Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'He was a sitting duck': All Blacks await Swain verdict

Photo by Joe Allison/Getty Images

The second of the many major talking points to come out of the first Bledisloe test in Melbourne last week was Darcy Swain’s dangerous and illegal clean-out on Quinn Tupaea.

ADVERTISEMENT

Scans revealed that Tupaea had suffered a ruptured medial cruciate ligament (MCL) and partially torn anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) in the incident which saw Swain yellow-carded.

Amongst the outcry over Mathieu Raynal’s match-defining time-wasting call, there was an outpouring of sympathy and prayers for Tupaea who is expected to miss the next three months – the remainder of the international season.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

Tupaea’s All Blacks teammate Beauden Barrett appeared for media on Monday and was asked if he had a view on the incident.

“Yea we do, we do, I thought it was…” Barrett hesitated. “I feel for Quinn, he basically didn’t see it coming, he was a sitting duck.

“It was a bit of a free shot.”

Swain was cited for the shot and was scheduled to appear before SANZAAR’s judicial committee on Monday night with the outcome set to be announced sometime Tuesday.

Related

The hit has had ramifications throughout both teams.

Swain will likely receive a hefty ban, especially if the committee is to take into account his recent track record with foul play.

ADVERTISEMENT

Swain received a red card for head-butting England lock Johnny Hill in the July series earlier this year, a World Rugby committee at that time handed Swain a two-week ban.

The All Blacks are down two midfielders, Tupaea’s knee injury is in addition to David Havili’s concussion.

A new backline could see Beauden Barrett start at 15 and brother Jordie get his opportunity in the midfield with rugby league convert Roger Tuivasa-Sheck potentially in the mix off the bench.

Barrett went on to express further sympathy for his midfield teammate.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I feel for him because he’s going to be out of the game for a long period of time.

“I’m not too sure what’s happening in their camp with Darcy Swain.

“Of course I feel for him (Tupaea), we don’t like to see these sorts of injuries .”

All Black centurion Aaron Smith also added to Barrett’s sentiment, with a brief comment referencing Swain’s actions.

“Seeing Quinn like that on Friday was pretty tough,” Smith said.

“You always feel for the brothers and injuries happen in rugby, but you know, some can be controlled.”

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

M
Mzilikazi 1 hour ago
Does the next Wallabies coach have to be an Australian?

Great read on a fascinating topic, Nick. Thanks as always.


My gut feel is that Joe Schmidt won't carry on through to the next RWC. He is at the stage, and age, in his life , that a further two years in a very high pressure coaching job would not be a good thing for either himself or his family. The fact that he remains based in Taupo seems a significant pointer, I would have thought. I believe he has a round trip of 12 hrs driving just to get on a plane to Australia.


Amongst the many good things Joe Schmidt has achieved to this point is that the WB's are now a more enticing prospect to coach going forward.


Tbh, the only Australian coach I would see stepping up and developing the WB's further would be Les Kiss. He has far more in his CV than any other Australian. He now has 23 years of coaching Union,starting with a defence role with the Boks, then back to Australia with the Waratahs. Overseas again for nine years in Ireland, which included 5 years as defence coach with the national team, during which he was interim head coach for two games, both wins. His last years in Ireland were with Ulster, even then a team beginning a decline. So that spell was his least successful. Finally the spell with London Irish, where I felt Kiss was doing very well, till the club collapsed financially.


Of the other Australian options, Dan McKellar has a lot to prove post the year with Leicester. Stephen Larkham has not, in my view, yet shown outstanding qualities as a coach. Nether man has anything close to Kiss's experience. Some may see this as being harsh on both men, ignoring good work they have done. But is how I see it.


Looking outside Australia, I would see Vern Cotter as a strong possibility, if interested. His time with Scotland was outstanding. Ronan O'Gara, I would think, might well be another possibility, though he has no international experience. Jake White ? Maybe .

74 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Steve Borthwick handed fresh injury concern ahead of Six Nations Steve Borthwick handed fresh injury concern ahead of Six Nations
Search