Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

England forwards coach Richard Cockerill laughs off calls to outlaw the maul

By PA
(Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

Richard Cockerill has hit back at calls in New Zealand to outlaw the maul by declaring England will enthusiastically continue to use an important weapon in their arsenal.

ADVERTISEMENT

Former All Blacks coach Wayne Smith, who helped mastermind the 2011 and 2015 World Cup triumphs as well as the Black Ferns’ global success last year, believes it is “legalised obstruction” and would “get rid of it entirely”.

England scored three tries through driving mauls in Saturday’s victory over Italy, prompting head coach Steve Borthwick to remark that “they certainly enjoy a maul at Twickenham, so I was pleased to see a few”.

Video Spacer
Video Spacer

Cockerill insists the disapproval of Smith, a respected figure in the game, is purely a result of Kiwi shortcomings.

“The game is the game, isn’t it? We can all play the same way or we can all play slightly differently,” England’s forwards coach said.

“Generally, the teams that moan about the maul are the teams that aren’t very good at it.

“English rugby is built on set-piece – the good club teams have a good set-piece. National teams have good set-pieces, whoever they are.

“If we have an advantage in the maul, we should take advantage of it. It would be stupid not to.”

ADVERTISEMENT

In addition to the maul being highly-effective in the round two win over Italy, a step forward was taken in the scrum as England look to restore a traditional pillar of their game.

When Eddie Jones was sacked in December, he left behind the worst performing scrum of any tier one nation in 2022. Cockerill is overseeing a rebuilding process that required input from officials.

“We have spent more time on it and we have had a lot of dialogue with the referees, especially Wayne Barnes, Joel Jutge and Phil Davies from World Rugby,” he said.

“Basically we asked ‘what do you think of our scrum, what do we need to work on?’ We have taken lots of inputs from the officials because that has not been as good a relationship as we would have liked.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The perception was that we were a little bit ill-disciplined, a bit reckless. We were ranked 10 out of 10 in tier one post-autumn and that tells its own story.

“You should take that personally because that’s part of our identity as a team. We just had some conversations and then we have gone about fixing it, making sure our stability is good and doing lots of reps on the training field.

“The boys have worked hard and we have got a good pack of forwards. It’s just keeping them honest and working them harder than we probably did previously.

“We will get a lot better. Stats-wise we are pretty good at this point but there is still a fair bit we can tidy up.”

Courtney Lawes will resume full training for the first time on Thursday having recovered from a calf injury, with England ready to select him for the clash with Wales on Saturday week.

ADVERTISEMENT

O2 Inside Line: All In | Episode 5 | Making Waves

Confidence knocks and finding your people | Flo Williams | Rugby Rising Locker Room

Tackling reasons for drop-out in sport | Zainab Alema | Rugby Rising Locker Room

Krakow | Leg 3 | Day 2 | HSBC Challenger Series | Full Day Replay

Kubota Spears vs Tokyo Sungoliath | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

Jet Lag: The biggest challenge facing international sports? | The Report

Boks Office | Episode 39 | The Investec Champions Cup is back

Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry? | New Zealand & Australia | Sevens Wonders | Episode 5

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

2 Comments
G
Greg 798 days ago

'The game is the game, isn't it'. No Cock, the game has evolved in many different ways if you know your rugby history, but has always been based on one essential rule - that the ball carrier can be tackled. The rolling maul reverses that rule and compounds that nonsense by allowing the ball carrier's team-mates to run obstruction. Smithy's objection to the maul wasn't special pleading for the ABs - look at the stats for the ABs maul and maul defence since Jason Ryan arrived. It's about the spectacle - imagine if the English women had won the RWC final and the enduring memory had been of eight white bottoms wobbling their way forward in unison looking for worms.

P
Poe 799 days ago

Cock. Rugby has been tilted north by the pathetic maul fake rugby.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

W
WI 19 minutes ago
How 'misunderstood' Rassie Erasmus is rolling back the clock

It isn’t just the running rugby, but everything else as well. The Boks have a sense of desperation that sets in when they are matched physically, that cannot at times be offset by their skillset. One of the reasons, as far as i understand it, for Tony Brown’s introduction to the set up was to increase the Boks strike plays along with among many things. Is this not Rassie’s assessment of the Pool loss to Ireland? If you watch that game, so many opportunities, yet an unconverted try and a lone penalty to show for all those scrum penalties, stolen lineouts and 5 m maul attempts?


Fast Forward to Durban, the Boks could not score a single try? Led 24-19 with 65 minutes to go, led 24-22 with 40 seconds to go with a scrum, of all things in Ireland’s 22, yet end up losing the game. At the end of that series they had won 3 out of the 4 halves of rugby, yet drew the series.


Who could forget the infamous quarterfinal loss to the Wallabies in the 2011 WC Quarterfinal? Desperation as the time ticked on, in came the small things and the skillset failed.


The Boks have almost got it all, this one thing, as Eddie Jones said back in 2007, if the Boks get it, they might become unplayable. I think Rassie have realized as much by the failures of previous Bok teams. Boks Vs Robbie Deans, Heyneke Meyer VS All Blacks, 4 Straight Defeat to Wales? All i am saying, is that it isn’t readily apparent to me, that the Boks have it yet, and if they do, maybe it should ascend pass other nations? However, what would the school, domestic rugby philosophies not do to hinder it?


Gone are the extreme ends of the spectrum represented by Heyneke Meyer’s Bash Ball and Alister Coetzee’s flying with the fairies, as neither work for the Boks. It is obvious, that the gold lies in the combination of Mallet and to an extend Rassie. Not sure one coach would be able to change the mindset of a Rugby Nation, and to help me not hear my Bulls Fanatic neighbor shout “ Vok hul op!”

156 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING South African rugby's top heavy house of cards South African rugby's house of cards
Search