Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Ferns strewn and history made: A re-watch of the Red Roses WXV 1 triumph

AUCKLAND, NEW ZEALAND - NOVEMBER 04: Captain Marlie Packer of England leads the team out for the WXV1 match between New Zealand Silver Ferns and England at Go Media Stadium Mt Smart on November 04, 2023 in Auckland, New Zealand. (Photo by Dave Rowland/Getty Images)

So they huffed, and they puffed, and they blew the house in – storming the land of the long white cloud, and leaving ferns strewn across the lawn as they departed – the WXV 1 trophy stashed beneath one muscular arm.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Red Roses – twelve months on from the hand that stole the final lineout, the heroics, and the heartbreak – trampled and scorched their way to the inaugural title, making the world champions look eminently mortal in the process.

For UK viewers, those 80 minutes were watched through initially bleary – but soon, awestruck – eyes on the sofa, as England racked up 33 points and permitted New Zealand just eleven minutes of scoreboard access of their own.

It was their tenth straight bonus point victory, and capped off an undefeated season. It was mightily impressive in all sorts of ways, and culminated in a history-making pot lift. It deserves, a few days on, a bit of a revisit.

Rikki Swannell sets out a stall as well as anyone, and calls this fixture with trademark passion and dexterity, but the disconnect between her promise of ‘the one everyone’s been waiting for’ and the swathes of empty seats is immediate. She’s dead right – this is a titanic headline fight – but the crowd is reminiscent of the Six Nations a decade ago.

This has been a soft launch for a tournament with huge potential, but you can only hope this is the last time the best two teams on the planet do battle in front of stands which are more abandoned than occupied.

A few moments stand out before kick-off. Marlie Packer wins the toss, expressionless – she’s always been one to snap the visor down early – but a beaming Ruahei Demant lets the smile slip off her face just as the captains leave the tunnel. Even the world’s best player gets nervous, it seems.

ADVERTISEMENT

Perhaps, on some level, Demant knew that the Red Roses were the ones in form – and that the Player of the Year trophy would soon be stashed in an overhead locker, en route to Yeovil.

The New Zealand anthem is accompanied by a virtuosic electric guitar line – which proves a real vibe. Krystal Murray leads an anticipation-cranking, hackles-raising haka – watched on by a gently smiling Maud Muir, who’s made for occasions like these. Sky Sports emblazon ‘It’s Only Live Once’ across billboards, and they’re right, but there’s still – somehow – a sense of jeopardy, watching this back.

Holly Aitchison sends it long: so long that you assume it’s incontestable. Mo Hunt – opportunity-fuelled – hurtles into shot and gets the charge down. It’s immediately knocked on, and the sting’s taken out of that particular passage, but the gauntlet’s been thrown – and it’s red, rosy, and thorny.

The world’s best don’t need any time to make their mark on a test match, and that’s the case here. Sylvia Brunt’s soon carrying white jerseys along with her, like a tiny, jet-propelled clothes horse.

ADVERTISEMENT

Claudia MacDonald gets her ‘defenders beaten’ stat ticking along within moments, and seems intent all evening on pushing it above the number of tickets sold. Sarah Bern is havoc-wreaking and blockbuster.

The Roses are playing out of their skins. Morwenna Talling fires off a five-metre offload. Alex Matthews is virtually omnipresent. Zoe Aldcroft displays a superhuman ability to hoover up metres each and every time she carries. After 17 phases, Georgia Ponsonby turns them over, but she’s a solitary sandbag in the face of a vengeful flood – and the hosts’ number is up off the back of the ensuing scrum.

A penalty’s drawn immediately, and Matthews’ control at the base is masterful. Over she goes, and so too does the conversion. Zoe Harrison will be back soon, which is fabulous, but it’s getting hard to imagine that number ten jersey without Aitchison in it. As the extras cleave the posts, she’s not missed a kick all competition.

Mererangi Paul on the left wing is as eye-catching as ever, but these initial exchanges are – ultimately – about as one-sided as an open sandwich. Demant drops a pass and Mackenzie Carson pounces. Abby Dow is hauled into touch as she attempts to counter, but the New Zealand lineout misfires spectacularly.

