1
'Serious controversy here': Quins' win questioned as Bath make report
By Ian Cameron
It looks like Harelquins’ thrilling 40-36 Gallagher Premiership victory over Bath could yet be marred by controversy after a complaint has been made that a player returned to the field before his sin-binning had elapsed.
ADVERTISEMENT
Despite trailing significantly, Bath staged a remarkable comeback in the latter half sparked by tries from Will Muir, Alfie Barbeary and others.
However, Bath’s attempt to snatch a victory from the jaws of defeat may have been partially thwarted by the presence of a sin-binned player on the pitch, giving the hosts an unfair advantage.
Video Player is loading.
According to the television time clock, it appears that second-row replacement Irne Herbst, who was carded at 63 minutes, was back on the pitch and playing just eight minutes later, completing a clearout out at a ruck at 71 minutes.
Rugby Inside Line wrote on X: “There could be some serious controversy here. 63:52 – Herbst yellow carded 71:52 – Yellow card still says 3:18 71:58 – Herbst makes the tackle and clears out the ruck If the TV clocks are correct he is on the pitch two minutes early… Potentially huge ramifications.”
There could be some serious controversy here.
63:52 – Herbst yellow carded
71:52 – Yellow card still says 3:18
71:58 – Herbst makes the tackle and clears out the ruck
If the TV clocks are correct he is on the pitch two minutes early…
Potentially huge ramifications. pic.twitter.com/CafBIoWHuy
— RugbyInsideLine (@RugbyInsideLine) March 30, 2024
ADVERTISEMENT
Bath director of rugby Johann van Graan says he was aware of the incident and has reported it to match officials, implying that he expects something will come of the matter.
‘Ja, it seemed like it,” said Van Graan when asked by TNT Sports about whether or not a player had returned early from the bin. “We flagged it to the referee afterwards so I’ll trust the process.”
In the second weekend in a row that Gallagher Premiership officials have been thrown into the spotlight, following last weekend’s TMO audio faux pas during last weekend’s Harelquins loss to Saracens.
Former England international Austin Healey, who was working as part of TNT Sports’ team at the match, spotted a clear-out by Harlequins captain Stephan Lewies, when he appeared to slide on his knees into Saracens fly-half Owen Farrell.
ADVERTISEMENT
And TMO Stuart Terheege was overheard telling referee Christophe Ridley on a microphone during the live broadcast: “The problem I have got now is that it looks like Austin has instigated it, because we’re late, so I don’t want to talk about it, okay?”
Lewies had received a yellow card during the first-half of a game that Saracens won 52-7 at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium.
additional reporting PA
I've read 3 articles about this so far and the only person defending the mistake below every one of them is BigMaul.
This was not a refereeing mistake, as the ref didn't even know. It was a mistake by other officials for which there was no excuse. If an official can't read a clock counting down from 10 minutes, step aside and let someone else do it.
I’ve not defended the mistake at any point. I’ve just pointed out the mistake was made by the officiating team, not by Harlequins or Herbst.
I’ve not made any excuses for the mistake. It’s very poor from the officials.
There are several keyboard warriors who are either ill informed or just trying to cause trouble (such as yourself) claiming Harlequins should be sanctioned for an error made by the officials. Clearly, that’s a dumb take.
Harlequins shouldn’t be sanctioned for an error made by the officials.
Not sure what controversy or ramifications are implied here.
The ref made a mistake. Happens every game.
Yeh, well maybe it's time they stopped turning a blind eye if it's to stop happening every game.