Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

New Zealand needs a reliable No.10 like Harry Plummer

Harry Plummer looks on during a New Zealand All Blacks training session at NZCIS on August 06, 2024 in Wellington, New Zealand. (Photo by Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)

There was no necessity for the All Blacks to draft Harry Plummer into their squad. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Stephen Perofeta might have a niggle, but that’s of no consequence. 

Perofeta is a peripheral part of this squad to begin with, made even more so by the rejuvenation of Beauden Barrett and subsequent selections of Will Jordan and Ruben Love. 

Perofeta’s never going to be trusted at first five-eighth, but Plummer might be. 

If I was heartened by the return of Jordan and, particularly, David Havili to the squad last week, I’m even more enthused by Plummer’s inclusion. 

New Zealand needs a reliable No.10. Someone able to follow a gameplan, give others the opportunity to do the brilliant things and not commit errors that put everyone under pressure. 

Damian McKenzie might yet become that player. Barrett too, for that matter. 

ADVERTISEMENT

But, like the selection of Havili, the summoning of Plummer suggests the All Blacks coaches have taken stock. 

They’ve seen what they have, assessed what they lack and sought to make selections that add to the sum of the parts. 

Plummer is a fine footballer. He’s not brilliant, probably not destined to be an all-time great, but he is a guy who can do a job for you. 

That’s what I mean about reliability. 

ADVERTISEMENT

To my eye, if you set Plummer a simple task, you can depend on him to perform it. 

Controlling the controllables, in other words. 

Without Richie Mo’unga, there’s an element of hope about who the All Blacks are sending onto the park at first five-eighth.  

There are few more brilliant players around than McKenzie. 

I love watching him play for the Chiefs. 

But the stakes are low and the opposition often scant. 

McKenzie can afford to make errors or take wrong options at that level, because he has the time, space and absence of pressure to rectify them. 

If we were to liken McKenzie to an NFL quarterback, you’d probably describe him as a scrambler. A guy who calls a play, doesn’t like what he sees from the defence and then plays off the cuff. 

That can be immensely effective and, in a rugby sense, we do see plenty of tries that come from broken play. 

I’ll persist with the NFL comparisons for a minute, in light of comments All Blacks attack coach Leon MacDonald made after the second test against England. 

MacDonald suggested plays had been rehearsed, then called on the field, which broke down. Players forgot or misheard calls and everything became untidy. 

We seem to be getting into an era where guys play less of what they see and more of what’s been prescribed. 

That’s the appeal of Plummer, from a coaching point of view. If a play’s called, I suspect you can rely on him to run it as it was designed. 

I don’t know how effective that strategy is, but I imagine it gives coaches a degree of comfort. 

So I’m encouraged that the All Blacks are having a look at Plummer. How much he plays – if ever – remains to be seen. 

But when I look at this squad, I feel he offers more to it than Perofeta can, who’s always struck me as a poorer version of McKenzie. 

The only thing that seems rigid about this new coaching group is the way they want to play. The fact they’re broadminded enough to consider which personnel are best equipped to execute that gameplan suggests better times could be ahead for these All Blacks. 

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

12 Comments
G
GL 80 days ago

😂😂😂 Harry!!

B
B.J. Spratt 99 days ago

Payout Mounga's contract. Problem solved. I am sure the "slippery" NZRFU, could make that happen.


They have managed to effect a lot harder "Dodgy deals" than that in the past.

T
Tim 64 days ago

Don't hold back on the details. Love to know more about these "dodgy deals".

S
SadersMan 105 days ago

Plummer needs to be more than a predictable Mr Reliable. And under Razor, he'll be challenged to be more, & will become so. Should he actually get selected proper (which I think he's not as yet).

M
MattJH 105 days ago

‘We seem to be getting into an era where guys play what they are prescribed rather than what’s in front of them’.

No we aren’t.

People have no patience and very short memories.

It takes time to imbed new systems with a new group.

Mo’unga didn’t exactly light up test rugby the moment he stepped on the field. Some of that was arguably the coaching but it still took him time.

It will take Dmac time, too.

But what if we lose a couple of 10s to injury? Wouldn’t we prefer someone to come in who has already been in the group, seen how things run on test week as opposed to someone brought in green and expected to step up straight away?

That’s why Plummer is there, it’s a chance to grow depth.

Havilli I don’t see the attraction in. Doesn’t make gain line, gets smashed in contact, and we have others with that skill set.

As they get more games under the belt, we will see the personal change gradually and combinations develop.

I do love how League teams just throw the latest young gun into the furnace and see how he copes, but that’s not the approach the ABs believe will work for them.

D
DS 106 days ago

NZ are conservative selectors and supporters. The lack of trust in any player that shows invention or flair is well documented. Fox over Botica; Mertz over Carlos; now Plummer over DMac; it's almost inevitable that the style of play displayed by the Blues will attract comment. Back to the one out or 10 man rugby seems risk free until they get out-played by a team that encourages 15 man rugby. Can only hope Robertson doesn't fall for the trap here? There are enough boring rugby teams without the ABs joining them!

F
Forward pass 105 days ago

Plummer isnt replacing DM any time soon. He wont even come close next season with Jacomb coming thru.

F
Forward pass 106 days ago

Im glad I was reading this on the loo. What a load of .....

T
Toaster 106 days ago

This guy Bidwell

All his articles are rubbish


Plummer has gone well this year but let’s let him deal with the pressures or test rugby and rush defences

B
BH 106 days ago

Hamish Bidwell with another clickbait, trashy article. Plummer is a Super Rugby/NPC-level player at best.

L
LS 106 days ago

Hey Hamish,

Not a lot of thought on this one.

Whos your next choice, Beaver?

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

LONG READ
LONG READ Why England's defence of the realm has crumbled without Felix Jones Why England's defence of the realm has crumbled without Felix Jones
Search