Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Joe Marler wasn't wrong to take a pop at the All Blacks' haka

Joe Marler of England reacts during the Rugby World Cup France 2023 match between England and South Africa at Stade de France on October 21, 2023 in Paris, France. (Photo by Craig Mercer/MB Media/Getty Images)

Sport needs more Joe Marlers.

Folk with a sense of humour, good points to make and the thick skin to wear the criticism that inevitably comes their way.

ADVERTISEMENT

I applaud Marler, the accomplished England prop, for his latest pop at the All Blacks haka.

I get that the haka is culturally – and commercially – important to the All Blacks and New Zealand Rugby, but I’ve never felt everyone else had to treat it reverentially.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

It was something the All Blacks used to do on tour, but not at home. A largely token exercise it was too, until Wayne Shelford invested more mana into the whole thing.

Those of us of a certain vintage remember the coming together of Shelford and Ireland’s Willie Anderson in 1989 as one of the great moments in the history of the haka.

Teams are kept apart in rugby now and I can see why.

One of the more memorable pre-match challenges I ever saw was between the New Zealand Maori and Cook Islands rugby league teams, in Hawke’s Bay about 20 years ago.

I say memorable because that ended in a brawl, after the two teams got a little too close for comfort.

Related

ADVERTISEMENT

As surprising and exciting as that was, it’s not the sort of thing you want to see at Twickenham every time the All Blacks come to town.

I’ve always felt New Zealand’s national sevens teams get the haka right. They perform it if and when they win a title, in large part because the tight schedule of tournaments doesn’t allow for it to happen before every match.

I’d quite like to see it become an aftermatch ritual for the All Blacks as well, not least because for all the good haka I’ve seen in recent seasons, they’ve often been the prelude to defeat.

The Kiwis rugby league team, for instance, produced a spine tingling haka ahead of Sunday’s test against Australia. Only problem was, the 80 minutes that followed weren’t marked by quite the same levels of ferocity and cohesion.

ADVERTISEMENT

Some of Australia’s players smirked afterwards, which no doubt upset a few sensitive folk, and that’s partly the issue Marler is driving at.

Just because the haka matters to us, doesn’t mean it has to matter to everyone else. Teams shouldn’t have to undergo cultural sensitivity training around how to receive the haka, just because New Zealand teams insist upon doing it.

I remember a time in the 1990s when Wallabies loose forward Sam Scott-Young blew kisses at the All Blacks during the haka.

It’s probably not something I would do, but I’d defend Scott-Young’s right to do it.

Marler’s bound to have offended people with his tweet about the haka and it’ll become a topic of pre match post-match chat in London as journalists, starved for actually interesting topics, resort to driving a wedge between the teams on the basis that the haka is some sort of sacred cow.

I was never much of a rugby player, but I played 1st XV footy and took great pride in performing the school haka ahead of our matches. The thing is, though, the opposition did theirs too.

A challenge was laid down, then another accepted in response.

That’s our rugby culture, but it’s not Marler’s or England’s and I’m not sure we’re in a position to demand that he likes, or even respects, our desire to do it.

Louis Rees-Zammit joins Jim Hamilton for the latest episode of Walk the Talk to discuss his move to the NFL. Watch now on RugbyPass TV

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

7 Comments
F
Flankly 46 mins ago

Test teams don't get much time to practice together. So it's great news for opponents if a team spends precious practice time on coordinating dance moves.

W
Wayneo 1 hr ago

As soon as possible after Billy Brontosaurus gets put out to pasture WR must get rid of the rule about the distance between the players when the Haka is being performed.


People don't get that the Haka is a challenge and that challenge must be reciprocated however the opposing team chose.


People had a go at the Ellis Park fans for the way they drowned out the Haka but that's the way they reciprocate to the Haka challenge.


If the England team is not allowed to advance and get up close and personal when the Haka is being informed, then there is nothing stopping the fans from making some noise.

A
Another 1 hr ago

Is the build up to this game so boring that we have to do yet another round of ‘let’s ban the Haka’?

G
GM 1 hr ago

Let's keep the haka, and the have the Poms do a Morris dance in response - the Scots can bust out the bag-pipes, the Aussies can thrash around looking for their wallets, and we can start the game three hours early so that we can accomodate all the correct cultural responses.

B
Bob Salad II 2 hours ago

In all likelihood, I doubt Marler will play against the ABs again.

H
Head high tackle 2 hours ago

I was never much of a rugby player


Never much of a writer either. Great at hating on your own countrymen tho. You have that nailed down in EVERY article you write badly.

J
JWH 2 hours ago

Idk if he's pulling a Justin Marshall or not - go against the ABs until the last few minutes and then unleash reverential praise on them. Just glaze them to death.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

TRENDING
TRENDING Assistant coach applauds All Blacks midfield as selection talk simmers Kiwi midfield heralded as selection talk simmers
Search