1
'It's an absolute joke. It's a complete joke...for me, that isn't even a penalty'
By Sam Smith
Former Irish international Stephen Ferris has blasted the decision-making in the United Rugby Championship clash between the Bulls and Ulster that saw lock Kieran Treadwell yellow carded for a high tackle on fullback Kurt-Lee Arendse.
ADVERTISEMENT
The circumstances of the TMO intervention infuriated both Ferris and ex-Springbok captain Bobby Skinstad, with play having moved on way past the innocuous tackle for two more phases before it was called back by the referee.
At the time the Bulls held a four point lead at 20-16 with a quarter of the game to go with both sides still in the game but the yellow card swayed the match in the home side’s favour, with the Bulls scoring shortly afterward against a 14-man Ulster side.
Video Player is loading.
Ferris labelled the call an ‘absolute joke’ on Premier Sports post-match show and argued that the tackle did not even warrant a penalty.
“It’s an absolute joke. It’s a complete joke… you cannot freeze frame it,” Ferris explained on Premier Sports.
“Kieran Treadwell hits the ball with his shoulder. When he hits the ball with the shoulder, there is a little bit of head movement. You can clearly see, it’s on the ball.
“If anything, his face brushes the jersey. There is no direct impact to the head, none whatsoever.
ADVERTISEMENT
“You can freeze frame all you want, but play it in real time. For me, that isn’t even a penalty.
“Yes, a couple of inches higher it is a really dangerous tackle, and that’s what we are trying to get away from.
“But Bobby, if this is going to be yellow cards going forward…. and you know what, what happens two minutes afterward? Maul try, and for me that was the game.”
Ex-Springbok loose forward Bob Skinstad was equally disappointed with the call and called out TMO Marius Jonker for having too much influence on proceedings, claiming he ‘had no place getting involved’ in that circumstance.
“Look, player welfare is paramount, we know that. If you think Stephen was getting excited about why it shouldn’t be a card, I was even worse,” he said.
ADVERTISEMENT
“For me, that’s a job’s worth role. I know Marius Jonker, he was a good referee, he’s got absolutely no place getting involved there.
“That is ’cause and effect’, that’s rugby, he’s made a tackle. Ulster actually had a penalty way up the field, he’s gone all the way back and actually ruined the last twenty minutes of a spectacle.
“I don’t think that was a very smart nor technically proficient piece of adjudicating.
“I’m sad, the game was coming into its own. It was exciting, Ulster had just scored, the Bulls were an attacking position. We spoke about it being a one score game, which is what it was going to be.
“I’m not happy there. You can hide behind ‘protecting the head’ and say let’s stop for every little tiny brush of an elbow going past some guy’s neck area by mistake.
“Literally you could be playing touch rugby and hit someone with your elbow. I don’t think we should call back for that kind of thing ever again. It’s ridiculous.”
The standard of officiating in the URC has been horrendous however the worst receipiants have been the South African franchises particularly in the first part of the season.. NH refs enjoy stifling games rather than allowing free flowing rugby
Yip. The same Marius Jonker that cost the Boks victory in the first test against
the B.& I Lions...... I agree, why is he still there? Ulster was robbed.
And by the way, some referee decisions when SA teams were up North, was as questionable(Connacht vs Stormers,etc). Let's just say refs will get some things wrong no matter where they are from. As they say "it's part of the game"
PS: All the games played in SA were refereed by Northern refs. NO ON FIELD SA REFS WERE USED........
URC, for me is a brilliant tournament, seeing some Irish, Scottish & Wales legends is really an honour.
Okay so now that's out of the way. How about the CLEAR deliberate elbow to the face of Zak by one of the Ulster players. That should have been red. Guess yellow seems better then.
Is Marius South African? Then what do you expect? He is only human susceptible to favoritism, nepotism, patriotism and cheatism masquerading as error, mistake and incompetence. He's done a lot of damage in games. Please retire him asap.
2 games in South Africa and 2 games Ulster where hard done by