Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

South Africa player ratings versus New Zealand

New Zealand's Sevu Reece is tackled by three South African players in Yokohama (Photo by Adam Pretty/Getty Images)

The Springboks’ World Cup opener was certainly not the result Rassie Erasmus wanted. South Africa started their World Cup campaign with a 23-13 defeat to the All Blacks on Saturday.

ADVERTISEMENT

15. Willie le Roux – 4/10

It was certainly a performance below his standards.  The full-back was horrendous under the high ball and failed to prove a threat on attack, leaving much of the counter-attack responsibility in the hands of Cheslin Kolbe.

14. Cheslin Kolbe – 8

The standout performer in the Springboks team. His ability to read the game continues to carry the ineffective backline. The livewire wing instigated the Boks’ first try with a lethal line break and he had a few try-scoring opportunities, but mostly found himself alone without any support runners.

13. Lukhanyo Am – 5 

Showed some skills with ball in hand but was not very influential on the attack. He was replaced with Jesse Kriel just short of the hour mark.

12. Damian de Allende – 7 

Made a couple of strong runs and also managed to produce a few crucial tackles. On one or two occasions he was a little bit selfish but overall a good performance by the centre.

ADVERTISEMENT

(Continue reading below…)

11. Makazole Mapimpi – 4

One of the team’s weakest members. His defence remains a very vulnerable aspect of his play and managed to escape a sanction for his tackle on Richie Mo’unga.

10. Handré Pollard – 5

Not the best of kicking displays by the pivot. He struggled in the first half – missing an easy penalty kick which shifted the momentum of the match. However, he tried to make up for in the second half with a drop goal. But overall the No10 was very below par. He certainly needs more responsibility to control the game and show his prowess.

ADVERTISEMENT

9. Faf de Klerk – 5 

Over-utilised the box kicks, which most of the time failed to reach the target. In the second half, he made two snipping runs from the breakdown. However, the dreadful loose pass which Richie Mo’unga perfectly snapped up for the All Blacks first score summed up his performance.

8. Duane Vermeulen – 7

The No8 was an absolute beast, making powerful carries and having a massive impact on defence. His stats also included a couple of steals at the breakdown. He further produced two perfectly-timed tackles on Aaron Smith at the ruck.

7. Pieter-Steph du Toit – 6

A very uncharacteristic performance by the flanker, even if the ITV TV commentator in the UK begged to differ (see above Tweet). He conceded two unforced penalties, but was more involved in the second half and scored the team’s only try.

6. Siya Kolisi – 5 

He left the field after just after 50 minutes, the pace of the game certainly catching the captain off-guard as he hasn’t played a full 80 minutes since injuring his leg about four months ago. He made some solid carries but wasn’t very effective.

5. Franco Mostert – 8

One of the unsung heroes. He did a lot of the donkey work and showed how valuable he is the Springboks team making twelve tackles, nine carries and produced a stunning lineout steal on the South African 22.

4. Eben Etzebeth – 7 

Strong with his tackles, he only missed one and he was also very disciplined despite the intensity of the match.

3. Frans Malherbe – 6

The prop put Joe Moody under huge pressure during scrums. However, other facets of his game remained a little average and he were replaced after just 54 minutes of play.


2. Malcolm Marx – 6

The hooker was effective but certainly not spectacular. His lineout throws reached the intended target, which was encouraging.

1. Steven Kitshoff – 7

Just like fellow prop Malherbe, Kitshoff got the better of the New Zealand pack. He won the early the penalty which handed the Boks the 3-0 lead and he was constantly seeking work all over the park

Replacements:

16. Bongi Mbonambi – 5 (on for Marx, 60 mins)

Didn’t bring the energy expected.

17. Tendai Mtawarira – NR (on for Kitshoff, 67 mins)

Not enough time to be rated.

18. Trevor Nyakane – 6 (on for Malherbe, 54 mins)

Came on to continued the dominance in the scrums. Unfortunately, his campaign might be over as he left the field with an injury.

19. Rudolph Snyman – NR (on for Etzebeth, 69 mins)

Not enough to be rated

20. Francois Louw – 7 (on for Kolisi, 50 mins)

Tackled well and was a menace at the breakdown.

21. Herschel Jantjies – NR (on for de Klerk, 71 mins)

Not enough to be rated.

22. Frans Steyn – NR

Not used.

23. Jesse Kriel – 6 (on for Am, 54 mins)

Made a couple of decisive breaks and added much-needed physicality in midfield.

– rugby365.com

WATCH: Rassie Erasmus talks to the media following South Africa’s loss in Yokohoma

ADVERTISEMENT

Kubota Spears vs Saitama Wild Knights | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

The gruelling reality behind one of the fastest sports in the world | The Report

Boks Office | Episode 40 | The Steven Kitshoff Special

Perry Baker in the house | HSBC Life on Tour | Los Angeles

O2 Inside Line: All In | Episode 6 | Le Crunch

The Unexpected Journey to USA 7s Glory | Aaron Cummings | Sevens Wonders

USA vs Japan | Full Match Replay

Yokohama Canon Eagles vs Shizuoka BlueRevs | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

Confidence knocks and finding your people | Flo Williams | Rugby Rising Locker Room

Tackling reasons for drop-out in sport | Zainab Alema | Rugby Rising Locker Room

Jet Lag: The biggest challenge facing international sports? | The Report

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

M
Mzilikazi 10 minutes ago
As the balance of power shifts away from Ireland, has Andy Farrell got his Lions calls right?

