1
‘Where’s the leadership’: Justin Marshall reacts to All Blacks’ ‘worrying’ defeat
By Finn Morton
Former New Zealand halfback Justin Marshall has questioned the All Blacks’ leadership after their “worrying” 35-7 loss to South Africa ahead of next month’s Rugby World Cup.
ADVERTISEMENT
It was one of the darkest days in the history of the All Blacks. Playing against the world champion Springboks at Twickenham on Friday, the New Zealanders fell to a record-setting defeat.
First-half tries to Siya Kolisi and Kurt-Lee Arendse set the tone for the Boks, but a red card – which was the result of two yellow cards – to Scott Barrett was the final nail in the All Blacks’ coffin.
Much to the surprise of commentator Justin Marshall, the All Blacks continued to make the same mistakes time and time again during the second term as they succumbed to a disastrous defeat.
“I was really surprised to be honest, mate, that the All Blacks struggled the way they did,” Marshall said on The Platform. “They pretty much got ambushed by a side that came out super physical, super committed, was massively positive.
“I think I said during the commentary that Siya Kolisi turned down many kicking opportunities to try and accumulate points which sometimes South Africa tend to do to go for more.
“Eventually that led to obviously yellow, red cards, and the All Blacks just not being able to maintain the intensity that South Africa brought to the game.
ADVERTISEMENT
“We’ve spoken for the last two weeks, three weeks mate that we needed to get our number one side out there, and needed to go out there and flex our muscles and make a statement about intent of Rugby World Cup.
“Credit to Ian Foster he named a full-strength side to a degree but they just weren’t up for it. They just mentally weren’t there and I can’t understand why.”
With coach Ian Foster at the helm, the All Blacks recorded big wins over Argentina, South Africa and Australia on their way to another Rugby Championship crown last month.
The All Blacks also claimed the Freedom Cup and Bledisloe Cup as they charged into last Friday’s Test on the back of four wins from as many starts. They looked good, very good to start their international season.
ADVERTISEMENT
But that’s what made the 35-7 scoreline so surprising. Nobody expected the Springboks to inflict such pain and despair about the All Blacks and their supporters, but records are made to be broken.
“There’s been too much read into how well the All Blacks went in The Rugby Championship in terms of how far they had come,” Marhsall added.
“I certainly feel that South Africa really did their homework. They looked at what happened to them at Mt Smart, they brought a completely different style of defence… they were a different beast.
“When you get that in the opposition, and there is a change in their DNA and the way that they’re playing, then you’ve got to recognise that really quickly and adjust and that’s exactly what the All Blacks didn’t do, they did the opposite.
“They looked stunned, they looked shocked, they looked clueless as to how they could find a way to break down the aggressive line speed that South Africa brought.”
Coach Foster named a near full-strength side to take on the Boks, too, which is “worrying” going into the Rugby World Cup.
All Blacks Brodie Retallick and Shannon Frizell missed the Test due to injury, but the rest of the starting side was practically at full strength.
“The All Blacks, which is worrying…the side they put out was full of experience, been to World Cups before, there’s enough personnel out there to know, ‘Okay, the opposition is doing this to us, we’ve got to adjust, we’ve got to adapt’ (and) didn’t.
“That’s the thing that really bemused me; the fact they weren’t able to combat it and just simply continued to do the same things that revolved around them making the same mistakes and getting themselves under the same pressure and huge ill-discipline because they weren’t coping.
“Where’s the leadership?”
Agree with Justin re leadership, however Sam Cane should never have been picked as Captain from the start..
Wrong coach, wrong captain, wrong fullback. What gets me is there was no evidence of a Plan B or C from Sam Cane, he's so one dimensional. Someone like McCaw always adapted superbly onfield when things were going wrong and so can Sam Whitelock who should always have kept the captaincy. France v South Africa for the final - vive le France!!
True dat, have to agree with everything you said. Roll on post RWC so we can reset & go again under Razor.
Agree with Justin. If Cane isn't there for his leadership attributes - and he can't be on the evidence of Dunedin and Twickenham - then what is he doing there? Noticeable in Dunedin that it was Whitelock who led by example in the second half. Cane is lost when the shit hits the fan. WTF were those winks about?
What about Foster and Ryan? Surely the coaches should have understood something about bok lineout tactics and relayed that to the team?
It's not only Cane - there is a leadership group: Savea, Whitelock, BB, Scott and they were some of the worst players of the game
Where was Marshall’s leadership when he allowed himself to get assaulted off the pitch trying to milk penalties and lost another World Cup game. If he spent less time being a shock jock, mouthy git he might have been more successful in winning tournaments.
Justin Marshall is a goose commentator- we are targeted from the outset from officialdom like we have a larger magnifying set of eyes on every single play and believe me if they can spot anything that remotely conceivable look like an infringement or error they go straight to TMO I thought World Rugby already laid restrictions on TMO involvement the only referee that ever had the balls of he’s own conviction was Nigel Owens and southern hemisphere refs this World Cup is going to be a shit storm - 37 minutes of actual play out of 137 minutes if game time how the F#%*k is that entertaining just say it Marshall the adjudication is an an abomination and needs a rocket up where the sun don’t shine - there ya go I said it “and ya can take that to the bank” remembered that line from a movie ha ha ha
It's been an unfortunate trait of AB teams for many years that they appear unable to react to winning opposition strategy by changing their own game plan on the hoof. It seems that they train to play a certain way and then that's it, there simply isn't a plan b.
I’m not sure about ‘many years’ but I reckon you could see it since around 2019, in the RWC against England. It’s a leadership thing. Prior to that our leadership would rark up the troops and try something else. They do seem to be missing the adaptability that they used to have. It’s very frustrating to watch.
Well we got rugby league from the wingers who wanted to have less set pieces so maybe we should have set piece Union with no backline ?
A bad day at the office. Get over it.
But the problem here that is this has been happening every season since foster has been in charge. When we do start to relax and think positive then another stinker like this happens, its not a bad day its a recurring theme .Just hope he does a Beaver and "the plan" works.
Exactly, who cares. Had circumstances been reversed and NZ destroyed 14 Springboks everyone would be dismissing the result as irrelevant
Marshy is right, they were played off the park in every facet. Plus the 7-1 split probably got inside their heads. It's definitely worrying for kiwi fans