Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Ex-England No10 explains how Australia can exploit 'feeble' Argentina

Wallabies' Zane Nonggorr, Billy Pollard and Harry Wilson look on against the Springboks in Perth (Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

Former England player Stuart Barnes has claimed that a 3-0 British and Irish Lions series win next year over Australia would be “catastrophic” for the sport down under, but he isn’t yet writing off the Wallabies’ poor Rugby Championship campaign.

ADVERTISEMENT

The retired fly-half believes that rugby union is in dire need of a competitive Australia, especially as their recent efforts in heavy back-to-back defeats to South Africa in Brisbane and Perth left so much to be desired.

However, Barnes suggested there is one particular area where Joe Schmidt’s side can start their fightback towards credibility when they take on Argentina in La Plata next Saturday. Writing his latest column for The Times, he suggested: “The Wallabies have a chance by taking on the Pumas at their traditional game. Argentina were once a stronghold of the scrum.

Video Spacer

Rassie and the Springboks next on the All Blacks hit list | The Rugby Championship

Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
Duration 10:32
Loaded: 0.00%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time 10:32
 
1x
    • Chapters
    • descriptions off, selected
    • captions off, selected
    • en (Main), selected
    Video Spacer

    Rassie and the Springboks next on the All Blacks hit list | The Rugby Championship

    “It can be argued that the absence of scrums for an hour in Wellington, and the plethora of them in Auckland a week later helped explain a thumping, great turnaround (along with a clear pattern of the Kiwis kicking complacency out of their system).

    “The very thought of Australia dominating Argentina’s scrum would have been a joke a few years ago but while the South Americans have lost their edge, Australia have a potentially decent scrummaging pack.

    Fixture
    Rugby Championship
    Argentina
    19 - 20
    Full-time
    Australia
    All Stats and Data

    “Angus Bell, coming back from injury, had a fine first 40 minutes against the Springboks until a cut above the eye ended his comeback Test match. He is a strong ball carrier but, more importantly, a fine technician in the front row.

    “On the tighthead side, the charismatic Taniela Tupou – the Tongan Thor – is one of those players whose presence can lift those around him. Considering Allan Alaalatoa captains the Wallabies from prop, the front row is a potential match-winner.

    ADVERTISEMENT

    “It is not beyond the bounds that Australia will gain a psychological and tactical advantage in the scrums. Whereas South Africa are up there with the All Blacks as the best scrum, Argentina are a feeble reminder of a fabled past.”

    Barnes gave his scrum verdict after seeing Los Pumas hammered 10-42 by the All Blacks seven days after they produced a surprise 38-30 round one win. He began his column with a focus on the dire long-term situation the Wallabies find themselves in.

    “The Lions can help the Wallaby cause with a series to ignite the spluttering union presence but the home side has to be good enough to make a fight of the three games. A Lions whitewash would be catastrophic – the word is chosen more with care than hype – for one of the world’s great nations of the last 40 years.

    “For the sake of world rugby and the Lions, let’s hope Joe Schmidt masterminds some sort of Australian comeback, starting next Saturday.”

    ADVERTISEMENT

    ADVERTISEMENT

    South Africa v Argentina | World Rugby U20 Championship | Extended Highlights

    France v New Zealand | World Rugby U20 Championship | Extended Highlights

    England v Wales | World Rugby U20 Championship | Extended Highlights

    Tattoos & Rugby: Why are tattoos so popular with sportspeople? | Amber Schonert | Rugby Rising Locker Room Season 2

    Lions Share | Episode 3

    Zimbabwe vs Kenya | Rugby Africa Cup Semi Final | Full Match Replay

    USA vs Spain | Men's International | Full Match Replay

    Portugal vs Ireland | Men's International | Full Match Replay

    Trending on RugbyPass

    Comments

    11 Comments
    W
    Wayneo 327 days ago

    Escuchaste eso Argentina?


    Los Australianos piensan que eres débil.


    Quizás el scrum argentino pueda compartir este chiste...

    C
    Carlos 327 days ago

    We do read and speak English, you know?

