Northern | US

Law quirk may save Wallabies gun after hip drop tackle sidelines Leroy Carter

Leroy Carter (C) of New Zealand reaches out the score a try during the rugby union Bledisloe Cup match between New Zealand and Australia at Eden Park in Auckland on October 10, 2026. (Photo by Michael Bradley / AFP via Getty Images)
Comments
34 Comments

Rob Valetini may be fortunate World Rugby’s new hip-drop penalty is yet to be validated after the Wallabies backrower’s late tackle left All Blacks winger Leroy Carter with a potentially serious ankle injury.

ADVERTISEMENT

The All Blacks retained the Bledisloe Cup with a 50-19 win at Eden Park, their 12th-straight Test defeat of the Wallabies extending their unbeaten streak at the venue to 54.

Valetini’s desperate effort on Carter to stop a try in the 67th minute forced the winger off the park.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

Coming from behind, Valetini’s weight appeared to fall on Carter’s legs as he fell to the ground.

“It didn’t look good. Sort of like a hip-drop type tackle, landed on the back of his ankle,” New Zealand coach Dave Rennie said.

World Rugby, after years of serious injuries in similar tackles, followed the NRL and NFL and moved earlier in the week to add specific mention of the hip-drop in the global game’s rule book.

Currently there is nothing in the laws to penalise the action but, as of November 1, it will result in at least a penalty kick and potential suspension.

“I’ll leave that for the officials,” Rennie said when asked if the tackle should be punished.

“I’m sure it’s not intentional, but that’s the way the game’s going.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Captain Codie Taylor said the All Blacks, coming off three-straight losses to South Africa, were spurred on by a Tana Umaga “spray” earlier in the week.

Umaga, now an assistant coach, had been in sides that have won and retained the Bledisloe in the late 1990s early 2000s.

“Appropriate fear,” Taylor said of how it fired up the side.

“Which is what you need when you’re playing for the Bled at Eden Park.”

Wallabies centre Len Ikitau failed his head injury assessment and is set to miss the Sydney rematch next Saturday, while All Blacks lock Scott Barrett was also concussed but Rennie was hopeful he would pass protocols to feature.

ADVERTISEMENT

1 YEAR TO GO - RWC27

1 YEAR TO GO 

The countdown is on until the biggest Men’s Rugby World Cup ever kicks off in Australia. Go All Out and secure your seats with tickets now available! 

BUY TICKETS NOW

HSBC SVNS returns to Cape Town this December!

Don't miss your chance to see the world’s best rugby teams take centre stage 5-6 December in Cape Town.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

34 Comments
B
B 35 days ago

I thought world rugby was all about lower tackle height? Contact starts around the hip and it’s just two players each trying to do a different thing


If Valetini is passive, or if he doesn’t even make the tackle, he gets dropped for the rest of the season. Nothing in it and he had every right to tackle

B
Bazzallina 35 days ago

Being a NRL fan this is a classic hip drop tackle was only a matter of time before they addressed this probably should have earlier, no malice but causes lotsa injuries lucky with union doesn’t happen often

M
Mzilikazi 35 days ago

“Coming from behind, Valetini’s weight appeared to fall on Carter’s legs as he fell to the ground.”


Have you not looked at the tackle ? “Appeared” What is that supposed to mean ?


There is absolutly no question in my mind that Valetini made a perfectly clean tackle with no malice, no intention to hurt Carter. He had every right to attempt to pull Carter round and prevent the try.


“It didn’t look good. Sort of like a hip-drop type tackle, landed on the back of his ankle,” New Zealand coach Dave Rennie said. Rubbish, Dave Rennie. That is on the verge of being a malicious comment. This from the man who campaigned to get Lachie Swinton off a suspension for a shoulder to head hit on Lachlan Boshier in SR a few years ago…and succeeded.

B
B 35 days ago

I’d forgotten about the Swinton episode. True that

M
MikeM 35 days ago

This is not a hip drop tackle. Look at the tackle, he is trying to pull him back to stop him scoring…nothing wrong with it, and I am a Kiwi. At no stage did his full weight drop onto the legs of Carter, so it is NOT a hip drop tackle.


Why do rugby keep following the NRL by saying we are going to outlaw the hip drop tackle…just say outlaw dangerous tackles.

P
PM 35 days ago

RV has no history as a dirty player but I would pretty dirty about the this if I were a Kiwi. JAS deciding twice not to bother using his arms in the last 10 minutes when his team's already toast left me embarrassed to be a Wallabies fan and colours the Valetini tackle worse.

S
Short Arm 36 days ago

Does there has to be some onus on the tackled player to submit to the tackle in order to not get hurt?

Risk & reward here. His reward was a try, but by continuing to struggle to get to the line he is risking this type of injury. What was RV supposed to do, let go? Can't win.

J
JW 36 days ago

Crazy that the delay is specifically to allow tackles like this to continue.

M
Mzilikazi 35 days ago

Tackles like this, JW. What was wrong with it ? It was a perfectly legal tackle under the laws of the game, and I would hope will be after the new protocol is in place. Is there actually going to be a change in the laws ? I think it is worth repeating what Short Arm says above: “Risk & reward here. His reward was a try, but by continuing to struggle to get to the line he is risking this type of injury. What was RV supposed to do, let go? Can't win.”

A
Adi03 36 days ago

Look at the physical reality: Valetini's legs were under Carter, not above him. Valetini didn't unweight himself to drop dead weight vertically from mid-air. To stop Carter's forward momentum on the try line, Valetini wrapped him and used the strongest part of his body—his own legs—as a sliding horizontal pivot on the turf to anchor his upper body and pull Carter away from the line.

Furthermore, Valetini chased and wrapped Carter from his right side. Biomechanically, when you pull a running player from the right while tracking backwards, your hips have no choice but to naturally rotate to the right. It is basic anatomy, not a malicious twist.

The injury itself was a tragic byproduct of competing forces, not a dirty tackle. Carter’s boots were studded firmly into the turf as he lowered his center of gravity to drive for the line and roll sideways. Because his feet were completely anchored to the ground, his ankles bore the full brunt of the rotational torque. If Carter had even one foot off the ground or in mid-stride, his leg would have freely rotated with the tackle, and he likely walks away unhurt. This wasn't a vertical body-weight drop; it was a high-velocity, horizontal collision where an anchored player met a sliding defender…

And Im not even a Wallabies supporter.

B
BH 35 days ago

Good gracious that is a long spiel. Valetini grabbed Carter around the hips, dropped his body weight to stop momentum, and in doing so he trapped Carter’s ankle between his body and the ground. There isn’t anything to debate here - it’s the very definition a hip-drop tackle. And he’s lucky that he’s done it outside of the ban window set by World Rugby.


It wasn’t a “dirty” tackle by any means. Unlike Sua'ali'i’s blatant shoulder charge on Jordie, which should’ve been a yellow card.

T
TokoRFC 36 days ago

I didn’t see anything in it live and after watching it again I don’t think Valetini was doing anything other than trying to stop a try.


I don’t know if Rennie is insinuating anything here or just comparing but it looks just like an unfortunate rugby incident to me

c
cnw 36 days ago

I don’t think people are saying it was a “dirty tackle” but the biomechanics of this type of engagement, where the lower body of the tackler lands on a leg, even if momentarily, are very dangerous.

R
Rugby3 36 days ago

Yeah but note Rennie trying to play dirty by making obviously false accusations.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close