Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Racing owner gets personal in bizzare public criticism of Siya Kolisi

Racing92's South African flanker Siya Kolisi reacts after the European Rugby Champions Cup pool 2 match between Bath and Racing 92 at The Rec in Bath, south-west England on January 14, 2024. Bath won the match 29 - 25. (Photo by Adrian DENNIS / AFP) (Photo by ADRIAN DENNIS/AFP via Getty Images)

Racing 92 owner Jacky Lorenzetti has accused Siya Kolisi of being “transparent” in their Top 14 semi-final defeat to Bordeaux-Begles at the weekend amid a scathing assessment of the South Africa captain’s first season in Paris.

ADVERTISEMENT

The double World Cup-winning skipper arrived at La Defense Arena last year after lifting the Webb Ellis Cup, and made a “remarkable” start to life in sky blue and white according to Lorenzetti.

However, the Racing chief believes the hand injury the Springbok sustained in March, and subsequent surgery, was something that he did not recover from. Though the 33-year-old did make a return to action a month later, Lorenzetti feels he was unable to recapture the form he had previously shown.

Video Spacer

Walk the Talk with Eddie Jones – Trailer | RPTV

Eddie Jones reflects on his career, rugby’s growth in Japan, coaching England and Australia, South African rugby and much more. Full episode coming Tuesday 18 June on RPTV

Coming soon

Video Spacer

Walk the Talk with Eddie Jones – Trailer | RPTV

Eddie Jones reflects on his career, rugby’s growth in Japan, coaching England and Australia, South African rugby and much more. Full episode coming Tuesday 18 June on RPTV

Coming soon

Speaking to French outlet Midi Olympique shortly after his side’s season came to a close, Lorenzetti pulled no punches in his assessment of Kolisi’s season, comparing him to his predecessor Wenceslas Lauret, and even accusing the Springbok of being overweight.

He does, however, have faith that Kolisi will come good next season, with the club set to be further bolstered by the arrival of former England captain Owen Farrell.

Fixture
Top 14
Bordeaux
31 - 17
Full-time
Racing 92
All Stats and Data

“He had a remarkable start to the season, where he was a unifier off the field,” he said in the interview.

“The break was harmful to him. He gained weight, lost form and yesterday he was transparent. […] We miss it.

ADVERTISEMENT

“In the back row, we used to have an ultra-present warrior, a warrior called Wenceslas Lauret. For the moment, Siya does not let us forget him.

“But we think that next year, that will change.”

The 83-cap Springbok was not the only Racing player in the firing line as Lorenzetti picked apart another trophy-less season for the Parisians. Another new recruit, Fiji’s Josua Tuisova, was also lambasted, and accused of not making the impact they expected after arriving from Lyon.

“He didn’t bring anything, we must be clear,” he said. “It was not the impact player we expected.”

In the Fijian’s defence, he only made his debut in May after a six-month lay-off due to a knee injury sustained during the World Cup, so he can be excused for struggling to instantly return to his destructive best.

ADVERTISEMENT

Related

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

27 Comments
D
Dlala 181 days ago

He’s not really a very good player, anyhow. Been a passenger in the Springboks squad for too long.

J
Jon 181 days ago

If anyone knows the French, you know they speak a different language.

C
Chris 181 days ago

😄 Siya and Eben are on paid holidays between Bok camps. I think they care somewhat, but really they are just earning a living until Bok camp starts.

B
Bull Shark 181 days ago

I didn’t read anything scathing in that assessment. Not untrue. Just unnecessary.

Someone should advise French owners that managing the performance of key personnel by bleating to the media about them is obnoxious.

M
MattJH 181 days ago

I imagine the $$$ he is earning would buy a whole lot of “yeah whatever mate”.

S
Sinead 182 days ago

I think any coach or owner singling out a player like that for public critism is just bang out of order. Stuff that has to be said to a player should be said one to one in private. I feel sorry for those players.

F
Flankly 182 days ago

Spelling bizarre as “bizzare” in your headline is bizarre.

Nice clickbait comments from the Mr Lorenzetti, the famously successful winner of rugby prizes.

If only Mr Kolisi had some medals to prove his credentials. That would make Mr Lorenzetti look a little stupid.

P
Peter 182 days ago

Usual comment by a Frenchman. Visit North Paris and the slums that the French consign black foreigners to and you will appreciate what I’m writing.

D
Dan 183 days ago

Just another overrated SH player who.can’t hack superior NH comps. A tale as old as time..

p
pabst 183 days ago

Here we go, I called this last year, French people are impossible, narcissistic and arrogant. They are shameful.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

f
fl 18 minutes ago
‘The problem with this year’s Champions Cup? Too many English clubs’

"Yes I was the one who suggested to use a UEFA style point. And I guessed, that based on the last 5 years we should start with 6 top14, 6 URC and 4 Prem."

Yes I am aware that you suggested it, but you then went on to say that we should initially start with a balance that clearly wasn't derived from that system. I'm not a mind reader, so how was I to work out that you'd arrived at that balance by dint of completely having failed to remember the history of the competition.


"Again, I was the one suggesting that, but you didn't like the outcome of that."

I have no issues with the outcome of that, I had an issue with a completely random allocation of teams that you plucked out of thin air.

Interestingly its you who now seem to be renouncing the UEFA style points system, because you don't like the outcome of reducing URC representation.


"4 teams for Top14, URC and Prem, 3 teams for other leagues and the last winner, what do you think?"

What about 4 each + 4 to the best performing teams in last years competition not to have otherwise qualified? Or what about a UEFA style system where places are allocated to leagues on the basis of their performance in previous years' competitions?

There's no point including Black Lion if they're just going to get whitewashed every year, which I think would be a possibility. At most I'd support 1 team from the Rugby Europe Super Cup, or the Russian Championship being included. Maybe the best placed non-Israeli team and the Russian winners could play off every year for the spot? But honestly I think its best if they stay limited to the Challenge Cup for now.

39 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Barrett and Prendergast put Leinster European rivals on notice Barrett and Prendergast put Leinster European rivals on notice
Search