1
South Africans rugby teams aren't helping themselves in Europe
What’s the opposite of exploding out of the blocks? Last week, in the opening round of continental domestic rugby, South Africa’s five teams added fuel to the argument that none of them belong on European pitches and are directly to blame for a once great competition bloating beyond recognition.
ADVERTISEMENT
The Bulls, apparently the country’s best hope of securing a Champions Cup semi-final berth, got stuffed by Saracens in torrid conditions in north-west London. The Stormers dropped a clanger on home turf and were beaten by a double-digit score by Toulon despite leading after 57 minutes. In the Challenge Cup the Lions were undone by 16 points at Ospreys, a team that sits third-last on the URC table, while the Cheetahs could only manage a home draw against French strugglers Perpignan.
Thank goodness, then, for the Sharks who claimed a 39-21 win over Exeter Chiefs at Kings’s Park. Well, not quite. The Sharks fielded 10 Springboks in the starting XV and played three more off the bench. Exeter had to travel around 24 hours from Devon to Durban and arrived on South Africa’s east coast having lost all seven of their Premiership games this season. This should have been a cricket score. For their coach, Rob Baxter, to say after the game that his team “blew” a golden chance for a win shows how tight this really was.
If this sounds harsh then consider the rancour that South African clubs and their supporters have had to face for the past few years. When news broke that the Saffas would have a seat at Europe’s top table it was met with disdain and suspicion. England’s World Cup-winning coach, Sir Clive Woodward, called the decision “brainless”. France’s great wing, Philippe Saint-Andre, said it was “rubbish” and a “complete aberration”. Joe Marler snidely told TNT Sport,“You want to talk about Europe and we’re going to Natal Sharks next week, which is where? In South Africa.”
South African rugby supporters have largely brushed this all aside and met these quips and quibbles with shrugged shoulders. After all, just about every successful side in Champions Cup history has benefited from South African muscle. The great dynastic outfits of Toulon and Saracens that dominated the competition between 2013 and 2019 had more than their fair share.
The backlash to South African participation in a tournament sponsored by a South African company has largely been viewed as gatekeeping with more than a whiff of first-world xenophobia. Well of course they wouldn’t want the South Africans, those snobbish Brits and Francs. Something, something World Rugby conspiracy theory. Something, something Rassie Erasmus. Something, something four World Cups. They hate us cos they ain’t us, and all that.
I played up to this myself. Almost two years ago to the day I wrote that much of this apprehension was “rooted in a previous age where moustachioed imperialists divided the globe with rulers on a map.” I insinuated that critics, whether they knew it or not, were peddling an old colonial and anti-African sentiment, one that espoused an old theory that men raised on the continent’s southern tip had no place in civilised company.
ADVERTISEMENT
Not that it mattered, though. Soon enough the five clubs would prove their worth on the pitch. Just like the Springboks they’d show that they belonged. And even though the Bulls sent a C-team to Northampton in last season’s Champions Cup quarterfinals, and even though the Stormers lost a thriller by a single point to La Rochelle in the round before, the Sharks’ celebratory reactions to winning the Challenge Cup showed that this meant something to the players. They’d had a taste of the side dish. Now it was time to take a stab at the main course.
Which is why this past weekend was such a disappointment. If these teams aren’t going to prove that they do indeed belong, that they are able to mix it with the development sides of Ireland, France and Scotland, er, I mean, Leinster, Toulouse and Glasgow Warriors, then what is the point? The toll this new format is taking on the environment cannot be ignored. All this criss-crossing of the globe, all that carbon emitted, has to be off-set by more than just carbon credits. We need trophies and famous wins in Dublin and the south of France. There has to be something to show for all the pushback and spats on social media.
Onto this weekend then and the chance to set things right. The Bulls have an opportunity to exact revenge on the team that knocked them out last season. Northampton Saints are not quite the swashbuckling outfit that lifted the Premiership title and are there for the taking.
ADVERTISEMENT
The Sharks and Stormers have tricky ties in England but will back themselves to do the business against Leicester and Harlequins respectively. The Tigers are on a two-game losing run having been well-beaten by Sale Sharks and Bordeaux Bègles while Quins are in the midst of one of their trademark inconsistent periods. Both are beatable.
The Lions players and coaches have had the good fortune of sleeping in their own beds this week and will welcome Pau to Johannesburg on Saturday. Ellis Park won’t be full but it’ll still be 1,753 metres above sea level which could be the difference in the closing stages of the contest. The Cheetahs are the least likely winners as they head north to Cardiff. And though they won’t be expected to win, they are just the sort of group that could spring a surprise.
Three wins from five matches; that is what should be demanded by the South African public. Looking further ahead, a semi-final place should be the minimum requirement from at least one South African team. Anything else should be regarded as a failure.
Rugby’s best of the best, ranked by experts. Check out our list of the Top 100 Men's Rugby Players and let us know what you think!
There is way too much rugby. The URC should be a round-robin, and the Premiership a flat league (not going to mention the French because they seem intent on doing their own thing).
This would make the Champions and Challenge Cup more meaningful. The result would be bigger audiences at the games because they would become calendar highlights for the fans, not repetitive events. Rivalry will build because a loss will sit in the dark chambers of supporters hearts for a long time. Stop making rugby for the networks and start making it for the fans
Good article Daniel with the right questions asked for a change in particular ito of environmental impact and carbon emissions. This format is totally absurd on that point of view and this week end results show that it doesn't even make sense on the plain rugby side.
Saffa teams can't win away in any way, shape ornform. They'll get destroyed as they aren't used to playing in superior NH comps.
This is just the norm for SA franchises. Unlike their national side, they just all lack ambition and innovation.
Exactly the opposite of the French.
I read where England is wanting Ireland and Wales to form a comp and get SA teams out. It will be interesting to see where this goes in the next couple of years. Lose and the SA teams will be rubbished, Win and they will be hated. Lose lose for them..... They could only manage 3 wins in SR in 20+ years.
The Irish condition to the RFU reportedly is that the SA and Italian sides are not dropped (and the SRU also backs that). England are less keen on that idea, because it would very much make them the junior partner in any merger.
The Welsh teams leaving the URC to merge into a new Premiership is the most likely mooted change (maybe 25% chance in next few years), but the break up of URC itself seems unlikely.
Especially in Ireland, the matches against South African teams are popular, and seen as good for irish development and making URC more exciting.
These kinds of rumours get bandied around every year. I wouldn't put any real faith in them.
SARU isn’t going to pass up the EPCR rewards available and while it’s going to take a little time to get accustomed, I’ve got no doubt the Boks teams will get there soon enough. Much as they are doing in the URC, remember how poorly they fared in the early games/tours, and look how they’re performing now. EPCR is a step up from the URC and as the logistics playing field starts to even itself out and their game experience grows, they will compete and no doubt, at times, prevail.
Time to bring the boys back home, we have plenty competition here to keep us sharp and competitive enough to win RWCs.
ha!