I did not think there would have been such a big Irish contingent, and must admit I am surprised by some of the selections. For example injury has taken Hanson back a long way in my opinion, and would agree with the comments on Darcy Graham being the better player over the past year.


Ryan also surprises me. I recall a couple of years before the last Lions tour, out to SA, he was being talked of as a possible captain. He then lost form, and was not selected. I don’t feel he has ever fully met the early hopes many of us would have had for him. Not even a first choice for Ireland.


I am happy to see the second Irish hooker in the squad. I highly rate Kelleher, but would concede George is very unlucky…fine player, good leader. And very happy to see Conan going….very smart player, who from all accounts has had to work very hard to get to the level he is at. Was never a noted school boy star. Interestingly, neither was van der Flier.


I’m not convinced Itoje will be a good captain. Very good lineout technican, but has tended to be a very niggly type of player, and concedes a lot of penalties. For example saw him put in a silly shoulder block off the ball playing for Saracens against Sale. He can also have games where is ineffective for periods. Not sure how he would go if it were the ABs or Boks, not that I’m writing the WB’s off as having no chance.


Despite my Irish heritage, neither am I happy to see Sexton in the coaching team. The Prendergast of the coaching world ? Would have thought he should have some time as a coach at some level before being so elevated.

74 Go to comments
R
Ronan Furlong 26 minutes ago
As the balance of power shifts away from Ireland, has Andy Farrell got his Lions calls right?

“Why did England beat France but Ireland concede over 40 at home to the same opponents?”


Because France embarrassingly butchered the match against England by playing their worst game in about 4 years, and because the wounded real France turned up in Dublin a few weeks later with pride on the line.


I’m not basing my theory around the current Leinster …. I’m basing my theory around Kelleher being better than George at playing as an edge forward a la Sheehan (which is what Faz wants - hence no Dewi Lake either). I’m basing my theory on the absolute stupidity of anyone (like you) thinking Wainwright is a better 8 than Conan. I'm basing my theory on the stupidity of you wanting to take an unavailable Martin over James Ryan.


By the way, the “current Leinster” you're so happy to deride, are top of the URC and reached this years Euro semi finals, just like Saints. I didn’t notice any other English teams in the semis, did you? Are Sarries, Leceister, Quins, Sale et al not as good as Leinster? Presumably, by your logic, that means they are also overrepresented in the lions squad? Or does performance in Europe only matter for lions selection when Leinster lose by 4 points (as opposed to Leicester and Quins getting utterly embarrassed by URC teams?)


Let’s see how Saints get on against Bordeaux shall we? If they lose by more than Munster and Ulster lost to Bordeaux, should we be rethinking the inclusion of so many Saints players?


Of course not, as only an idiot would drop an entire cohort of players due to one lost game now, wouldn’t they?


p.s. I’m not surprised you’re welsh and cheering for England, as it’s a common 'Stockholm Syndrome’ trait from where you’re from. I'm a

little more surprised at your overt, small man bias against Leinster.


p.p.s Hansen is the lucky Irish player in the squad, no one else. But being from Connacht, he doesn’t fit your narrative does he? Partly because even you can't find a remotely deserving fit English or Welsh winger to replace him, can you?

74 Go to comments
M
Maria Zambrano 1 hour ago
As the balance of power shifts away from Ireland, has Andy Farrell got his Lions calls right?

HIRE A GENUINE CRYPTO RECOVERY SERVICE TRACE HACKER'S CRYPTO RECOVERY

Maria Zambrano had always been cautious with her money, but the promise of high returns from an online investment platform proved too tempting to resist.

Lured in by professional-looking websites and testimonials, he invested a total of $500,000 worth of Bitcoin, convinced he had found a legitimate opportunity.

However, within weeks, communication with the company became sparse, withdrawal requests were ignored, and soon, the platform disappeared altogether.

Maria Zambrano realized I have fallen victim to an elaborate online investment scam.

Devastated but unwilling to give up, I began searching for recovery options. After coming across TRACE HACKER'S CRYPTO RECOVERY, a firm specializing in recovering lost cryptocurrency,I decided to reach out. From the first consultation, the team displayed professionalism and expertise, explaining the recovery process and using advanced blockchain tracking tools to trace the stolen Bitcoin.TRACE HACKER'S CRYPTO RECOVERY specialists conducted an in-depth investigation, identified the fraudsters’ transaction patterns, and leveraged their connections with cybersecurity experts and legal authorities. Within weeks, they managed to freeze a portion of the stolen funds before they were laundered through multiple wallets. Through persistence and legal channels, TRACE HACKER'S CRYPTO RECOVERY successfully reclaimed $500,000 worth of Bitcoin and returned it to me Overwhelmed with relief, I realized the importance of working with a trusted recovery firm.

My experience serves as a cautionary tale for others while online investments can be enticing, due diligence is crucial.

Thanks to TRACE HACKER'S CRYPTO RECOVERY, he got a second chance at financial security.

If you’ve lost funds to an online scam, TRACE HACKER'S CRYPTO RECOVERY may be able to help you too.

Email:support @ tracehackerscryptorecovery. com

Email: info @ tracehackerscryptorecovery. com

Whatsapp: +447 35570 2876

Website:https:// tracehackers cryptorecovery. com/

74 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Andy Farrell explains why Marcus Smith beat Owen Farrell to a Lions spot Andy Farrell explains why Smith beat Owen Farrell to a Lions spot
Search