1
Why England's infamous celebrations might actually be holding them back
By Josh Raisey
Whether the England team sat down one day and decided to overegg their celebratory pudding or whether it happened organically may never be known, but they surely never expected it would evoke such outcry far and wide.
ADVERTISEMENT
The more it has become their ‘thing’, the more the England players have seemingly played up to it, and, in turn, have been questioned on it, with the general responses being that it galvanises and uplifts the team. While most of the criticism seems to be based on the fact that people find it annoying, some critics like Sir Clive Woodward have delved a little deeper and have pointed out that it hinders England’s decision-making, as winning a penalty is when players should be assessing what to do next.
But former England fly-half Danny Cipriani went a step further recently and suggested that this approach from England could actually be affecting their playing, chiefly their spluttering attack.
Saturday was only the second time under Steve Borthwick that England have managed to score four tries in a match, and they had to wait until Joe Marchant crossed the whitewash in the final play of the game to achieve that feat. Joining the Rugby World Cup 2023 Official Podcast recently, Cipriani said that England’s trademark celebrations are indicative of how they are not composed when they attack.
While it was during August that many took notice of this ploy from England, ex Ireland flanker Stephen Ferris said on the podcast that this trait has been part of this team’s DNA for a while now, saying it predates Ben Earl, who has been pinpointed as celebrator-in-chief.
“I follow Ben Earl, he is an unbelievable player,” Ferris said. “But it sort of started before Earl came into the team, it used to be Maro [Itoje]. I get it, celebrate the moments.”
Cipriani added: “When you see the way they attack, England have a lot of individually talented players but they are knocking the ball on, slightly off timing with runs, all of that stuff is happening at the moment. If you are emotionally so charged that you are like ‘yeah’, when does that ever calm down for you to make a good decision or run a good line or be involved in the game to engage in the present moment, if you are so charged up like that?
ADVERTISEMENT
“You don’t see your [Brodie] Retallicks or [Ardie] Saveas behaving in that way because they are very calm and cool under pressure. I’m not saying there’s a right and a wrong, but you need to know your balance within that. If you’re going to be like that, you still need to have some composure to you in how you’re going to play. It can’t all be one speed, otherwise you’re not going to catch the ball.”
In fairness it's not like England have many tries or wins to celebrate, so let them have something.
I did notice Smith was really charged up coming on, which is not something I'd want to see out of a 10/15 who needs to be calm and collected to identify opportunities not chomping at the bit to prove himself.
Let's face it , winning a scrum/ lineout penalty is probably the sole ambition of englands game plan currently
“with the general responses being that it galvanises and uplifts the team.”
Really? Is that the general response? Or just what the muppets in the England squad parrot? From my experience the general response is that they’re behaving like a bunch of kids. It’s pathetic and needs to be stopped. Personally I would like to see it penalised. And I’m an England fan. Enough is enough.
And by the way, obviously it predates Earl and has been going on for years… do the writers here even watch rugby? It’s a Saracens thing. They’ve been doing it for about 10 years. Right around the time they stared winning by cheating. And then they imported it into England.