Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Just one vote stopped former internationals from switching Test allegiances

Charles Piutau. (Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images)

The chairman of Pacific Rugby Players, Hale T-Pole, has revealed that one of rugby’s most discussed potential eligibility law changes was almost ratified at a recent World Rugby meeting.

ADVERTISEMENT

There has been much lobbying over the last decade to allow players to represent more than one nation at Test match level.

Under the current laws, once a player has been capped, he is no longer able to switch allegiances. This has resulted in a number of players – primarily of Pacific Island descent – earning a handful of caps for a tier-one nation and then spending the rest of their days restricted from taking part in international football.

Suggestions have been pushed forward that would allow players to play for a second nation, providing they meet all the other eligibility criteria and have only had a small stint with the Test team they were initially selected in.

World Rugby considered such a law but it didn’t quite make it off the ground.

Continue reading below…

Video Spacer

“We lost out by one vote last time,” T-Pole told Stuff News recently.

T-Pole believes that even if the law had been ratified, it would be just a “short-term fix”.

“From where we stand it’s a tricky one because we want to push for our players but the reality is they’ve played their best rugby trying to get to the All Blacks and if they don’t make it we get the second part of their career,” said T-Pole.

ADVERTISEMENT

New Zealand’s only eligibility laws mean that a player has to reside in the country in order to represent the All Blacks. That rule has resulted in countless players being forced to choose between the money on offer from representing clubs in Japan or Europe, or playing for the world’s most successful rugby nation.

https://www.instagram.com/p/B8P8780AvVV/

For Pacific players, having the ability to send money home to the islands where funds available are considerably less plentiful than in the developed rugby world makes it tough to stay in New Zealand.

Clubs in Europe are especially happy to bring these types of players north because they won’t have to take time out from the domestic game in order to play Test rugby.

Allowing players to switch national allegiances would thus have a significant impact on the power-brokers in the Northern Hemisphere.

ADVERTISEMENT

There’s also a train of thought that representing New Zealand and also wanting to earn a living is for some reason an insult to the game.

“They say, ‘You can’t go and play for the All Blacks and make a name and a bit of money and then apply to change’,” T-Pole said. “I understand that.”

WATCH: Clubs fear RFU’s savage second-tier funding cut ‘will affect many people’s livelihoods’.

Video Spacer
ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

F
Flankly 26 minutes ago
Jake White: If I was England coach, I’d have been livid

I am not an England fan, but still very disappointed at what Borthwick is serving up. Regardless of winning or losing, they should be executing the basics at a world class level. That was the reason they replaced Eddie with Steve. After two years England has not built the solid foundations that the RFU were presumably after. Its hard to see it as anything other than a coaching problem.


Having said that I really hope that Rassie has got his team fired up for the game. The Boks at maximum intensity and with no crises (eg red cards) would be expected to win this game. But it does not take much reduction in pressure for Bok teams to lose. The Boks lose when complacency sets in.


On Felix Jones, my guess is that they can't agree on a non-compete so they kept him on payroll for the duration of the Nov tests. The risk was that he would be hired by Rassie or Razor prior to the tests.


As relates to law tweaking, it feels like WR are more comfortable discussing changes in laws than insisting on implementation. For my money the biggest thing they could do is to be strict and consistent in officiating ruck behavior. In every game we see flopping, lazy lying, clearing of unbound players, making plays while off your feet, delays in placing the ball, side entry, offside line infringements, and similar nonsense. It's really really bad, and the WR attitude seems to be that we should turn a blind eye in pursuit of "flowing rugby". In truth it's just boring, because it randomizes the outcome.

9 Go to comments
N
NH 2 hours ago
Battle of the breakdown to determine Wallabies’ grand slam future

Nice one John. I agree that defence (along with backfield kick receipt/positioning) remains their biggest issue, but that I did see some small improvements in it despite the scoreline like the additional jackal attempts from guys like tupou and the better linespeed in tight. But, I still see two issues - 1) yes they are jackaling, but as you point out they aren't slowing the ball down. I think some dark arts around committing an extra tackler, choke tackles, or a slower roll away etc could help at times as at the moment its too easy for oppo teams to get quick ball (they miss L wright). Do you have average ruck speed? I feel like teams are pretty happy these days to cop a tackle behind the ad line if they still get quick ball... and 2) I still think the defence wide of the 3-4th forward man out looks leaky and disconnected and if sua'ali'i is going to stay at 13 I think we could see some real pressure through that channel from other teams. The wallabies discipline has improved and so they are giving away less 3 pt opportunities and kicks into their 22 via penalty. Now, they need to be able to force teams to turnover the ball and hold them out. They scramble quite well once a break is made, but they seem to need the break to happen first... Hunter, marika and daugunu were other handy players to put ruck pressure on. Under rennie, they used to counter ruck quite effectively to put pressure on at the b/down as well.

3 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ 'Two groups of dancing bears': The cross-code clash making a comeback for charity 'Two groups of dancing bears': The cross-code clash making a comeback for charity
Search