Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Grant Williams' first Springboks Test start lasts just 10 seconds

(Photo by Wikus de Wet/AFP via Getty Images)

Grant Williams’ first start as the Springboks No9 was dramatically ended on Saturday by a collision just 10 seconds into his team’s Rugby Championship match against Argentina in Johannesburg. The recently turned 27-year-old was named last Tuesday for his maiden run-on appearance for South Africa after three previous appearances off the replacements bench.

ADVERTISEMENT

The scrum-half was one of nine changes to the Springboks XV made by head coach Jacques Nienaber following their round two 20-35 loss to New Zealand in Auckland. However, hopes that the Championship finale would provide South African fans with a good look at Williams ahead of the upcoming Rugby World Cup were dashed by an injury sustained in his first involvement in the match.

Argentina kicked off at Emirates Airlines Park and their start went deep into the 22 to where Williams was poised to gather. He caught the ball on the five-metre line, but his right-footed kick was blocked on 10 seconds by the charging Juan Cruz Mallia.

Video Spacer

Springbok coach Jacques Nienaber on Grant Williams starting against Argentina

Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
Duration 1:02
Loaded: 0%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time 1:02
 
1x
    • Chapters
    • descriptions off, selected
    • captions off, selected
    • en (Main), selected
    Video Spacer

    Springbok coach Jacques Nienaber on Grant Williams starting against Argentina

    The Argentine full-back, who was airborne at the time, caught Williams in the head with his follow through and after the play was stopped on 17 seconds following a South African infringement at a ruck, referee Andrew Brace decided that Mallia was committed to the collision after touching the ball and that foul play hadn’t taken place.

    The knocked-out Williams was stretchered off, allowing Faf de Klerk, who had dropped to the bench to accommodate the Test rookie getting his first start, to come onto the field. This lack of game time for Williams will frustrate the Springboks given how highly coach Nienaber had spoken about him earlier in the week.

    “Grant is on his third Test and his first start. It is our job to help him gain experience during the week to give him as much exposure of what he is going to get on Saturday so that he is happy and comfortable in the role that he has to fulfill; so that doesn’t have to think about it,” explained Nienaber after he had decided to start Williams.

    “He can just bring out his natural talent and that makes him special. Yes, he has a role to fulfill, but there is also something that Grant brings to the table that makes him special, that is a Grant Williams thing.”

    ADVERTISEMENT

    South Africa recovered from the early loss of Williams to lead 15-9 at the interval courtesy of tries from Eben Etzebeth and Damian de Allende, and they went on to win 22-21 to clinch a second-place finish in the tournament behind New Zealand.

    Manie Libbok’s converted 69th-minute try stretched the hosts’ lead to 22-9 before de Allende’s yellow card was followed by late Argentina tries for Mateo Carreras and Gonzalo Bertranou.

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Cape Town | Leg 1 | Day 2 | HSBC Challenger Series 2025 | Full Day Replay

    Gloucester-Hartpury vs Bristol Bears | PWR 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

    Boks Office | Episode 36 | Six Nations Round 3 Review

    Why did Scotland's Finn Russell take the crucial kick from the wrong place? | Whistle Watch

    England A vs Ireland A | Full Match Replay

    Kubota Spears vs Shizuoka BlueRevs | JRLO 2024/2025 | Full Match Replay

    O2 Inside Line: This Rose | Episode 3 | France Week

    Watch now: Lomu - The Lost Tapes

    Trending on RugbyPass

    Comments

    21 Comments
    B
    Byron 584 days ago

    There is literally no way this is not a straight red! The debate on that framework is a different discussion, but to todays framework and how rugby has been reffed in the last few years that is straight red. Now this is an extremely vulnerble position for the kicker and impossible to protect oneself in the motion, while the defender doesnt need to heed any safety while flying in like a missile. Career ending challenge, disgusting this is not even mentioned in the article.

    F
    Frank 584 days ago

    The inconsistent application of the rules is not rules. Rugby has become corrupt. Let me tell you guys here right now, France is going to win RWC 2023 of this I have no doubts AT ALL.

    F
    Flankly 585 days ago

    Law 9.11: "Players must not do anything that is reckless or dangerous to others ..."