As Hunt feeds a ravenous white and red scrum, the Roses have had 90% possession. Dow goes again – her ability to decelerate, withdraw, and then surge onwards Mark Telea-esque – and every collision seems to tumble in their favour. It’s like every England player is one size bigger than their opposition number, and two notches angrier. Perhaps they are.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by WXV (@wxvrugby)

Lark Atkin-Davies, launching an attacking line out in Auckland for the first time since that seismic final, is pinpoint, and soon has her fifth WXV 1 try. Sarah Hunter, watching on powerless in Auckland for the first time since the toughest day of her storied career, claps her hands and beams from the coaches’ box.

As Renee Holmes misses touch with an over-ambitious penalty, the Kiwis have had eight carries to England’s 38. They just can’t get or keep hold of the ball: their passes aren’t anything as clean as usual, or are placed so that their recipients are forced to check their runs to gather them.

A graphic pops up, titled ‘Dominance: World Cup titles’, reminding us that the side who’re yet to break a tackle have won the big dance six times, whilst England – up 14-0 – have triumphed just twice. If this were your first-ever experience of women’s rugby – you’d never believe it.

England are back in the Kiwi 22, and Aitchison is grinning behind their scrum. Eight phases later, Bern hurtles over. She’s unstoppable on days like these, but is helped no end by the chasm in the Black Ferns’ defence to the side of the ruck. The world champions lose more lineouts and cough up more possession, whilst the Roses keep the pedal flat to the floor. If it’s not Dow on the prowl – it’s MacDonald.

If it’s not MacDonald – it’s Kildunne. The fullback’s denied an absolute pearler by a few petulant blades of painted grass. England hustle and hustle in defence – leaping straight back up to their feet so New Zealand have nowhere to go, ball-in-hand.

Finally, in the 38th minute, the famed passes stick. Ruby Tui is unleashed down the right, and they’re up the other end – where Alana Bremner recycles a bouncing ball, and Dow can’t cover all three options. Kennedy Simon dummies and scythes through. It’s 19-7, and the hooter soon sounds.

Packer, Aldcroft, Matthews, and Aitchison wander towards the sheds – unhurried – the latter animated in her analysis, and flourishing as their playmaker.

Whatever Allan Bunting says at half-time has an effect. New Zealand are still being starved of the quantity of ball they’re used to, but they begin to make some hay through contact. Amy Rule, Chelsea Bremner, and Simon produce a few hefty carries – right as Packer has a few minutes off being utterly world-class.

A pair of penalties and a knock-on from the skipper gifts the Kiwis the territory they need to launch a devastatingly slick strike move, and Katelyn Vahaakolo is over. They’ve scored the last twelve points, and you wonder if the chase might just be on.

As it turns out, the door – having creaked open for all of ten tantalising minutes – is slammed shut again. The Red Roses put their shoulders back to the wheel, and exemplary service from Hunt allows every single carry to bring them closer to a fourth. Talling grounds it. Aitchison does the honours. 26-12.

Some coaches distil winning down to stringing together positive involvements – and this matchup exhibits that perfectly. One team repeatedly layers power with accuracy, and then sprinkles on some stardust – whilst the other can only follow a break with a knock-on or penalty.

Staying power counts, too, and England look incredibly well-conditioned: the clock claims we’re at 70 minutes, and yet Matthews is still puncturing the frayed black fabric of Kiwi defence, and they’re still routinely ripping possession from their hosts.

The talismanic Aldcroft gets a thoroughly deserved score to bring up 33-12. The poi whirl in the stands, but all the on-field dynamism is from the visitors – as Kildunne has yet another chalked off, and smiles wryly. She can afford to: they’re away and clear.

Appropriately, it’s a scrum penalty which concludes a contest in which England’s power game was world-beating. The on-field celebrations are wonderful, but not a patch on the magnificent shot we’re offered from the rubbish little camera in the coaches’ box. Hunter wiping away tears says it all: the Red Roses had returned to the scene of their great heartbreak, and swatted aside its ghosts en route to an emphatic, title-clinching victor

Post-match, Packer describes 2025 as ‘Everest’, and she’s right: it’s the pinnacle overshadowing all of this. England dominated the last cycle before being thwarted in the match which mattered most. You suspect they’d happily miss out on WXVs and Six Nations, if it meant they were the ones to triumph at a sold-out Twickenham in two years’ time.

