1
SA journalist calls for referee to be banned from Test rugby for life
By Ian Cameron
A South African rugby journalist is calling for referee Paul Williams to be banned from officiating a Test match again following the Springboksā loss to Australia in Adelaide on Saturday.
ADVERTISEMENT
James Richardson of the South African threw the proverbial kitchen sink at the New Zealand official, branding him ādiabolicalā, āincompetentā and potentially biased.
The Boksā 25-17 defeat at the hands of Dave Rennieās Wallabies wasnāt without its controversies. South African scrumhalf Faf de Klerk was yellow carded after his hands brushed across Nic Whiteās face, a questionable Marika Koroibete tackle on Duane Vermeulen went unpunished, while a two-man tackle on Makazole Mapimpi was also questioned.
Richardson branded Williamsā performance as āeither criminally incompetent or evidence of biasā in angry op-ed on the website.
āMarike Koroibete should have been carded for the flying shoulder charge that denied Makazole Mapimpi a try.
āPerhaps the worst incident in the first half was one that brings shame onto the game of rugby.
āWilliams bought into play-acting from Australia scrumhalf Nic White whose actions have no place in the sport at all.ā
He then claimed that both Williams and White ābring the game into disreputeā.
ADVERTISEMENT
Richardson then went on to claim that the official should be banished to the ābush leaguesā for the rest of his whistling career.
āWilliamsā diabolical decision-making robbed the Springboks of momentum and points and changed the nature of the game.
āThis referee has no place taking charge of big games and should be banished to the bush leagues for the rest of his days.ā
He isnāt the first South African to blame the Test loss on officialdom. In fact, itās become something of a pastime in the country where the Springboksā are never seemingly at fault for their defeats.
ADVERTISEMENT
Many believe the phenomenon of ref blaming in the Rainbow Nation has been exacerbated by the antics of current Springboksā director of rugby, Rassie Erasmus, who anchored a 62-minute video in 2021 about referee Nic Berry which became public and massively viral during the British & Irish Lions tour.
Erasmus was banned for his part in the fiasco but it hasnāt seen a decrease in the amount of South Africans who look blame Test losses on officials.
It's a bit disingenuous to say Rassie's video was just band but no mention that the all experts agree the content was correct. Also that the video was leaked and that's why he was band... the ref was caught out in that video and nothing can be said about the validity of his content. There is a serious issue about inconsistent reffing in Rugby we should stick together as Rugby fans to abolish this. We have modern systems and technology to ensure accurate results. Not being able to hold Refs (officials) accountable is a form of authority rule. I guess there are many people including this author who would prefer to defend this as apposed to having a fair and true outcome. Then there would be nothing to complain about and who ever wins on the day is the true winner.
The ref maybe was not the best but that is not why we lost. We were diabolically poor. That is it. The Boks did not deserve to win.
Go Bokke
3 clear (in full view of officials), forceful and reckless direct hits to the head of Springboks, with no mitigation, not sanctioned at all by the match officials. (On Vermeulen, Gelant and De Allende) Wallabies given a licence to harm the Springbok players in this match. I do not recall any match where this has happened before. So Brendon Pickerill and Taul Trianini also show take the chop.
Regardless of whether Williamsā decisions were right or not, Richardson is totally out of line in publishing this. By all means make an assessment of the facts of the disputed decisions, but personal attacks on the individual should not be remotely acceptable. Rugby referees do a tough job, and at most levels they do it without being paid. Those few who are paid and get to take on international games are the ones who have consistently shown that they can make decisions that are consistent with the current interpretation of the Laws.
For what itās worth, as a neutral and amateur ref, I didnāt see much that was obviously wrong. A couple of calls for either wider were harsh or (on replay) incorrect, but not more than usual.
Koroibeteās tackle definitely needed a review, but on review it was very clear that his left arm was in a position to tackle - and it was only the pace of the tackle and the point of contact that stopped him being able to wrap. You then have to add to that that Mapimpi had jumped upwards rather than diving down for the line - an illegal act in itself, and one that changed the point of contact and made the tackle significantly more dangerous for the tackler.
Iāve seen similar tackles penalised as shoulder charges, but Iāve also seen similar tackles accepted as fair (and blatant shoulder charges ignored by refs). Williams looked at the footage and made a decision that was consistent with the prevailing interpretation and what he was seeing. You may disagree with the eventual conclusion, but thereās plenty to justify it. You canāt ask for much more than that from a ref.
The problem is that a forceful face to head charge in this match and 2 shoulder to head charges and the Mapimpi shoulder charge, and 2 dangerous neck rolls were all accepted as fair in this match. Forget the outcome of the match. Explain this from player safety standpoint. Go ahead.
I agree with this analysis. I for one don't understand why this SA writer's angst is news. Whenever SA wins, it is because their athletes are stronger and faster like Olympian gods. When they lose, it's the refs fault. The howling was loud when the Lions won a game in 2021 and Wales won this spring. Standard behavior.
In the US, state athletic associations districts are starting to withhold refs from schools where there is a history of abuse. Having a referee involved in a game is a social contract between the teams/supporters to abide by the decisions made. This abuse of officials is the kind of conspiracy theory that taints the game and makes it something ugly.
Everybody makes mistakes at work. It happens and that's part of the game. SA got outplayed from the opening whistle and a poor call from the ref didn't determine the outcome.
This is so bad that referee Paul Williams should be cited. A truely shocking performance that last the entire match. His positioning was below amateurish and I haven't seen dangerous play of that nature with the potential to seriously injure and possibly end a players career in decades. Williams clearly has a problem managing high level test matches. Nobody in their right mind and who is a fan of world rugby of which I am could in anyway defend that performance by williams, I would have serious concerns if he was refereeing my young sons game of rugby. Shocking stuff really.
I agree with the banned
oh dear ,how sad
Australia deserved the win, If anything the scoreboard was flattering to the boks BUT .... not pleasant when an official is clearly not doing their job. Accountability would be appreciated
Ref was Poor, Bokke where poorer dominated territory and possession but could not cross the line, South Africa's attacking with ball in hand was dismal, we desperately need an proper international level attack coach. Why don't we copy some of the Aussies moves which split us apart. Aussie jugby league moves which are superb š š
I Totally agree with you. Can i just put this out there as well... Jake White got consultants in a year out before the 2007 RWC. He manned up and acknowledged his blind spots and got in Eddie Jones amongst many others. This Bok team has massive attacking potential which is something we could not say of our previous teams, clearly the current management is unable to unlock it... Get out the cheque book, find the best attacking minds in the game, task them to design attacking schemes tailor made for our players. IS THIS NOT OBVIOUS!!!
I'm a kiwi and there were several really poor calls in that game
lol, itās the refs fault again.
Saffy's historically blame the refs because they were so used to refs biased towards them in home series.
Current tactics of slowing games with continuous water (i.e fatigue) breaks is unsporting and brings the game into disrepute.
Rassie and co should be the ones to go !
Actually water breaks have nothing to do with South Africa. If you want to hear thr Kiwis moan about the ref you dont have to look far. Listen to Mehrtens on The Platform after the Mbombela test
And what about Craig Joubert and the 2011 world cup final ? Should he be hanged ?
Firstly it wasnt the final. Secondly it was one decision not multiple
That doesn't mean that they are wrong.