    You can try to argue that Juan Cruz Mallia was not charging the kicker (Law 9.25), or more generally charging the player (Laws 9.15-9.17), but the ref should have evaluated the action in relation to 9.11. And the standards are about "reckless" or "dangerous", either of which would have merited a sanction.

    In any case, irrespective of the wording, the spirit of the law is quite correctly that players have a responsibility for the safety of other players. If what the Puma #15 did was dangerous or reckless then it is at least a penalty. If the degree is serious then it's a yellow or red card. Hint: Jumping feet first towards someone's head is not safe, even if it is your butt that collides with them.

    Btw, I thought that the refereeing was a mix of welcome attention to the offside line and sloppiness in areas like ruck binding and players off their feet. It was mostly OK, but the fact that the Williams incident was not even referred for review is a shocker.

    Also, many of us were looking forward to seeing Grant Williams getting a good run, and a chance to earn a RWC spot. Faf played very well, and it may have favored the SA result for him to be on early, but I was sorry not to see that Grant/Libbok axis at work in a real test.

    R
    Richard John 585 days ago

    Mallia, at full speed, launched himself high from a great distance,
    knowing full well that there was NO way he could safely avoid hitting Williams.

    This is extremely reckless and dangerous play. It could even be argued that his intention was to play the man.

    A Red card and ban is justified.

    B
    Barry 585 days ago

    Should have been straight red. Referees got that wrong and ignored player safety.

    C
    CO 585 days ago

    Definitely a red card, surely should be cited for recklessly knocking someone out.

    S
    Schneider 585 days ago

    If that happens to an Ireland or French player in WC 1/4 or semi- thats a straight red. Incredibly reckless challenge.

    C
    Connor 585 days ago

    CJ Stander got a Red for that in 2018. That injury ruined Pat Lambie's career.

    In an age when player safety is "supposedly" a priority of World Rugby, the fact that such an incredibly reckless and dangerous is not punished and even tacitly endorsed, is an outrage.

    C
    Chris 585 days ago

    Frans Steyn made a charge down against NZ in 2022- penalty . Exact the same thing, but 10 times worse, completely different ruling.

    Load More Comments

    Join free and tell us what you really think!

    Sign up for free
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Latest Features

    Comments on RugbyPass

    P
    Paige Usher 17 minutes ago
    Former All Black Craig Newby lands head coach role in England

    I got my bad school grade fixed with the help of darkhatthacker@gmail.com, am so so happy and grateful to you darkhatthacker@gmail.com , your speed in carrying out this job was 100% fast!!! I must say I am really impressed. Thank you once again

    4 Go to comments
    R
    RedWarriors 1 hour ago
    France change two for Ireland but stick with 7-1 bench tactic

    We will see how much these big French lads can run. England kept fatigue pressure on France by keeping kicks infield. A lot of kick tennis will suit Ireland as these buffallo will have to run up and down the pitch. Prendergast, Lowe, Osborne, Keenan. 4 Big kickers in the starting line up. You cannot have a stop/start match allowing this big guys to be rested before every scrum and play. Need a baseline of fatigue to bring the ceiling of damage they can do down.

    France are confident which is dangerous for Ireland but also dangerous for France. The confidence and standards can drop if expectations are not met.


    A stat I did see was disquieting. France are converting 56% of their 22 entries to tries. They scored a lot versus Italy, but missed a lot against England.

    This resembles a bit the damage Toulouse were doing after line breaks. Flament was all over this. The defence will need to be excellent and our best defender Ringrose will not be there. That said versus England we conceded 3 points in 68 mins. We conceded 11 in 75 against Scotland but we were messing for 7 of that.

    It is hard to score against Ireland.

    When Aki came on versus Wales we scored 19 points in half an hour which was roughly France’s scoring rate against Wales in Paris.

    France will score, but Ireland with a full performance should outscore.


    As rgds the 7-1 split, Ireland will inflict physical damage like versus Springboks in Durban. I think France are underestimating Ireland’s physicality and I will be surprized if that split doesnt cause problems and backfire a little.

    10 Go to comments
    TRENDING
    TRENDING Marcus Smith benched as England change three to take on Italy Marcus Smith benched as England change three to take on Italy
    Search