Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Ireland player ratings vs South Africa | Rugby World Cup 2023

Tadhg Furlong of Ireland, centre, and Iain Henderson celebrate winning a scrum penalty during the 2023 Rugby World Cup Pool B match between South Africa and Ireland at Stade de France in Paris, France. (Photo By Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile via Getty Images)

Ireland made a major statement to the rest of the World Cup on Saturday evening at the Stade de France as they overcame the world champions South Africa 13-8.

ADVERTISEMENT

It was a brutal affair between the world number ones and the reigning champions with Andy Farrell’s outfit holding out a late onslaught from the Boks to win.

Now Ireland are in pole position to win Pool B, here are how the players rated:

15 – Hugo Keenan – 8
Set the tone for the Irish with his first run and was a constant threat with ball in hand. His balance in heavy traffic is remarkable and is getting better with every test match

14 – Mack Hansen – 8
A well taken try made up for an early dropped high kick and he is a player who has that marvellous ability to be in the right place at the right time although he almost ran over the dead ball line before putting the ball down.
That was too close for comfort.

13 – Garry Ringrose – 7
Had to go off for a HIA in the first half after taking a big blow but responded in typical fashion by putting his mark on his opposite number.

12 – Bundee Aki – 9
What a first charge from the big man which let the Springboks know there was a physical threat coming their way. He is playing at a level that makes him one of the outstanding backs at the World Cup. His off loading game is right up there with the best.

ADVERTISEMENT

11 – James Lowe – 8
Early positional mistake did not affect is bubbling confidence as he gave the scoring pass to Hansen and then rescued his side by ripping the ball away from the opposition as they drove for the try line. Became an even bigger national hero lifting Etzebeth off the ground.

10 – Johnny Sexton (capt) – 7
Massive hit on his right shoulder had him in trouble but this is warrior who is used to be roughed up. Clever break held the Springbok defence when they wanted to go wide and it created the space for the Hansen try.

9 – Jamison Gibson-Park – 6
Was exposed too often by the Boks charging him down or scragging him at the break down. His service was as quick as ever although his overall game suffered because of the pressure he was under

1 – Andrew Porter – 6
Good work clearing out the break down but things did not go his way in the scrums with a couple of big decisions against him in this key area

ADVERTISEMENT

2 – Ronan Kelleher – 5
Had a nightmare at the line out in the first half including a not straight but instead of letting his head drop he bounced back but will be frustrated that his bread and butter work wasn’t up to standard.

3 – Tadhg Furlong – 6
The scrums did not go Ireland’s way at key moments and the big made had to take on plenty of piano shifting in the tight rather than carrying the ball into the opposition

4 – James Ryan – 6
Line out problems were not solved quickly enough and this was the type of game that shows he lacks the sheer brute strength to be a commanding figure

5 – Tadhg Beirne – 7
Stuck in the fight although not the ball carrying performance he normally delivers and that meant plenty of unglamorous work around the break down and knocking down opponents

6 – Peter O’Mahony – 8
Was his combative best when others found it tough to stand their ground. Was the go to man when the line out was malfunctioning and put in a big shift – but what’s new for this fighter

7 – Josh van der Flier – 7
A first half turn over and a refusal to back down despite facing bigger back row opponents made it a ferocious battle for the open side who confirmed his position as one of the best in the game

8 – Caelan Doris – 7
Not the impact he wanted to make although he kept putting his body on the line and that was vital against the Springbok pack and their second half replacements

Replacements: – 6

Dan Sheehan made immediate impact with his line out accuracy while Iain Henderson added fire and fury at the break down while Finlay Bealham was busy

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

S
SK 58 minutes ago
What is the future of rugby in 2025?

Set pieces are important and the way teams use them is a great indication of how they play the game. No team is showcasing their revolution more than the Springboks. This year they have mauled less and primarily in the attacking third. Otherwise they have tended to set like they are going to maul and then play around the corner or shove the ball out the back. They arent also hitting the crash ball carrier constantly but instead they are choosing to use their width or a big carrying forward in wider areas. While their maul is varied the scrum is still a blunt instrument winning penalties before the backs have a go. Some teams have chosen to blunt their set piece game for more control. The All Blacks are kicking more penalties and are using their powerful scrum as an attacking tool choosing that set piece as an attacking weapon. Their willingness to maul more and in different positions is also becoming more prominent. The French continue to play conservative rugby off the set piece using their big bruisers frequently. The set piece is used differently by different teams. Different teams play different ways and can be successful regardless. They can win games with little territory and possession or smash teams with plenty of both. The game of rugby is for all types and sizes and thats true in the modern era. I hope that administrators keep it that way and dont go further towards a Rugby League style situation. Some administrators are of the opinion that rugby is too slow and needs to be sped up. Why not rather empower teams to choose how they want to play and create a framework that favours neither size nor agility. That favours neither slow tempo play or rock n roll rugby. Create a game that favour both and challenge teams to execute their plans. If World Rugby can create a game like that then it will be the ultimate winner.

34 Go to comments
J
JW 6 hours ago
'Let's not sugarcoat it': Former All Black's urgent call to protect eligibility rules

Yep, no one knows what will happen. Thing is I think (this is me arguing a point here not a random debate with this one) they're better off trialing it now in a controlled environment than waiting to open it up in a knee jerk style reaction to a crumbling organtization and team. They can always stop it again.


The principle idea is that why would players leave just because the door is ajar?


BBBR decides to go but is not good enough to retain the jersey after doing it. NZ no longer need to do what I suggest by paying him to get back upto speed. That is solely a concept of a body that needs to do what I call pick and stick wth players. NZR can't hold onto everyone so they have to choose their BBBRs and if that player comes back from a sabbatical under par it's a priority to get him upto speed as fast as possible because half of his competition has been let go overseas because they can't hold onto them all. Changing eligibility removes that dilemma, if a BBBR isn't playing well you can be assured that someone else is (well the idea is that you can be more assured than if you only selected from domestic players).


So if someone decides they want to go overseas, they better do it with an org than is going to help improve them, otherwise theyre still basically as ineligible as if they would have been scorning a NZ Super side that would have given them the best chance to be an All Black.

147 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Does South Africa have a future in European competition? Does South Africa have a future in European competition?
Search