1
Ex-Ireland player criticises return of 'proven doper' Aphiwe Dyantyi
By Liam Heagney
Former Ireland midfielder Gordon D’Arcy has heavily criticised the recent return of Aphiwe Dyantyi with the Sharks after the expiry of his four-year ban for doping. It was shortly before the 2019 Rugby World Cup when the then Springboks winger tested positive for multiple anabolic steroids and he was eventually banned in December 2020.
ADVERTISEMENT
The World Rugby breakthrough player of the year in 2018, who at the time was contracted to the Lions in Johannesburg, pleaded guilty but claimed he did not knowingly take a banned substance. However, the South African Institute for Drug-Free Sport insisted that Dyantyi’s denials hadn’t met the burden of proof.
With his suspension now over, Dyantyi has returned to playing, making four appearances in recent weeks for the Sharks. The initial three games came on his club’s European tour to Ireland (vs Leinster), England (vs Ospreys) and Italy (vs Zebre Parma), but D’Arcy was struck by the reception that the now 29-year-old received when he made his home debut last Saturday for the Durban-based franchise.
“Instead of lauding the smash and grab by Connacht, it was the return of Aphiwe Dyantyi that caught the eye for me,” wrote the retired D’Arcy in his weekly Irish Times rugby column. “What really struck me was that his return was so celebrated by the home crowd and the home broadcaster.
“Dyantyi did very little of note in the game and yet he was interviewed post-match. Nobody was in the least bit sheepish or ashamed about welcoming back a proven doper.
Watch it here ???https://t.co/qBKZo1Rj4B
— RugbyPass (@RugbyPass) November 22, 2023
“Time and again, South Africa’s record with this stuff is questionable, to say the least. Just this summer, their playmaker Elton Jantjies had to withdraw from the wider Springbok World Cup squad after testing positive for an anabolic steroid.
“In 2020, former South Africa hooker Mahlatse ‘Chiliboy’ Ralepelle was banned for eight years after he tested positive for a banned substance for the third time in a decade.
ADVERTISEMENT
“These aren’t obscure players. Dyantyi was World Rugby’s breakthrough player of the year in 2018. Jantjies and Ralepelle both played for the Springboks on and off for over a decade. Imagine equivalent Irish players serving long doping bans. Imagine the kind of reception they would get when they came back.
“Yet here’s Rassie Erasmus on Dyantyi earlier this summer. ‘I really hope that he comes back with a bang and he does really well for the Sharks. And I hope we can one day pick him for the Springboks again.’
“Even with the caveat that everyone deserves a second chance, this type of ringing endorsement for a proven doper contributes towards a greying culture of cheating.”
D’Arcy, who was capped 82 times by Ireland and once by the British and Irish Lions in 2005, went on to note how South Africa were threatened with having to play their recent Rugby World Cup knockout games with a ban on displaying their national flag and playing their national anthem due to their government’s non-compliance with the World Anti-Doping Agency code.
ADVERTISEMENT
“Dyantyi’s major asset is his speed… Yes, Dyantyi has served a four-year ban. But he does not lose the physical benefits of doping. His speed is artificially increased and that still gives him a comparative advantage against players who have made a decision to stay within the rules of our sport.
“South Africa won so many supporters over the last two World Cup cycles. As back-to-back world champions, they should be setting the gold standard when it comes to doping.
“Instead, they have chosen a more laissez-faire attitude to enforcement and there doesn’t seem to be a culture of condemnation. Instead, the message to young players seems to be – cheat and you will be okay. That can’t be good enough.”
- Click here to read Gordon D’Arcy’s Irish Times column
No it’s not. By the way, she says hello and can you please try harder to satisfy her next time.
Ag well well a blowup doll is definitely better than your blougat, gap toothed, meths addled vrou
Haha. But you still have to blow up your doll to have a good time.
I’m sitting in East Sheen London watching a movie on MTV typing on my macbook with my beamer cabrio outside while you are sitting in a counsel kiwi hut supplied by a broke surrender monkey government with sewerage running like a river outside your front door - enjoy
South Africa’s back to back world cups are built on a regime of institutional doping. Ireland and France’s recent success are also built off doping.
It is literally everywhere in professional sport.
You really think Siya could come back from what is usually a 9 month recovery after surgery, to play elite international rugby, without anabolic steroids? Physiologically impossible.
Typical talentless reply from the master of misunderstanding the gist of the thread. You go preach to your long suffering family the ones truly looking for a rope to hang themselves from to escape the relentless drudgery of listening to your delusions of grandeur. You can spend christmas day sat up on your rocking horse like Napoleon and pontificate on the virtues of a better tomorrow without ‘drug cheating’ and ‘the unfairness of life’ etc. Thanks for the lively chat you simpering nonce I’ve got some code to write for the military industrial complex can’t take the whole day off we’re not on a 4 day week yet.