    J
    Jimmy 327 days ago

    This article was good for a morning laugh. Just as well JS doesnt pay much attention to the feeble Stuart Barnes. The Wobblies will be desperate, but Los Pumas will have the wood over them for both games.

    H
    Hellhound 327 days ago

    Feeble Argentina? If they are feeble, then Australia must be nearly non existent. They are quite big mouth, considering Argentina is most likely, definitely going to kick their b*tts. It's 2 home games for the Pumas. They may be inconsistent, but Australia isn't the AB's and the Pumas isn't weak. What excuses will Australia have when the "Feeble" Argies goes back to back on them? Argentina will win both tests. That statement is without taste and won't age well. Don't worry, it will only age a week before reality sets in, then another week when horror joins the table. How are you going to explain the "Feeble" comment to the media then? Fans and haters alike, together with the media is going to rip the Aussies apart. That was a very distasteful choice of words and won't be harmful to Argentina, but definitely to the Australians. Not a good move son.

    O
    OJohn 327 days ago

    Stuart Barnes is English oh wonderous genius .....

    C
    Carlos 327 days ago

    Feeble Pumas? What is he suggesting? The Wallabies should purposely drop balls to cause scrums?


    I’m not so sure the Wallabies scrum is any better than the Pumas, regardless of how poor they truly are in relative terms.


    But Barnes is back at his obnoxious best. Never mind.

    B
    Blanco 327 days ago

    Typical Barnes. Argentina dropped a little in the second test, NZ were outstanding. The reasons Argentina dominated the first match had a lot of reasons: not lack of scrummaging.

    In test 2. I thought ref Piardi's decision to make an example of Argentina deep in their 22 for the five second rule was ridiculous.

    You either make your point in a less dangerous part if the pitch (10 metre line) or you verbally make it clear that a penalty is imminent.

    H
    Hellhound 327 days ago

    Pumas will go double at home against the Aussies. I can't wait for the excuses when they lose both tests against "feeble" Argentina.

    Load More Comments

    Join free and tell us what you really think!

    Sign up for free
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Latest Features

    Comments on RugbyPass

    C
    CO 49 minutes ago
    Scott Robertson's disappointing Ruben Love decision

    Will Jordan is as good as any fullback in the world and at six foot two is backed up by younger, larger talent at fullback like Sullivan and Spencer. Ruben Love is a slightly larger but less eccentric version of McKenzie at this stage in his development.


    McKenzie, he's like a wildly energetic dog that doesn't stop being a pup until the age of six.


    McKenzie is no longer the young pup, he's entering his best years as a ten, he's been a test player for nine years and that's really starting to produce under Razor.


    NZ sometimes pigeon holes players early and can be blind to the McKenzie late bloomers, McKenzie is a loyal, passionate Allblack and it's only because of a double world player of the year that he's not starting at ten each time for the Allblacks.


    For those that get to meet McKenzie he's a relaxed, friendly, courteous and composed person and he is looking likely to peak as a ten at RWC.


    However, McKenzie isn't really the guy we need to replace and Love is the nearest thing NZ has as a younger model. Instead NZ needs to be looking for a guy with the size and height of Beauden, Pollard, Farrell, Larkham, Sexton.


    Carter was a freak at ten and McKenzies also really special but the games now dominated by first fives that are noticeably over six foot. A smaller guy needs to be freakishly talented.


    Love is a handy player that plays well at both fullback and ten, he's got a really good mindset and a superb footballer like McKenzie but I'm a crowded fullback field that still has Jordie Barret around to fill in, Love needs to spend a lot more time at ten, a position that NZ is struggling with for world class depth.


    As for Naitoa, he needs a run at six, he's a lock that's really better suited to six.


    The French are a handful and the Allblacks can really build a strong year by winning the third test, once the games under control then Love should be swapped with McKenzie to have his chance at ten.

    8 Go to comments
    LONG READ
    LONG READ Iconic Lions moments of the professional era: 5-1 Iconic Lions moments of the professional era: 5-1