Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

NZR cannot afford to sit idle on appointing the next All Blacks coach

All Blacks head coach Ian Foster walks through the crowd towards the field after The Rugby Championship match between the New Zealand All Blacks and Argentina Pumas at Orangetheory Stadium on August 27, 2022 in Christchurch, New Zealand. (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

Succession didn’t get us anywhere.

Signposting that Ian Foster would ascend to Steve Hansen’s throne left us without options.

Sure, New Zealand Rugby (NZR) managed to get Scott Robertson to participate in a sham appointment process – which must make him blush on a daily basis – but we still finished with the anticipated outcome.

ADVERTISEMENT

And now folk want us to do the same? To have NZR sit idle, to the point where we get Foster again after the Rugby World Cup or have an assistant succeed him?

No, thanks. The time for genuine coaching renewal is already overdue.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

Look, if there’s a shambolic and illogical way to do something, then NZR will find it. We know that already.

But for people to suggest that the governing body shouldn’t sound out or identify – even name – coaches for 2024 and beyond defies belief.

So what if this process undermines Foster. The bloke has had more than a fair go.

I read and hear that if NZR are looking at alternatives now, then they may as well go the whole hog and sack him.

It would be another expensive decision, leaving another contract to be paid out, but is that really such a bad outcome? Or must we protect Foster and his brand at all costs?

ADVERTISEMENT

What are we afraid of? The man is a relic of a regime that came to power in 2004 and yet we still think that talk of its end is premature?

If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. But it is broke. It’s been broke for a while now.

The All Blacks have to be bigger than one man and one school of thought and it’s not disrespectful to say so.

We’re a small country. The coaching tree isn’t a big one and many of our better practitioners trace their origins to Wayne Smith, for instance.

Clean slates will be hard to find, but that’s no reason not to try.

ADVERTISEMENT

It would be negligent of NZR not to be proactive this time. To assume that coaching candidates will flock to them.

That clearly didn’t work last time – even if it’s generous to suggest that was ever NZR’s intention – leaving us with a pale imitation of Hansen as head coach.

People say that Hansen had run his race by 2019. That he’d lost his touch, failed to rebuild the squad and left Foster to inherit an absolute mess.

We’ve heard about Covid this and fatigue that, to continually mitigate the often miserable results since 2020. We’ve tried a sabbatical here, a new assistant there, but never properly addressed the issue of the man at the helm.

And now – in deference to that man – we’re going to criticise NZR for belatedly investigating alternatives?

You’ll have to forgive me for not joining that chorus.

We kicked NZR from pillar to post for failing to properly plan for succession last time, so it would be absurd to condemn them for having a decent look now.

Ian Foster has tried his best and should ideally be afforded a dignified finish, but the needs of the team and its loyal fanbase have to come first.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

2 Comments
b
by George! 654 days ago

More appropriate selection of "reaction emojis" please!

M
Mark 654 days ago

I agree with practically all of this. No doubt he was probably a useful assistant, although when Hansen appointed him I like most was puzzled. There were personnel with more glowing resumes than his. Sadly he will be remembered for all the wrong reasons and hopefully this kind of appointment will never happen again. As Foster himself likes to repeatedly say there will be plenty of "learnings".

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

H
Hellhound 37 minutes ago
France put World Cup pain behind them with unbeaten run in November

France is starting to look like they are finally over their WC headache, although they were lucky that NZ had a very bad game. The Argies as usual is one game good, the next bad. If they can sort that out and be more consistent, they could become contenders for the WC.


NZ, Argentina (if they are more consistent), and now the Wallabies too is in an upward curve (can they be consistent?), as well as Fiji(as inconsistent as Argentina) looks like possible contenders. The Boks will be as usual a huge threat to defend their title. Things are looking up for the South, so the North should rightfully beware of the Southern Hemisphere threat.


With the French looking dangerous, the English with their close runs (mostly a mindset problem) and the Scottish seems to be the NH main contenders. The Irish is good, but not excellent anymore. They are more overbearing and with their glory days mostly gone with old players hanging on by a thread, by 2027 if they don't start adding in the younger players, they won't make it past yet another WC Quarter final. The problem is that their youngsters, while good is nothing special.


That is just 8 teams without the Irish that can become real WC contenders. Lots of hickups to be sorted still for these teams, excluding the Boks to become a threat. Make no mistake, the top Tier is much closer than people realise and the 2027 WC will be a really great WC, possibly the best contended WC ever.

1 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING David Campese names his Springbok world player of the year winner David Campese names his Springbok world player of the year winner
Search