Maybe what you should do is go find a rope and spare your family the shame of having you around for Christmas…
Where you from then - too embarrassed to tell us aren’t you. I love insulting virtue signallers that say things like ‘I also find it shocking that a cheater is welcomed back so cheerfully. I don’t care about the origin, I wish the sport to be clean.’ These are the statements of a snivelling preeeeeek. Have you read all my comments?!? If so you’re not only stupid but also insane - you need to get a paying job it’ll make you much less prone to delusions of grandeur about your intelligence or the intelligence of others. Like us saffers love shouting at the likes of you - FU$%EN TW@T!
It’s unfortunate that all of these players are Black/POC. It’s a complex situation due to childhood malnutrition/difficult socio-economic context, and all of this may have driven some of these players to make bad decisions. There is an obvious tinge of racism to Darcy’s comments and that is very troubling, but seems to be par for the course in Ireland’s hatred of all things South Africa. They prefer their foreigners to be from New Zealand’s North Island, like half their backline. Whether Darcy likes it or not, SA is going to give Dyanti a second chance, it cannot afford politically and morally to just consign a black player to the trash heap.
There’s definitely some truth in what you’re saying here.
However, on a personal level, I’d hammer any drug cheats equally. I’m English and if it was (say) Farrell or Marcus Smith, I’d have equal condemnation for it.
You’re right in that it is sad that socio-economic factors play such a huge part in this. Equally, it is still cheating and we don’t need players full of roid rage charging at fellow pros.
It’s simply not safe.
Suddenly old Gordon is an expert also lol. Who told him that the effects of the drugs remain forever. Shame
rugby fans around the world need to stop allowing the springboks to live rent free inside their heads… I guess they just cant handle being bested by an African team, over and over again
I mean I’m a rare English person that actually has a lot of love for the Boks.
Roid rage drug cheats, not so much.
A whole article of tears because no one cared that Connacht beat the Sharks 🤣🤣🤣
Hang on a second he has paid his dues for the crime he committed and those are the rules.. he was a stupid kid made a bad choice in life everyone deserves a second chance.. D’Arcy is the very definition of white privilege
D’Arcy 🤡
Ireland rugby also don’t test schoolboys rugby players for doping. South Africa has been doing this for a very long time. NZ only starter a few years ago.
RSA tests and banned Chilli Boy for 8 Years. This guy is now 29yrs best years behind him.
RSA catches and ban’s drug cheats, So D’Arcy’s point is what that, nobody ever tried to get ahead under dubious methods in Ireland?
The same country that gives us Connor “Roid-Bloated” McCgregor, in the fight circuit? or is it you just dont wanna catch any, and their “support’ is overseen in house.
Haskell [ENG] disappeared from Rugby for a year, came back significantly larger, all semi-pro’s told me it was known Viatmin-S played a role. But RSA who test and ban players are the drug cheats.
Rassie has to be ‘welcoming back’ especially to returning players of a deeply needed ethnic profile. Rugby is trying to win over the black populace, despite top level break throughs most have been handpicked and placed in historically dominant school rugby systems like Grey College, previously white schools. Grow up D’Arcy clown.
This is an attempt to keep an underlying thread of Boks are drug cheats, Choose a man and a time and bring a test D’Arcy, and suffer same for your Internationals, its happening already. Believe you me if their was a failed drug test under wraps or a known drug game, ENG wouldn’t have tried the Race baiting with Tom Curry they’d have gone straight to that for their smear.
Dutch Farm boys like PSDT eating meat in sunshine doing outdoor work grow tall, is this vitamin-S too? Clown.
There are convictions with sentences that once served allow the perp to return to their sport. If you think drug taking should be punished like murder where the perp gets a life sentence then 3/4 of the population of Ireland belong in the klink. I know I’ve been over there a few times and have relatives that lived there many years - the Irish are as drink/drug/mushy addled like the rest of us.
- “nobody ever tried to get ahead under dubious methods in Ireland” was not his point
- Connor McGregor performs in a different sport
- D’Arcy didn’t say Haskell or anyone else shouldn’t not be banned if they tested positive for banned substances
- That is good for Rassie if indeed he is encouraging the black populace, it is definitely working if you compare the ethnicity of the SA rugby populace since 30 years ago; but there are many more black rugby players to commend that aren’t cheats.
- “Choose a man and a time and bring a test D’Arcy”. Not sure if you want to fight Gordon D’Arcy or you think Ireland aren’t good enough to compete with SA. Two good tests between the two in the last couple of years if I remember correctly.
- Underlying thread? He didn’t say that South Africans are drug cheats, he said the 3 that were caught are.
- Curry vs Mbonambi situation is irrelevant to this article
- Meat is not a banned substance and he did not claim anything about Pieter Steph du Toit. The man is a big Afrikaaner beast, like many South Africans of all ethncities.
- Clown? Come on. Please stop resorting to benign insults and passing on the blame.
It would be interesting to read if you had examples of other players banned for usage of illegal substances, either from without or within South Africa.
writing long essays won’t invalidate any of D’Arcy’s points…
I also find it shocking that a cheater is welcomed back so cheerfully. I don’t care about the origin, I wish the sport to be clean. Call me a utopist if you want but I find it ridiculous that your defensive line is “no better elsewhere and therefore shut up”.