1
Scott Robertson doubles down on reasoning for Hoskins Sotutu's omission
By Ned Lester
Without a doubt, the biggest selection debate that came out of the All Blacks team naming on Monday was the omission of Hoskins Sotutu.
ADVERTISEMENT
The star Blues No. 8 was influential in his team’s Super Rugby Pacific title run, scoring as many tries as any Blues player ever has in a season while again showcasing his remarkable playmaking for a forward.
The All Blacks coaches however have instead opted to select Wallace Sititi, the 21-year-old Chiefs prospect who impressed throughout a breakthrough rookie season under coach Clayton McMillan.
Video Player is loading.
The young gun was quickly tipped as a future All Black as he made his mark on the Super Rugby stage, but a selection ahead of Sotutu in 2024 was largely unexpected.
All Blacks coach Scott Robertson, who was heavily involved in the back row selections along with forwards coach Jason Ryan, emphasised at the team naming that he and the selectors were looking for players who excel on both attack and defence, a statement many interpreted as saying that Sotutu’s defence isn’t up to scratch.
The coach doubled down on that sentiment on Tuesday, while also calling Sotutu a “hell of a player” who was unlucky to miss selection.
“As I mentioned last night, a big focus for me and the team, especially in the loose forwards at the Test level is to be great on both sides of the ball,” the coach told SENZ.
ADVERTISEMENT
“We talk and I had a conversation with him (Sotutu) during the year and asked to see a few things, and we (selectors) had good conversations and we went with somebody else.”
Our first squad of 2024 🖤
Congratulations to all those named for the first time 🫡#AllBlacks pic.twitter.com/0Kw51kNwPG
— All Blacks (@AllBlacks) June 24, 2024
When it comes to Sititi, Robertson was full of praise for not just the youngster’s skill set, but also his mentality.
“Well he picked himself, didn’t he? With those performances. He just rose up to the challenge. In the quarter-final, we thought wow, and then again in the semi and when you’re on the other side of the scoreboard in a final, he led the count on both sides of the ball, playing off slow ball beating players with both feet, there was confirmation in the final.
ADVERTISEMENT
“But, the good thing about him is he can play all three positions, he’s exceptionally quick in the lineout as well and it was just his character and how resilient he is.
“He can get up, working back to get behind the ball when the ball was high, he volunteered to make a couple of tough carries into an absolutely deadset wall. He carried it and we thought ok, that’s a Test footy player.
“Just like his dad, I knew his dad’s shoulders pretty well.”
With six loose forwards selected, Robertson was then asked how he thought the starting trio might come together.
The seven-time Super Rugby champion coach revealed he likes to begin that process with a starting team and work his way backwards, so he did have a clear idea of who is in line to start against England. He was asked specifically about Chiefs captain Luke Jacobson.
“With the loose forwards, the majority of them can play two, maybe three positions, a lot of them are very good around the breakdown, defensive triple actions in that area, and they’ve got a good lineout balance, they’re good leaders, all of them.
“Luke has been exceptional for the Chiefs all year with his consistency, and discipline for the majority of the time and performing at the highest level.
“That mix, with their versatility, you need someone on the bench that can play all three ultimately, so all those things were considered.”
There is no bigger Hoskins Sotutu fan than me. His omission from the All Blacks squad, after a fantastic season with the Blues hurts a lot. The coaches have come out publicly and said they back themselves to get many of the new All Blacks ready for test match level rugby, why then can they not have the same confidence in their abilities to re-build the most skillful loose forward in the country into the mold they require? However as much as it pains me to admit, when I take off the fan boy goggles and look at their selection reasoning in the cold light of day, I realize they have a point, a big point. Off the ball positioning, effort plays on defense, hard tackling, and I mean the old school rattle your teeth Isitolo Maka type defense affectionately referred to as the “Tongan torpedo”. I think Razor and co are looking to bring this back into the All Blacks psyche they want players that can wave the magic wand on attack, and then turn around and deliver bone rattling, truck stopping hits on defense, as Razor said he wants players who work on “both sides of the ball”. I think my man Hoskins finds himself in the same boat that Akira Ioane found himself in under Hansens reign, and I pray he takes the rejection and the coaches advice on board, and fills those shoulders with a bit of extra concrete, tears off a bit of leather with his teeth, and gets down to the business of changing the narrative.
Well said. He can not be far away but I see the selection rationale for those picked. It goes without saying but there are are rich pickings for this current crop of NZ loose forwards.
It's a shocking call and I would’nt be surprised if he considers going elsewhere now. Defence isn't a defining trait of the ABs and hasn't ever held them back. He was worth the risk.
I’ve calmed down a little on the Hoskins omission.
But Perofeta the only outside back that is primarily a full back?
Does this mean he starts at 15 against England?
Beauden Barrett will start at 15 until Will Jordan returns from shoulder surgery for the Rugby Championship.
I’d say Beauden will
He’s named as a 10 but that’s just semantics as the back up to McKenzie
If McKenzie goes down in the first test we would not want Perofeta being thrust in just yet
Hoskyn who?
Hoskyn Sotutu is great on attack in a dominant forward pack, but his around the maul play is a bit “rusty” and his defensive capabilities are not strong.
We all think we are/ should be AB selectors, but …. Razor was carried into the job on our shoulders, now we have to trust him and let him do it his way. I think the last 4 years was really muddled for the ABs, I'm really looking forward to seeing how Razor's team plays.
The All Blacks have always been coached by some dumb ass that can’t select properly.
It’s tradition.
They need to be told by us.
Did you give the same advice when Foster was in charge? The rules are the same for each coach - win - regardless of reputation.
Razor was appointed by the predominantly Crusader Head Office, without job appointments or interviews, against protocol and normal procedures. Not everyone is fine with this process!
For anyone who has questioned Razor’s non-selection of Sotutu then there you have it. We’ll just have to accept it and move on.
And he has provided a great summary of Sititi’s performances of the Super Rugby finals, especially the grand final. He was the clear standout forward in the losing team that was completely dominated.
So the player who has performed so well all season makes way for a 21 yo with little experience and a few “flashy” games at seasons end? Luke Jacobson can play three positions too but the player who should be focused on is Blackadder. Hardly able to play three games in a row without breaking and like his Dad has little real impact when it counts.
Clearly more than player ability at play here. My suspicions point to the forwards coach. Some coaches don’t seem to know how to deal with Polynesian players? Some history there too.