That earlier on-screen graphic felt ill-timed, but its point stands: can they do it at a World Cup? Only time will tell, but what’s inarguable is that the newly-crowned WXV 1 champions are seriously, seriously good – and are only getting better.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

6 Comments
P
Pecos 358 days ago

Unfortunately our eyes & hearts were focussed on Paris & WXV1 didn’t compute. And the Black Ferns were terrible. The WXV1 version would’ve been smashed by the Black Ferns RWC2021 version. Still, the goal remains RWC2025.

p
philip 384 days ago

Have been following the Red Roses campaigns for the last 3 years and have thrilled to their play leaving me increasingly uninterested in the men’s international fortunes. Magnificent rugby and splendid skills and gumption by the ladies. Thanks Claire for your excellent reminder of their excellence.

a
andrew 432 days ago

Brilliant read and red roses will conquer Everest in 2025

j
jon 432 days ago

Excellent review 👍👍👏👏

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 3 hours ago
How law changes are speeding up the game - but the scrum lags behind

so what's the point?

A deep question!


First, the point would be you wouldn't have a share of those penalities if you didn't choose good scrummers right.


So having incentive to scrummaging well gives more space in the field through having less mobile players.


This balance is what we always strive to come back to being the focus of any law change right.


So to bring that back to some of the points in this article, if changing the current 'offense' structure of scrums, to say not penalizing a team that's doing their utmost to hold up the scrum (allowing play to continue even if they did finally succumb to collapsing or w/e for example), how are we going to stop that from creating a situation were a coach can prioritize the open play abilities of their tight five, sacrificing pure scrummaging, because they won't be overly punished by having a weak scrum?


But to get back on topic, yes, that balance is too skewed, the prevalence has been too much/frequent.


At the highest level, with the best referees and most capable props, it can play out appealingly well. As you go down the levels, the coaching of tactics seems to remain high, but the ability of the players to adapt and hold their scrum up against that guy boring, or the skill of the ref in determining what the cause was and which of those two to penalize, quickly degrades the quality of the contest and spectacle imo (thank good european rugby left that phase behind!)


Personally I have some very drastic changes in mind for the game that easily remedy this prpblem (as they do for all circumstances), but the scope of them is too great to bring into this context (some I have brought in were applicable), and without them I can only resolve to come up with lots of 'finicky' like those here. It is easy to understand why there is reluctance in their uptake.


I also think it is very folly of WR to try and create this 'perfect' picture of simple laws that can be used to cover all aspects of the game, like 'a game to be played on your feet' etc, and not accept it needs lots of little unique laws like these. I'd be really happy to create some arbitrary advantage for the scrum victors (similar angle to yours), like if you can make your scrum go forward, that resets the offside line from being the ball to the back foot etc, so as to create a way where your scrum wins a foot be "5 meters back" from the scrum becomes 7, or not being able to advance forward past the offisde line (attack gets a free run at you somehow, or devide the field into segments and require certain numbers to remain in the other sgements (like the 30m circle/fielders behind square requirements in cricket). If you're defending and you go forward then not just is your 9 still allowed to harras the opposition but the backline can move up from the 5m line to the scrum line or something.


Make it a real mini game, take your solutions and making them all circumstantial. Having differences between quick ball or ball held in longer, being able to go forward, or being pushed backwards, even to where the scrum stops and the ref puts his arm out in your favour. Think of like a quick tap scenario, but where theres no tap. If the defending team collapses the scrum in honest attempt (even allow the attacking side to collapse it after gong forward) the ball can be picked up (by say the eight) who can run forward without being allowed to be tackled until he's past the back of the scrum for example. It's like a little mini picture of where the defence is scrambling back onside after a quick tap was taken.


The purpose/intent (of any such gimmick) is that it's going to be so much harder to stop his momentum, and subsequent tempo, that it's a really good advantage for having such a powerful scrum. No change of play to a lineout or blowing of the whistle needed.

165 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Junior Kpoku: 'My goal is to fight for an England place at the 2027 World Cup.' Junior Kpoku: 'My goal is to fight for an England place at the 2027 World Cup.'
Search