Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'Quite despicable' - World Rugby publish scathing text from Spain's eligibility scandal

Gavin Van den Berg of Alcobendas gestures during the spanish league (Photo by Oscar J. Barroso / Europa Press Sports via Getty Images)

World Rugby have taken the decision to issue the full written judgment in the case of Spain’s recent points reduction that has led to them being turfed out of the Rugby World Cup for a second time in four years.

ADVERTISEMENT

The scathing document is heavily critical of the Spanish rugby union (FER) and their apparently lax attitude to eligibility.

In April World Rugby imposed a 10-point deduction and a fixed fine of £25,000 on Spain after they were found guilty of fielding an ineligible player in two Rugby World Cup 2023 qualifying matches.

Video Spacer

Scaling The French Rugby Pyramid | Zack Henry | Le French Rugby Podcast | EP 27

We’re joined by an Englishman in the Pyrenees as Pau fly half Zack Henry talks us through his journey from Rouen in Federale 1 up through PRO D2 and to the Top 14 via a stint at Leicester in the Premiership. We hear how playing under Steve Borthwick at Tigers wasn’t the right fit, what Gabin Villiere was like back in his days as a back-up scrum half in the French third tier, how dangerous Chouffe socials can be and what happens when you injure your hamstring and are sent to a faith healer rather than a physio! Plus, Johnnie makes a big prediction about who will miss out on the Top 14 play-offs, we discuss Spain being stripped of their place at the World Cup in France next year and we pick our MEATER Moment of the Week…
Use the code FRENCHPOD20 at checkout for 20% off any full price item at Meater.com

Video Spacer

Scaling The French Rugby Pyramid | Zack Henry | Le French Rugby Podcast | EP 27

We’re joined by an Englishman in the Pyrenees as Pau fly half Zack Henry talks us through his journey from Rouen in Federale 1 up through PRO D2 and to the Top 14 via a stint at Leicester in the Premiership. We hear how playing under Steve Borthwick at Tigers wasn’t the right fit, what Gabin Villiere was like back in his days as a back-up scrum half in the French third tier, how dangerous Chouffe socials can be and what happens when you injure your hamstring and are sent to a faith healer rather than a physio! Plus, Johnnie makes a big prediction about who will miss out on the Top 14 play-offs, we discuss Spain being stripped of their place at the World Cup in France next year and we pick our MEATER Moment of the Week…
Use the code FRENCHPOD20 at checkout for 20% off any full price item at Meater.com

Subject to appeal, the points deduction applied to the Rugby World Cup 2023 qualification table means that Romania will qualify as Europe 2 into Pool B replacing Spain, and Portugal will replace Romania in the Final Qualification Tournament in November 2022.

World Rugby found that South African prop Gavin van den Berg had not been a “resident” of Spain for a 36-month period before he played for Spain on 18 December, 2021 and 5 February, 2022.

The document shows that Spain claimed that van den Berg was only absent from Spain for more than two consecutive months because of “exceptional circumstances”. In fact, it found that he was absent from Spain for a total period of 127 days in the first year of that 36-month criteria period, time which didn’t meet the  “exceptional circumstances”  clause under Regulation 8, and even included travel around Europe.

It also found that “representatives from the player’s club had apparently, without either Spain’s or the player’s knowledge, tampered with travel stamps in the player’s passport to make it seem that the player had not been out of Spain for more than two months (62 days) in that first year, to facilitate the player’s reclassification as a domestic player to benefit the club. However, notwithstanding the amended stamps, the player had been out of Spain for longer than the permitted period.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The tampering with the passport was described as ‘quite despicable’, although it was pointed out that neither the player nor the union were aware of the skullduggery.

“The machinations then revealed over the apparent tampering with, and (ab)use of, the copy of the Player’s passport are quite despicable and reflect very badly on those that may have played a part in such events. However, these events are not directly relevant here. A proper explanation, in evidence, from the responsible club officials might have been helpful, but was not essential. All three allegedly complicit club officials declined to give evidence.”

The report points out that  “the passport tampering is irrelevant, except that it does point up the lack of any FER inquiry of the Player.”

The fact that player had posted on social media while traveling around Europe during his residency – writing ‘Saffa touring Europe’ – was also brought forward as evidence of how the residency rules were being absent-mindedly flouted.

ADVERTISEMENT

The FER were heavily criticised for their shoddy administration around the breach, not least given they had been sanctioned and kicked out the last World Cup over a similar incident.

“The Committee further expressed concerns that the Union did not appear to have an appropriate process in place to review the movements of players that were relying on residence for eligibility.

“The Committee noted that the Union had been sanctioned in the past for selection of non-eligible players (in what is referred to as the RWCQ 2019 Case) and in those circumstances expected the Union to have stringent processes in place to ensure that the circumstances of each player had been carefully considered prior to being selected.

“The Committee further noted its dissatisfaction with the Union not seeking confirmation of the Player’s eligibility in advance of selecting the Player to represent the Union.”

The player was noted as giving a candid testimony in the case and the panel recommended he faced no individual sanction.

“The Player’s state of mind and of knowledge of R 8 [Regulation 8] – or lack of knowledge – is found throughout his evidence… there was no conversation with, let alone education of, the Player as to R 8 and eligibility. Which were amongst the very matters stressed in the Bell matter only 18 months or so previous.”

Spain has a right of appeal within 14 days of the full written decision and World Rugby said “no further comment will be made until the completion of the process.”

 

 

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

H
Head high tackle 8 minutes ago
How can Scott Robertson revive the All Blacks’ playmaking ‘triple threat’?

Nick I think a lot of teams 10,12 and 13 combo's suffer considerably when compared to the Carter, Nonu, Smith era. I cant think of any other world combo that comes close to that combo. 3 once in a generation players all doing their thing collectively. Carter is possibably the best ever player and Nonu and Smith are world class in any generation. Im old enough to remember the runner/playmaker 12s of yesteryear and rugby was much simpler then. The defensive systems of today are so studied and practiced that the space is no longer there in the midfield.

Under Foster the backs never quite looked as fluid as the Carter, Nonu, Smith trio and thats mainly due to Mounga, Jordie B and Reiko just not being close in standard to the other 3. Your recent article around the ABs 70%, shows clearly that Mounga is no Carter and that the 12 and 13 players who have replaced Nonu and Smith just arnt Nonu and Smith.

There is hope for Razor to develop that area next year and beyond but Razor has been more conservative at centre than any other area. So far Razor has avoided change but I think it will come. Both current centres are makeshift centres who grabbed the positions due to injury and have kept them.

Spot on around WJ and his skillset tho. He certainly has a few skill deficiencies compared to many 15s and I would be very happy for him to stay at 14, but also happy if he develops his kicking and playmaking from 15 as he brings something no one else does. He is very good at passing or offloading for his support tho.

JB is still playing 15 basically. We need someone to play 12. Not just play AT 12.

14 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ 'You don’t want to be the one shouting the loudest' - Andrew Porter plotting All Blacks payback 'You don’t want to be the one shouting the loudest' - Andrew Porter plotting All Blacks payback
Search