Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Ireland player ratings vs Italy

Italy's Ian McKinley is tackled.

Ireland overcame Italy in a scrappy affair in Dublin, giving Joe Schmidt food for thought as he prepares to make the final cut to his 31-man Rugby World Cup squad.

ADVERTISEMENT

An injury scare to Joey Carbery may have been the headline moment in the match but there was plenty to be garnered from the individual performances of an Ireland team heavy with fringe players.

Here’s our Ireland player ratings.

Jordan Larmour

Stepped out of the back-field several times and also provided a fine scoring pass. 6/10

Video Spacer

Andrew Conway

Finished his one opportunity well but was unable to shine much beyond that. 6

Garry Ringrose

A smart pop out of the tackle led to Dave Kearney’s try, but the accomplished centre had precious few chances to cut loose. 6

Chris Farrell

A reassuringly potent presence in the midfield that Ireland were always able to build around. Increased his chances of World Cup selection. 8

Dave Kearney

Took his try well, but botched an early chance he ought to have converted without issue. 6

Joey Carbery

Looked creative and improving until injury struck that could now jeopardise his World Cup chances. 7

ADVERTISEMENT

Luke McGrath

Solid showing that kept Ireland ticking over but struggled to gel things together early on. 6

Jack McGrath

Conceded a number of scrum penalties and was hauled off at the break, struggling overall. 5

Rob Herring

Came off early. Solid if uninspiring, but kept it tight enough to keep himself in the running as second-choice hooker. 6

Andrew Porter

Scrummaged well enough and proved his all-round power once again. 6

Devin Toner

Dominated the lineout enough for Ireland to coast to the win. 7

ADVERTISEMENT

Jean Kleyn

A gritty debut from the uncompromising Munster lock, but perhaps not enough to force him onto the World Cup plane. 7

Rhys Ruddock (captain)

Led the team as calmly as ever, with the dependable Leinster flanker putting in a big shift of work. 6

Tommy O’Donnell

Put himself about all afternoon but was unable to cut loose. 6

Jordi Murphy

Took his try well and manned the base of the scrum without issue at number eight. 6

REPLACEMENTS:

Good charge-down and finish from scrum-half Kieran Marmion, a man who has never let Ireland down. Solid showing overall. 7

Jack Carty

Put in a solid shift after coming on for the injured Carbery. Held his own defence and didn’t look out of place in an unfamiliar midfield. 7

Tadhg Beirne

In the short time was made two turnovers. So strong and difficult to move when he is over the ball. 8

ADVERTISEMENT

Boks Office | Episode 40 | The Steven Kitshoff Special

O2 Inside Line: All In | Episode 6 | Le Crunch

The Unexpected Journey to USA 7s Glory | Aaron Cummings | Sevens Wonders

USA vs Japan | Full Match Replay

Yokohama Canon Eagles vs Shizuoka BlueRevs | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

Confidence knocks and finding your people | Flo Williams | Rugby Rising Locker Room

Tackling reasons for drop-out in sport | Zainab Alema | Rugby Rising Locker Room

Jet Lag: The biggest challenge facing international sports? | The Report

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

R
RW 12 minutes ago
Leo Cullen defends his position after Leinster's Champions Cup exit

It's funny you say that boet, it's one thing to say “We are the best team in the world and yet still do no better than your predecessors” and still fail at a QF game in a RWC for instance.

It's another thing to not only say but also to show HOW you are the best team in the World by winning a RWC twice in a row which is what both NZ and RSA have done.


So yes it could be arrogance on the part of Boks and Blacks but we have a legitimate reason for feeling that way. Whereas Ireland never have. In fact in terms of WCs, they have only ever done better than Italy regarding the Six Nations teams.

England have been in at least three finals, won one.

France have been in three finals, although they lost all of them, Wales have been in at least two Semi Finals, Scotland one Semi Final.

Even amongst your peers, you guys are at the back. So I don't see what reason you have be arrogant and yet, and yet you are.


Yes you win when the ultimate pressure is not on you. Pool games, three match series, autumn series, etc, URC and EPCR pool games. But when it comes to highest tier stakes, you don't have the ability to capitalize.


It's not how you start that matters, although it does help, but how you finish. I am reminded of Munster from 2023, playing seven away games in a row and managing to win all of them on the trot including a final. That one hurt because it was against my team the Stormers.


But the stats don't even help your case. So there is a difference between “arrogance” based on fact and that based on feeling.

34 Go to comments
R
RedWarriors 1 hour ago
'Most complacent selection decision you will ever see': Barrett benching slammed as Leinster knocked out

I can read out the headlines to you in all the National Irish Papers and none were complacent. To say they were is a fabrication pure and simple. People (including you) saying that Irish media are arrogant does not actually equate to Irish media being arrogant.

Since Ireland beat NZ in the 2022 series Irish supporters have had to deal with these accusations of arrogance. Out of nowhere. If you wish the International game to grow then please dont make supporting rugby this unpleasant for emerging nations.

Lets look at the Wales match in the 6N. One Irish podcast took the piss. 99% were completely respectful to Wales a few actually doing useful research in which Irish successes could be transferrable to Wales and which couldn’t.

Ofcourse the internet lit up. Ireland were arroagant. The Telegraph did a big column on it. Their substantiation? The same off the ball piss take and some hearsay about one Irish supporter at the Ireland/Scotland RWC match.

Things were dying down when Pundit Brian O’Driscoll claimed he read the Telegraph article and thought Irish supporters needed to have a good look at themselves. Everything was about that one piss take. And so what? Every Scots and irish supporter knows that the Welsh took no prisoners taking the piss during their scores of victories over us over the years. They like a bit of fun.


Next time you want to accuse Irish of arrogance then read all the articles and make that decision. Otherwise its disingenious.

46 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Jack Boyle: 'I gave my Ireland jersey to 'Church', he's done so much for me' Jack Boyle: 'I gave my Ireland jersey to 'Church', he's done so much for me'
Search