Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

‘Another patch of grass’: Waratahs eye historic upset at Eden Park

Dan McKellar head coach of the Waratahs looks on ahead of the round nine Super Rugby Pacific match between NSW Waratahs and Chiefs at Allianz Stadium on April 11, 2025 in Sydney, Australia. (Photo by Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images)

Dan McKellar knows the NSW Waratahs head into their season-defining clash with the Blues as firm underdogs, but the coach remains hopeful of an upset, with the visitors chasing a historic result on “just another patch of grass” at Eden Park.

ADVERTISEMENT

One-Test Wallaby Darby Lancaster was the hero for the Tahs last weekend at Perth’s HBF Park, as the winger crossed for a speculator last-gasp try to steal a win against the Western Force. With the match going to Super Point, it came down to an incredible try in the final play.

After shocking the Chiefs 21-14 on April 11, the Tahs lost their next four matches before making the long trip out west. If the New South Welshman failed to beat the men from Western Australia, then their hopes of making the playoffs would’ve been over.

Video Spacer
Video Spacer

The Force had some chances to steal it themselves, but the match seemed destined for a draw before Lancaster’s somersault finish. With one more round left in the regulaanr season, the Tahs are still a chance of playing finals football.

If the Tahs beat the Blues at Eden Park for the first time since 2009, then they’ll move on to the next stage if Moana Pasifika fail to stun the Hurricanes in Wellington on Saturday. After starting their season on Valentines Day, the Tahs’ entire campaign comes down to this.

“We understand the challenge that’s in front of us, but we’re certainly excited about it,” McKellar told reporters in Sydney on Thursday.

“I don’t think there would be a whole lot of people tipping us.

“To a certain extent that takes the pressure off, but internally there is pressure.

“We are not going to go over there to have a nice performance where we lose the game in a close scenario. We want to go over there and win.”

Head-to-Head

Last 5 Meetings

Wins
5
Draws
0
Wins
0
Average Points scored
35
13
First try wins
60%
Home team wins
60%

ADVERTISEMENT

McKellar has made a surprise selection call ahead of the Blues battle, with Jack Bowen named at fly-half for the first time this season. Bowen will join rising star Teddy Wilson in the halves, with regular halfback and captain Jake Gordon ruled out with an injury.

One-Test Wallaby Tane Edmed will instead look to provide impact off the bench, while Lawson Creighton has been retained at fullback. Edmed has shown signs of promise in the No. 10 jumper in recent weeks, but experience off the bench could be key.

Bowen will line up opposite former two-time World Rugby Player of the Year Beauden Barrett, who will drive a star-studded team around the park in attack. Mark Tele’a, Caleb Clarke and Rieko Ioane are among those in the Blues’ All-Star-esque backline.

“Most teams are difficult to beat at home. But Eden Park, it’s not like it is a tough place to play,” McKellar said.

ADVERTISEMENT

“It’s a beautiful stadium … but we just have to understand that it’s another patch of grass.

“It’s a nice stadium and we play in plenty of those. And the Brumbies showed early in the year that it [winning] is possible.

“We just have to make sure that we don’t do anything out of the ordinary other than go over there and do your job and perform well.”

Download the RugbyPass app now!

News, stats, live rugby and more! Download the new RugbyPass app on the App Store (iOS) and Google Play (Android) now!

ADVERTISEMENT
LIVE

Quarter Finals | Rugby Africa Cup

England v South Africa | World Rugby U20 Championship | Extended Highlights

Georgia vs Ireland | Men’s International | Full Match Replay

Lions Share | Episode 2

Chile vs Romania | Men’s International | Full Match Replay

USA vs Belgium | Men’s International | Full Match Replay

KOKO Show | July 1st | The Lions are here and the KOKO crew are getting excited

Touchdown in Dublin, The Red Sea Returns & We Prepare to Face Argentina | Ep 2: The Ultimate Test

South Africa v British & Irish Lions | 2009 | Second Test | The Vaults

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

E
Ed the Duck 11 minutes ago
Can Les Bleus avoid a Black-wash in New Zealand?

Florian Grill, President FFR 20.5.2025


https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360695274/french-rugby-boss-says-les-bleus-stars-could-tour-they-target-series-win-against-all-blacks


“French rugby is indeed based on a unique model, built around the Top 14 - a championship of exceptional intensity - and an ambitious national team, This demanding model places a significant physical and mental toll on players throughout the season. We therefore have a major responsibility: to look after their physical and mental health and to ensure they have essential rest periods. In this context, the selection for the July tour is based on two clear principles. First, an in-depth analysis conducted by the French team staff evaluates the players’ physical integrity, fatigue level, and current performance level in order to build a squad that is both strong and mindful of the players’ balance. Second, the formation of the group also respects a regulatory framework, jointly defined by the FFR and the LNR, which notably states that players who participate in the Top 14 final are not eligible for selection for a summer tour. However, exceptions are possible and are currently being discussed with the LNR.”


So there’s a few things to take from that where it’s clear that the Top 14 fixtures are at the core of the issue. It appears that the 2000 minutes or 25 games parameters are likely to be part of the “regulatory framework, jointly defined by the FFR and the LNR” but it’s also clear that this has been considered alongside a bespoke analysis of each players situation, for the purposes of NZ tour selection, and NOT applied in a rigid and homogenous style. Factors including the level/intensity of matches played, timing of match load across the season, injury profile and date of season end will all have been reviewed, alongside many others no doubt.


