1
Ireland not at All Blacks level claims former Test foe
By Ian Cameron
Despite their fine form in the this year’s Guinness Six Nations, Chris Ashton doesn’t believe that Ireland are yet the level of the All Blacks or South Africa.
ADVERTISEMENT
Ireland have won their first two games of this tournament at something of canter and have been winning wide praise across the rugby world.
Their Six Nations’ success to date comes however just three and half months after yet another Rugby World Cup quarter-final exit and for Ashton, it creates a bright line between the men in green and the likes of the New Zealand and the Springboks.
“I’d love to put this Ireland team in the same category of some of those all-conquering All Blacks teams, but there is a big difference between winning a Grand Slam and winning a World Cup,” said Ashton. “Ireland know that better than anybody having not been able to progress to a World Cup semi-final in their history.
“Within Europe, Ireland have definitely been the best team, but they haven’t been able to demonstrate that at a World Cup, which is their only Achilles heel if we are comparing them with the likes of South Africa and the All Black.
Ashton doesn’t think Wales have what it takes to knock them off their perch in Round 3.
“Unfortunately, in rugby, we always want to play everything down and not get too carried away with performances and how things are going,” mused Ashton.
ADVERTISEMENT
“I think for Farrell’s players, when they get past Wales, which I have no doubt they will, I do think there will be some sort of dramatic unexpected win in the tournament somewhere in this Six Nations because there always is.
“Will Wales throw that up? I don’t think so, so that sets up something for England vs Ireland at Twickenham. That will be a great occasion. I think if you’re Andy Farrell you need to play down all of the noise and take it one game at a time. There is an opportunity to make history with back-to-back Grand Slams.
Regarding their players, former winger Ashton has been impressed by rookie Munster wing Calvin Nash.
“Calvin has been in good form all year. He has had a great season at Munster and is such a strong carrier. I think that he has done well in his first few international games. He has been helped by the fact that he is going into such a strong Ireland team.
ADVERTISEMENT
“Everyone knows their role in the team, and they are so efficient. The team are creating spaces around the edges of the pitch and it’s a really nice team to be in if you play as a winger. I think he has done well.”
When the next RWC takes place it will celebrate 40 unbroken years of World Cup history. In all that 40 years Ireland have NEVER won one single knock-out game. Not one single knock-out game in the whole history of the tournament. And certain people want to bracket them with 7 time combined joint tournament winners NZ and SA. Amusing…..
Ireland best team in the World at the moment.
Irish team is not up there with SA (2015, 2019, 2013).
I regard SA 2015 as a superior team to NZ 2015. NZ had a walkover quarter final due to the scheduling NZ arranged with England and ITV. That is why NZ were able to come from behind with 14 men (sin bin) against a tiring SA, late in the 3rd quarter.
NZ also got lucky in 2011 with no depth and blessed to beat France and even more blessed they were not facing a rampant Wales.
The banter is fun. But can some NZ supporters understand that Ireland were NOWHERE until after 2000 and show some appreciation for Irish achievements?
Your records and that of SA are streets ahead. Can you show a little generosity towards other teams?
The current Ireland squad are clearly better than all the SH team - by a massive distance s. The SH teams haven’t been good for a decade. They just live off uncompentwnce of bad referees.
I think a series win in NZ ranks fairly high on the rugby totem pole, so we’ll take that. Our failure again at the RWC is frustrating and disappointing although I think a win against the ultimate winners and a four point loss to NZ isn’t a cause for shame. The fact that Kiwis now hate us is a big step up from being held in contempt.
Still, amongst all those Kiwi Irish Aussie Irish South African Irish Dutch Irish & American Irish, it’s not a bad Irish team to be fair.
One of Ireland’s biggest weaknesses - a lack of depth - has been partly addressed over the last few years by turning to Kiwi and Aussie players but you still feel they are a couple of key injuries away from being extremely vulnerable. In latter parts of the World Cup it’s about having at least two world class players in each position and Ireland just don’t have that. The Boks and, to a lesser extent, the All Blacks do. That’s the difference.