Northern | US

Nations Championship deliver verdict on Sam Prendergast citing


DUBLIN, IRELAND - NOVEMBER 14: Sam Prendergast of Ireland during the Nations Championship 2026 match between Ireland and Fiji at Aviva Stadium on November 14, 2026 in Dublin, Ireland. (Photo by Ramsey Cardy - Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images)
Comments
127 Comments

Sam Prendergast’s citing for an alleged act of foul play during Ireland’s 43-15 win against Fiji on Saturday has been thrown out.

ADVERTISEMENT

The fly-half became the first player to be cited under World Rugby’s new regulations for what was alleged to be a hip-drop tackle on Peceli Yato during the first half of the Dublin clash.

Fiji’s captain was injured in the incident and went off shortly after scoring a try. Prendergast was not penalised at the time but was later cited.

VIDEO

However, the 23-year-old has avoided a ban and is free to play in the remainder of the Nations Championship after the case was dismissed by an independent disciplinary committee comprising Mike Hamlin (Chair) – England, Wayne Erickson – Australia and Becky Essex – England.

A statement from the Nations Championship organisers said: “Having heard detailed evidence from Sam Prendergast and submissions made by Derek Hegarty and Andy Farrell, the Committee unanimously determined that the player had, to the required standard, proved that the citing should be dismissed.”

Detailed findings of facts and reasons for the Committee’s decision will be set out in its written judgment.

Prendergast’s tackle on Yato prompted an outburst on Monday from South Africa head coach Rassie Erasmus, in which he predicted the player would get off on “a technicality.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Erasmus said: “In the Northern Hemisphere, players probably get cited two or three games before being available for selection again.

“But from my experience here with the cases of Lood de Jager, Jan-Hendrik Wessels and Franco Mostert… it just never seems to go our way.”

Nations Championship

Watch Hemispheres collide as North faces South in the Nations Championship. Live matches, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV here

(*USA only)

HSBC SVNS returns to Cape Town this December!

Don't miss your chance to see the world’s best rugby teams take centre stage 5-6 December in Cape Town.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

127 Comments
R
RugCs 8 hours ago

You really talk complete and utter rubbish even after I have humiliated you.

E
Eric Elwood 12 hours ago

Yes. This is substantiated by the investigation by the Telegraph. And SA cant stand over their RWC wins.

M
Mzilikazi 21 hours ago

Looking at the tackle several times over, I don’t think there was ever any way that the charge of a body drop tackle was going to stand up. Sam Prendergast made a legal contact first, and as I see it he was being blasted out of the way by the powerful Fijian….he basically fell off the tackle. His knee touched the ground, but he had no strong grasp of his opponent, there was certainly no twisting or dropping off his body onto the legs of the try scorer.


In short the citing should never have been brought forward at all. Wasted a lot of peoples valuable time.

B
B 21 hours ago

I agree. It was unremarkable in real time although the injury is unfortunate


Looking at the footage now, he starts the tackle around the hips and is getting dragged. At no point does he - or Porter supporting to form the ruck - land on the limbs. And the new rule is explicitly about completing the tackle by landing there. If anything, the initial tackle height is what WR are trying to promote


I assume they didn't want to railroad the match commissioner who referred it, but there was never a case to answer


Presumably the lawyer got a few coins for attending but it was a waste of time

R
Rodney Ford 22 hours ago

🤣🤣🤣


What a surprise! Who could’ve seen it coming?!

P
Passit2me 1 day ago

Well, I’ll be very interested to find out the reason for Sam getting off.

That was a classic hip drop tackle in my view.


His body swung around with his hips landing on the Fijians ankle, and the Fijian wet off injured a few minutes later.

R
RugCs 1 day ago

Don’t try to squirm out of it. This is what YOU said, and I quote


The SA national men’s team had no adequate doping regime for either the 2019 or 2023.


