.

B
Blackmania 4 days ago

The match that really shows just how much the All Blacks have improved this year. Without being brilliant, simply by being good, they beat Scotland away from home by more than 20 points, scoring seven tries in the process!

Scotland had put in some outstanding performances throughout the tournament, beating France and England, winning comfortably in Argentina.

This All Blacks team no longer relies on individual performances to be competitive. And that’s something we hadn’t really seen for several years. The team’s overall collective performance has improved enormously under Rennie and Blair.

Of course, this still needs to be confirmed… There will be another major test in England, followed by one final game to round off the year.

P
PMcD 3 days ago

Good post and I agree.


The forwards were collectively much improved and this was their best game under Rennie. The scrum & lineout were better, the inner defence to stop the Scotland power runners was outstanding and they were much tighter in defence and they carried the ball well, especially Sititi.


It was another good performance from DMac at 10 and he’s really starting to look comfortable playing in this system and orchestrating the attack.


If they play like this vs ENG, they will have too much for them and it will confirm how much this team have grown under Rennie.


However add in Williams, Frizzell, Savea, Love and probably Clarke and this matchday 23 will still improve before RWC 2027 and the best is yet to come. If they also bring back Smith (as bench 9), this really could be interesting.

J
JW 4 days ago

The match that really shows just how much the All Blacks have improved this year.

Which pretty much is just coming down to the key selection mistake made last year with BB.


Sititi’s return to form has also been instrumental.

C
ColinK 4 days ago

Agreed BM. Most encouragingly that went to set piece dominance in the 2nd half, scrumming very well and doing great work in the lineout. Holland and Scooter played really well, and Grooter had a great game. We know we have a great attack game but this area was a weakness in the RGR so good to see them go there. Lot of work still to do but a good trajectory. England as you say is the real test now. Quite possibly Ireland on that finals weekend.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close