1
'It's madness. It's undefendable' - Ireland prop's yellow infuriates NZ
By Ian Cameron
A yellow card for Ireland loosehead Andrew Porter for head-high collision with New Zealand’s Brodie Retallick has gone down like a fart in an elevator on social media.
ADVERTISEMENT
Porter’s head struck Retallick in the 53rd minute, a collision that the 6’7 second row removed from the field for a HIA, which he ultimately failed.
Experienced matchday referee Wayne Barnes referred it to the TMO and after replays were shown on the big screen and broadcast around the world, many were expecting a red card to be brandished.
Video Player is loading.
This is a modal window.
The Video Cloud video was not found.
Error Code: VIDEO_CLOUD_ERR_VIDEO_NOT_FOUND
Session ID: 2025-05-29:58f6b0c191ba7328fbe75bc Player Element ID: brightcove-embedded-video
However, Barnes explained that as Porter absorbed the hit as a passive tackler, it was adjudged to only have met the yellow card threshold, having been mitigated down from a red.
Despite, the tackle being passive, Retallick’s HIA was very real and he didn’t return to the field.
Should Andrew Porter have received a red card for this incident? Or was a yellow card fair?
A potentially defining moment of the game #NZvIRE pic.twitter.com/M7uBHBKcQB
— Sky Sports Rugby Union (@SkySportsRugby) July 16, 2022
What made the decision more egregious for most fans was that Angus Ta’avao was red-carded for a head collision with Ireland centre Garry Ringrose just a week earlier in the second Test.
A yellow card can make all the difference ? It's not quite over yet for NZ #rugby #NZLvIRE pic.twitter.com/uwuMgerjJT
— RugbyPass (@RugbyPass) July 16, 2022
Many were left scratching their heads at the call.
Former second row Jim Hamilton wrote: “Brodie Retallick looks like he “absorbed” that tackle by breaking his eyes socket.”
ADVERTISEMENT
Brodie Retallick looks like he “absorbed” that tackle by breaking his eyes socket. #NZLvIRE
— Jim Hamilton (Vice Captain) (@jimhamilton4) July 16, 2022
“A huge number of posters from the NH last week suggested that NZ and the SH nations haven’t adjusted to the high tackle laws due to lenient punishments in Super Rugby,” wrote RugbyPass journalist Tom Vinicombe. “Andrew Porter just getting a yellow there has raised many questions about NH law interpretations.”
A huge number of posters from the NH last week suggested that NZ and the SH nations haven't adjusted to the high tackle laws due to lenient punishments in Super Rugby.
Andrew Porter just getting a yellow there has raised many questions about NH law interpretations. #NZLvIRE
— Tom Vinicombe (@TomVinicombe) July 16, 2022
Newcastle Falcons media manager Mark Smith wrote: “How was Porter only a yellow but Sean Robinson at Northampton gets red and a 3-week ban? This whole ‘mitigation’ lottery is infuriating. Seems to vary wildly from week to week, ref to ref.”
How was Porter only a yellow but Sean Robinson at Northampton gets red and a 3-week ban?
This whole ‘mitigation’ lottery is infuriating. Seems to vary wildly from week to week, ref to ref.
— mark smith (@markismith50) July 16, 2022
Rugby Report Card posted: “They are taking the piss. How is that a yellow bug last week is a red. What’s doing? We have thrown the baby out with bath water and we have thrown out consistency. It’s madness. It’s undefendable at this point”
ADVERTISEMENT
They are taking the piss. How is that a yellow bug last week is a red. What’s doing? We have thrown the baby out with bath water and we have thrown out consistency. It’s madness. It’s undefendable at this point #NZLvIRE
— Rugby Report Card (@rugby_podcast) July 16, 2022
“I’m an Irish fan, but think Porter is incredibly fortunate there,” wrote EK Rugby Analysis on Twitter. “Not a fan of medium force mitigation”
I'm an Irish fan, but think Porter is incredibly fortunate there. Not a fan of medium force mitigation#NZLvIRE
— EK Rugby Analysis (@ek_rugby) July 16, 2022
“Different week. Different interpretation of the rules. Would have been a red card last week,” wrote one fan.
Different week. Different interpretation of the rules. Would have been a red card last week #NZLvIRE
— Lainey ? (@NZLainey) July 16, 2022
It’s a debate that will roll on.
Bundee Aki's hit in the ruck on Ofa was shoulder directly on hed, the latter went off and failed HIA - enough said!
I can understand the frustration, yet another example of why the laws need to be simplified. It does no favours to referees and TMO's who are under enormous pressure as it is. Barnes is however a class act, in the final analysis NZ were outclassed on attack and defence.
The law is quite simple. Andrew Porter stands his ground and Retallick runs into him. Totally different to last week.
The three best sounds in rugby are the Welsh national anthem at Cardiff, Fields Of Athenry in Dublin, and kiwis moaning worldwide. Long may it continue.
The law is quite simple, yet you fundamentally fail to understand it.
The tackler has to adjust his body height to avoid head contact.
Last week the Irish player side stepped into Taavao, yet Taavao got the red card.
The tackler is holding his ground. That's gold.
Pathetic
If it were South Africa I would say the referee did us a favour. If there had been a red card and ZN has burgled a win the discussion about how they could for the first time be trailing by 19 points in the first half - no cards involved and how they looked completely out of their depth for most of the game. Hopefully for NZ the focus will now be on how bad NZ were rather than how bad the officiating was.