Testing for senior men in SA is 6x less than for other Tier1 nation

E
Eric Elwood 1 day ago

This is not an opinion piece. The Telegraph is open to defamation law and Ofcom supervision while making these claims. As SA rugby etc. has not sued for defamation we must assume the statements are true.

According to World Anti-Doping Agency figures, tests carried out by the South African Institute for Drug-Free Sport (SAIDS) dropped from 785 in 2015 to just 127 in 2024. During that same span, the UK equivalent body boosted its testing numbers.

For a nation that has produced 89 doping violations — around 20 per cent of the global total — despite its relatively small footprint in the sport, the decline in controls raises uncomfortable questions.

R
RugCs 1 day ago

You used the fake news outlets data then deliberately obscured what they were saying to suite your own false narrative - in other words lying. This is what the news outlet said. It did not say the lies you speak about 6 times less than other Tier 1 nations. Now go away.


A March 2026 Telegraph investigation (using WADA figures) did show that domestic testing by SAIDS on rugby players in South Africa fell sharply to a sixfold drop.

E
Eric Elwood 1 day ago

The testing allegations are by the Daily Telegraph who are subject to Ofcom rules and defamation law. Instead addressing the allegations you accuse me of lying like the numpty baby you are. Numpty.

R
RugCs 1 day ago

That a total lie. SAIDS has reduced its testing for children - there is no need to test all 400,000 kids plying the game. Why should they test 10x more than other nations?


The fact is that all professional players are tested as per World Rugby and WADA regulations. Your lies are noted.

E
Eric Elwood 1 day ago

Testing for senior men in SA is 6x less than for other Tier1 nations making it easy to run a doping supported career. Even with the non testing, two players were caught from the 2019 squad showing the epidemic. SA cannot stand over their RWC wins.

R
RugCs 1 day ago

Talk complete and utter rubbish. Players are tested for drugs by SAIDS under WADA and World Rugby rules, covering in- and out-of-competition testing from schoolboy to Springbok level, with elite players also subject to World Rugby’s independent programme. You ugly slander is noted.

H
Henrik 1 day ago

This judgement I can understand, certainly should have been a yellow card, but nothing more …..

from a Boks perspective, I hope he will be playing and receiving his end of some juicy (legal) tackles ….

u
unknown 1 day ago

Disraceful double standards, the lad can't even support his own head size with that tiny frame and then try to take down a rhino leopard style, and still fails miserably. But being from the emerald Isle, laws don't apply to them at all. Feel embarrassed to be Irish

u
unknown 1 day ago

Ignoring all the Ireland vs SA arguments on here. World Rugby needs to do more to deter dangerous tackle and clear out techniques. Hip drop tackles and crocodile roll clear outs can cause serious and potentially career ending injuries. I think World Rugby should being doing more to weed these out of the game, similar to the high tackles and head shots

E
EvilMockingJay 1 day ago

Shame ! Shame ! Shame !

(Well i’m not surprised at all)

E
Eric Elwood 1 day ago

I had no issue with an example ban for Prendergast but it was highly unlikely given Bell’s yellow was not upgraded against England.

The only significance of Erasmus comments was the likelihood it would prejudice the case against Prendergast. That appears not to have come up.

E
Eric Elwood 1 day ago

Erasmus and his lunatic online Saffa supporters really exposing himself for the tinfoil hat numpties they are.

P
Paul Ennis 1 day ago

I must say, I feel guilty. It is like watching Chris Redfield fighting off a hoard of zombies and I dare not jump in to help for fear that I will get infected. They know not what they are… but take solace in the knowledge that the rest of the world is watching you and desperately hoping that you survive the onslaught! WESKER!

R
RL 1 day ago

Jealousy makes you nasty! Only reason you feel that way is because your team always receive preferential treatment!

C
Cliff224 1 day ago

I haven’t seen the Pendegrast tackle. However, in ENG v AUS, Angus Bell made a hip drop tackle, and was punished with a yellow card. So if Pendegrast’s challenge was similar, then a red card would be inconsistent punishment.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close