The comparison with Englands experience is particularly relevant since it also highlights the current difference between the two countries’ league relationship with their union. The RFU have reached an (expensive) agreement with the GP that has taken many years to evolve and, critically, hands full season playing control of a designated group of 25 Test players to the England coach. The French agreements do not operate in the same way, where playing control sits with the clubs outside of the Test windows and this is key to the issues.


The difficulty for France however is that the Top 14 needs the weekend numbers that it needs and it’s not immediately clear how they can reduce them. The extension of their final has happened in conjunction with reducing 6N/AI overlap but they still haven’t managed to fully eliminate this. While it’s not clear how these issues can be easily or quickly resolved, it is very clear that the problem can not be simply defined as France disrespecting international rugby.

26 Go to comments
t
takata 1 hour ago
Can Les Bleus avoid a Black-wash in New Zealand?

The men at the beating heart of France’s first Test effort at Dunedin – number eight Guillard, the four half-backs [Le Garrec or Jauneau at nine, Segonds or Hastoy at 10], Fickou at 12 and Attissogbe at full-back] are all in imminent danger of playing over 2000 minutes, or over 30 games, or both. Overall, it is very hard to see what France is gaining in the player welfare equation. It is simply replacing one set of overworked players with another.

A very simple explanation is that, bar Joris Seconds at Bayonne, none of those players, Guillard (Lyon), Le Garrec (Racing), Hastoy (La Rochelle), Fickou (Racing) and Attissogbe (Pau) clocked much time during the highest level games of the club season which ended 7 days before the first test; their club didn’t qualify for the European Champions Cup final rounds and/or didn’t play the Top 14 play off.


So they all had quite a few off weekends that barely none of the first list could have enjoyed up to the end of June, except those injured or not in their prime. ie. Baille started only 5 games for Toulouse and 0 for France during the whole 2024-2025 season -explaining his stats- and it would have make no sense to send him over younger lads.


Joris Seconds (28), has a lot of game sheets, but shared all his game time at Nr. 10 with Camille Lopez (who is retired now); ie. he only clocked 108’ during his two last games in play off. He could also fully rest during the 6 Nations when Top 14 wasn’t playing.


Secondly, bar Mikaël Guillard, this second list was also made of players that weren’t used at all, or very little, during the whole 6 Nations. Guillard started 3/5 games and clocked 187’, Attissogbe 160’ - 2/2 start, Fickou 80’ - 1/1 start, Le Garrec 50’ - 0/3 start, plus a few more minutes by others.


Thirdly, it’s clear that Galthié wanted some preparation time and a full game (England A) before Dunedin. Most of his first 23 just did that as they ended their season on 7 June. His selection of 42 players was planned in 3 groups pending their availability: 28 + 9 + 5. Some players joined after the first group but could still make the game sheet at Dunedin because they were obviously needed.


But, as Galthié usually do, the first test team will rotate and very few will actually play all three tests (maybe Le Garrec & Seconds?). From what we know already, neither Guillard (@ 8) nor Villière (@ 11) will be on the next game sheet - so your projections on game time / game played are not worth the time you took to type them:


Here is the probable team for next test (with age and club):


Backs: Barré (22, Paris), Attissogbe (20, Pau), Depoortere (22, Bordeaux)

Centers: Barrassi (27, Toulouse), Gailleton (22, Pau)

Halfs: Seconds (28, Bayonne), Le Garrec (23, La Rochelle ex-Racing)

3rd Row: Van Tonder (27, Perpignan), Abadie (27, Toulon), Bochaton (24, Bordeaux)

2nd Row: Halagahu (23, Toulon), Brenan (23, Toulouse)

1st Row: Colombe (27, Toulouse ex-La Rochelle), Barlot (28, Castres), Erdocio (25, Montpellier)


Bench: Bourgarit (27, La Rochelle), Mallez (24, Toulouse/Aix), Montagne (24, Clermont), Taofifenua (34, Racing), Woki (26, Bordeaux ex-Racing), Vergnes-Taillefer (28, Bordeaux), Daubagna (31, Pau), Hastoy (28, La Rochelle).

26 Go to comments
S
Soliloquin 1 hour ago
Can Les Bleus avoid a Black-wash in New Zealand?

Thanks for that article! The analogy is very interesting, and it helps opening up the player welfare debate around the number of games and minutes played.

Better rested players mean more quality rugby. It means less risk of injury, so less risk of losing money by paying a salary to an injured player.

But it also means choices of games.


For those French players who were not involved in the Top14 playoffs, yet approaching and breaking the 2000’/25 games criteria, like Fickou, Auradou, Le Garrec or Guillard, were the 3 weeks enough to rest between the last game of the season and the first test?

While bearing in mind there was still a game the week before against a strong English squad at Twickenham.


Top 14 clubs and the LNR (but also the ECPR) need to understand that they hugely participate in the fatigue of players - LBB stated that he was utterly exhausted by the season 2 days ago. And adding this World Club competition is scary, scarily resembling the current World Club competition in football held in the US, which pushes some players to go beyond 70 games/year…


Would a restriction of games per player possible, so that they could be involved in Summer tours a possibility? With maybe part of the salary taken care by the French Federation, proportionate to the number of missed games?

How such a compensation could come? Can the French Federation find the funds for that?

What is the number of games possible? How would fare the clubs fighting relegation - like how could Stade Français accept this season, when they saved themselves almost during the last round, that Léo Barré could stop playing for the club if he was to go on tour against NZ with so much at stake?


I have no clue for all of that, but I have no doubt solutions can be found.

26 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING There be monsters: The 13 biggest World Rugby U20 Champions players There be monsters: The biggest World Rugby U20 Champions players
Search